sameule jenkins and legend jenkins

...

Joshua Rhett Miller

By Joshua Rhett Miller

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A North Carolina district attorney is defending his decision to prosecute a couple whose 7-year-old son was fatally struck by an SUV while walking to the store with his brother, insisting it could prevent similar tragedies.

Gaston County District Attorney Travis Page explained his charging decision Thursday in the prosecution against Sameule Jenkins and Jessica Ivey, whose son, Legend Jenkins, died on May 27 after he was struck and killed as he stepped off the median of a busy street near their Gastonia home. The driver, a 76-year-old woman, was not charged.

The couple, initially charged with involuntary manslaughter and felony child abuse, later pleaded guilty to the latter count and received suspended prison sentences along with years of probation, Page announced in June.

Read More on U.S.

sameule jenkins and legend jenkins

...

The case took on new prominence when it was featured in a New York Times op-ed published this week about the intersection of pedestrian safety, suburban sprawl and childhood freedom.

'Free-Range' Parenting or Criminal Negligence?

The district attorney defended his actions when reached Thursday by Newsweek, referring to previous instances of what he characterized as "criminal parental negligence," including the 2022 shooting death of 4-year-old Michael Ben Mendoza that led to charges against three people, including his parents.

"We have brought similar prosecutions in other situations involving criminal parental negligence — leaving a loaded gun out in the open for a sister to grab it and shoot her brother," Page explained.

Page has also filed charges against a mother whose infant overdosed after finding a stash of fentanyl, he said.

"Often, our criminal justice system is asked to address cases that involve greater societal issues — poor education, poverty, homelessness," Page told Newsweek in a statement. "Our system can be a way of connecting people in need to the services that might benefit them and change their lives — we do that with our treatment courts every month."

Jenkins and Ivey did not deserve prison time, Page added.

travis page

...

"Which is why we quickly worked to find a resolution that would hopefully allow them to work under supervision with social services and ensure a similar tragedy doesn't happen again," the district attorney said.

In June, Page said his heart was "broken" that a young boy would grow up without a brother, while the driver will never forget the sounds and image of the horrific accident.

"There is no prison or punishment worse than a parent living with the knowledge their decision-making and their actions caused the harm of their own child," Page said in a statement. "These parents do not deserve prison — they need mercy, they need grace, and they need a community to support them and other struggling parents in hopes that a tragedy such as this will never happen again."

Jenkins, 31, said he was "outraged" by Page's decision to prosecute him and his wife, and that their felony convictions will still make their livelihoods more difficult even without the threat of prison time.

"I really didn't understand it," Jenkins told Newsweek. "I've seen many cases since my arrest that have some of the similar facts and they weren't charged. I just don't think it's fair at all."

Jenkins complained about the ankle monitor he wore Thursday as part of his post-conviction conditions while explaining he was having a tough time finding a job as a convicted felon.

"I'm struggling with finding employment because of the recent felony," he said. "There's no company trying to hire me at the moment."

Jenkins received three years of probation, while his wife received 30 months, he said.

Questions of Race and Class

The father of six, who is Black, also questioned whether race factored into the decision to prosecute him and his wife, who is white.

"I really do and everybody I speak to about the matter, they feel the same way," Jenkins said when asked about a possible racial component to his prosecution. "I feel like they used my son's death as an opportunity to further mess my record up."

Jenkins called on North Carolina Gov. Josh Stein to pardon both he and his wife as they complete their probation, insisting they should not be penalized for allowing their young sons to walk outside without supervision.

"That's crazy," he said. "My son, that was an accident. We had all our kids at that time; we just made the decision to trust them with their independence. By sending a parent to prison, I don't feel like that's in any way helping out with parenting."

A message seeking comment from Stein's office was not immediately returned Thursday.

Page, meanwhile, downplayed critics of his decision to prosecute the couple, including some online who claimed the district attorney "preferred cars over mixed race children." The driver of the Jeep Cherokee that struck Legend, who could not be reached for comment Thursday, said she did not see the boy step onto the road in front of her, according to the police report.

Sameule Jenkins and Jessica Ivey

...

"It's easy and unfortunately common for folks to cast judgment without knowing everything — but they deserve grace too," Page said. "While I realize there are new challenges for at least one of the parents, I think that must be weighed against the challenges that others will now feel as a result of a completely preventable tragedy. I have also publicly asked our community to support this family, and other struggling families, to prevent future tragedies."

Matt Hawkins, a public defender who represents Ivey, said prosecutors showed more lenience to the father of a 10-year-old Gaston County girl who was fatally shot by another child in April after he allegedly left a gun unsecured.

"Although the father in that instance has been charged, his bond was set at $50,000 and he posted that bond in 27 minutes, compared to Ms. Ivey who was initially issued a $1.5 million bond and sat in jail until she entered a plea," Hawkins told Newsweek in a statement.

Hawkins said he believed the decision to charge Ivey was based largely on her explanation to police that she made a conscious decision to let the boys walk home by themselves.

"It's an extremely busy street, so in combination with Ms. Ivey's initial statement, the prosecutor believed this to be a willful omission in parenting that showed a reckless disregard for life," Hawkins said. "To be clear, based on the information that was originally at hand, I have a hard time faulting anyone for the initial charges."

Hawkins said he had concerns about how Ivey was treated following her arrest just before Legend's funeral. Her bond was later reduced to $150,000.

"This is still impossible for a person in her position to post," he said. "She was unemployed, living in Section 8 housing, with seven children. She was then issued, after only a few weeks, an offer to plead guilty to the felony child abuse charge, but she would receive supervised probation."

Since being with her children represented Ivey's top concern, she took the plea deal, Hawkins said.

"My ultimate question to the district attorney was, what if my client wasn't poor?" Hawkins continued.

"What if she was able to post this bond? Would she have felt inclined to accept a plea at such an early stage just so she could be released and be with her family? Probably not, in my opinion."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines