10

Loading video...

Sam Stevenson

By Sam Stevenson

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump’s approval rating moved in sharply different directions among America’s lowest- and highest-income voters across three recent polls in the same Echelon Insights series.

His net approval improved by 26 points among those earning under $30,000 between September and November, while falling 18 points among people making at least $125,000.

The apparent divergence followed midterm elections dominated by economic concerns, though experts told Newsweek that small income samples could make the results volatile.

Read More on Politics

“Shifts of this magnitude are rare in public opinion,” Costas Panagopoulos, a distinguished professor of political science at Northeastern University, told Newsweek.

“When you’re zooming in on specific subgroups of respondents like this, because of limited sample sizes, these dramatic differences could be statistical noise rather than true, meaningful shifts in preferences.”

David Barker, a professor of government at American University, described the pattern as “fascinating” but said it “defies easy explanation” and could simply reflect “random noise.”

The White House defended Trump’s record, pointing to his administration’s tax, border, health care, employment and trade policies.

Spokesman Davis Ingle told Newsweek that Trump would “never stop delivering results for the American people” and predicted that he would “go down as the most successful and consequential president in American history.”

Three Polls Show Opposing Movements

The September Echelon Insights survey found that 23 percent of respondents in households earning under $30,000 approved of Trump’s performance, while 75 percent disapproved, producing a net rating of minus 52.

Among those with household incomes of $125,000 or more, 41 percent approved and 58 percent disapproved, putting him at minus 17.

That poll questioned 1,002 voters in the likely electorate from September 17 to 21 and had an overall margin of sampling error of plus or minus 3.6 percentage points.

In October, approval in the lower bracket rose to 33 percent as disapproval declined to 65 percent, narrowing the deficit to 32 points. The wealthier group divided 41 percent to 57 percent, leaving Trump at minus 16.

Fieldwork was conducted among 1,010 likely voters from October 15 to 19, with a margin of error of plus or minus 3.6 points.

November produced the sharpest separation. Lower-income respondents registered 36 percent approval and 62 percent disapproval, compared with 32 percent and 67 percent respectively among the highest earners.

Panagopoulos noted that Trump nevertheless remained underwater with both groups, meaning disapproval still exceeded approval in each.

The nationwide survey covered 1,027 registered voters in the likely electorate from November 12 to 16 and carried an overall margin of error of plus or minus 3.7 points.

President Donald Trump speaks in the James S. Brady Press Briefing Room of the White House on November 09, 2026 in Washington, DC.

...

Across the full sample, 36 percent approved of Trump’s job performance and 63 percent disapproved.

Those published margins apply to each complete survey, not the much smaller income categories.

“If it’s a sample of a thousand people, now you’re talking about 150 or 200 people, and it’s probably even lower than that,” Panagopoulos said by way of illustration.

Thomas Gift, an associate professor of political science and director of the Centre on U.S. Politics at University College London, said people at both ends of the income scale can be particularly difficult to survey.

“Income subgroups, especially very high- and very low-income populations, tend to be hard to survey, and their smaller sample size makes them susceptible to bias with very large margins of error,” he told Newsweek.

“If the trends hold up after multiple surveys, I’d be more inclined to believe that what we’re seeing here is a meaningful change in approval ratings for different income cohorts,” Gift said. “However, until then, this could just be noise.”

Barker said “a lot” of caution was warranted when comparing income subgroups across three separate surveys. “One really shouldn’t draw any hard conclusions,” he told Newsweek, although he said it was reasonable to identify the pattern as preliminary evidence deserving closer examination.

A stronger test would involve panel data, in which the same respondents are interviewed repeatedly, rather than comparing separate samples of voters from one month to another, Barker said.

The distinction is important because changes in the composition of each income group could create the appearance of movement even if few individual voters had changed their minds about Trump

President Donald Trump attends a meeting of the Quad group in Manila on November 17, 2026.

...

What Could Explain A Genuine Shift?

Panagopoulos said that, if the pattern proves real, Republican efforts to persuade working-class families during the midterm campaign may have reinforced favorable attitudes toward Trump among some lower earners.

Higher-income voters paying closer attention as Election Day approached could meanwhile have formed more negative assessments of the president’s economic record.

“If there was meaningful change within these subgroups, it seems to me that some of these things going on over this period might have had a differential impact on each of these subgroups of voters,” Panagopoulos said.

Barker also said campaign dynamics were the first potential explanation that came to mind. Political advertising and campaign messaging often attempt to “bring voters home” by reminding Republican and Democratic voters of their partisan identities and encouraging them to vote accordingly, he said.

“Most people don’t pay attention to politics until campaign season, when all the ads etc. remind them,” Barker told Newsweek.

Given the present partisan divide, he said, that process could have reminded higher earners why they opposed Trump while having the opposite effect among lower-income voters more sympathetic to him.

That interpretation would suggest the movement was driven less by a sudden change in material circumstances than by voters becoming more politically attentive as the election approached.

Juven Jacob, a political strategist and founder of Juven Capitol Strategies who previously served as a presidential appointee and congressional staffer, suggested Trump’s campaign-trail proposal for $5,000 checks could have gained traction with people struggling to cover immediate expenses.

“The same squeeze that makes voters unhappy about prices can make a promise of direct relief more compelling,” Jacob told Newsweek. “If you’re juggling work and bills, it’s easy to picture what $5,000 could cover.”

However, he said researchers would need to know whether respondents had heard the proposal, expected to qualify and believed the payments would materialize before assigning it explanatory weight.

Gift said that drawing a direct connection between the figures and stock-market movements or the different economic experiences of income groups would be “highly speculative.”

He added: “I’d be hesitant to make these conclusions without survey questions that explicitly ask about these perceptions.”

Barker said a stock-market explanation was plausible, particularly as a potential factor in the decline among higher-income respondents, but added that there was not enough evidence to make that connection definitively.

President Donald Trump descends from Air Force One after arriving at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport on November 18, 2026, in Shenzhen, China

...

Different Households Experience The Economy Differently

“For one household, the economy is what’s left after groceries and rent,” Jacob said. “For another, it may also be what’s happening to their retirement savings.”

Market volatility could therefore have influenced affluent investors, but income alone does not show who owned substantial stocks or whether financial losses changed anyone’s view of Trump.

Jacob also said changes in the partisan composition of the income samples may have contributed to the contrasting results.

Examining movement among Democrats, Republicans and independents within each bracket would offer a better test of whether individuals were reconsidering the president, he said.

Barker questioned whether different economic experiences alone could explain the improvement among people earning under $30,000.

“If it were just about objective economic experiences, I would have thought that everyone’s opinion of Trump would have fallen, given that the high gas prices affect everyone but arguably low-income earners the most,” he said.

He raised the possibility that some people earning under $30,000 may be less exposed to fuel prices because they do not own vehicles, but presented that as a tentative explanation rather than a conclusion supported by the available polling.

James Christopher, a Democratic political consultant and managing director of James Christopher Communications, said tangible household costs were likely to matter more politically than short-lived market fluctuations.

“Households earning under $30,000 typically have little money to invest for the long term when they’re struggling to stretch each paycheck to cover rent, groceries and utilities,” Christopher told Newsweek.

“Affordability remains a campaign slogan until voters see the savings on their receipts,” he said.

What Happens Next

Panagopoulos said another two or three successive surveys would make the income movement more credible, while similar findings from rival pollsters would provide stronger corroboration.

“If there are true shifts of this magnitude happening within these subgroups, other surveys should be able to pick this up as well,” he said.

Jacob proposed watching approval and disapproval separately, because voters becoming more supportive of Trump would carry a different meaning from critics simply becoming less hostile.

Barker said the first test would be whether the pattern continues across new samples now that the campaign has ended. If the gap disappears outside an election environment, that would lend weight to his theory that campaign activity temporarily reinforced the partisan loyalties of different income groups.

Researchers should also examine panel surveys that return to the same group of respondents over time, he said. Such data can help distinguish an actual change in individual opinion from month-to-month differences between independently selected samples.

Until those tests are met, the numbers offer an intriguing snapshot rather than firm evidence that America’s richest and poorest voters are moving permanently in opposite political directions.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: John Fitzpatrick and Emma Lee-Sang

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines