10

Loading video...

Kaitlin Lewis

By Kaitlin Lewis

Night Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Michael Cohen has faced back-to-back days of grueling cross-examination by Donald Trump's defense team in the former president's business fraud case, with Trump's attorneys repeatedly accusing Cohen of admitting to committing perjury on the witness stand.

Cohen, a key witness in the former president's civil fraud trial, took the witness stand again Wednesday morning after a brief but heated cross-examination Tuesday by Trump's lawyer, Alina Habba. Habba accused Cohen of being a repeat liar and attempted to get Cohen to admit to lying in past criminal trials, according to those who reported from the New York courtroom.

Trump has denied any wrongdoing in the $250 million fraud lawsuit brought against him by New York Attorney General Letitia James, and on Tuesday accused Cohen of stating "lie after lie" during his testimony. Cohen, a former attorney who was once considered Trump's fixer, pleaded guilty in 2018 to a number of political and financial crimes related to hush-money payments made to adult film star Stormy Daniels.

Read More

Michael Cohen Mocks Trump After Giving Evidence: ‘If a Photo Could Speak’3 min read

Michael Cohen Mocks Trump After Giving Evidence: ‘If a Photo Could Speak’

Jenna Ellis Breaks Silence After Pleading Guilty4 min read

Jenna Ellis Breaks Silence After Pleading Guilty

Ivanka Trump Trying To Save Jared Kushner From Giving Evidence—Attorney4 min read

Ivanka Trump Trying To Save Jared Kushner From Giving Evidence—Attorney

Did Michael Cohen Perjure Himself in TrumpTrial?

...

Trump's Defense Team Again Tries to Catch Cohen In A Lie

According to reporting on X, formerly Twitter, by Adam Klasfeld, a senior legal correspondent at The Messenger, Cohen's second day of testimony started off with more questions from Habba about his previous 2018 guilty plea. The Trump attorney particularly narrowed in on Cohen's statement on Tuesday that he lied when he admitted to tax evasion crimes to Judge William Pauley.

New York attorney general attorney Colleen Faherty eventually objected to Habba's questioning, Klasfeld reported, calling the repetition "a little bit of a circus." Trump lawyer Christopher Kise chipped in, saying Cohen's answers were the "circus."

"In open court, he has now admitted to perjury in front of Judge Pauley," Kise said, according to Klasfeld.

After Faherty objected to the assertion, New York Judge Arthur Engoron, who is overseeing Trump's case, responded: "Well, that's the definition of perjury, lying under oath."

ABC News reported that Engoron told Trump's attorneys to not use the word perjury while questioning Cohen, but Habba prompted the former lawyer again to clarify that Tuesday "was the first time you admitted in open court that you lied to Judge Pauley?"

"In open court, yes," Cohen responded.

How Cohen's Past Lies Relate to Trump's Fraud Case

According to former federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani, even if Cohen has perjured himself on the witness stand, it's "unlikely anything comes of it."

"Perjury is often threatened, but rarely prosecuted," Rahmani told Newsweek via email.

"The statute of limitations may have run on Cohen's alleged false statements, and it's unlikely federal prosecutors charge Cohen for walking back his admissions during his guilty plea," he wrote. "Convicted felons deny their crimes all the time, even after pleading guilty."

"More than anything, this is impeachment evidence," Rahmani added. "Cohen's statements are inconsistent at best, or lies at worst, and undermine his credibility during the defense's cross-examination."

Michael McAuliffe, a former federal prosecutor and ex-elected state attorney in Florida, told Newsweek that it was "entirely predictable" that Trump's defense team was focusing on Cohen's history of lying, but noted that "the lies Cohen has acknowledged and been punished for overwhelmingly relate to his activities for Donald Trump."

"As such, Cohen's previous lies fit the overall story he's telling the public and the judge in the ongoing civil fraud trial––that Cohen was the hatchet and enforcer for Trump and did Trump's bidding on many fronts including valuation fraud," McAuliffe wrote via email Wednesday.

"It is highly unlikely Cohen is exposing himself to any new charges in testifying about his past criminal conduct and false statements," McAuliffe added.

Norman Eisen, a legal analyst and former U.S. ambassador to the Czech Republic, echoed in a phone call to Newsweek that it was an "obvious line of attack" on Habba's part to go after Cohen's history of lying, but noted that he believed Cohen "has been carrying it well" on the witness stand thus far.

"Michael pled to some things he did do and some things he felt he didn't do," Eisen said, speaking of Cohen's guilty plea in 2018. "The only choice he had when confronted with that on the stand was to honestly say that he felt he had not done that. Of all the bad choices, that was the best."

"I think that...the judge will understand that often when you have cooperating witnesses, they have a prior history of dishonesty," Eisen continued. "And here, Cohen had a good reason for it and the government will bring that out on its redirect of him."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines