
...

By Sean O'Driscoll
Senior Crime and Courts Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Donald Trump will "almost certainly" appeal his New York fraud case after a law professor strongly supported his version of events, an expert in white-collar crime has said.
Eric C. Chaffee, a law professor at Case Western Reserve University in Ohio, told Newsweek that it was a smart choice by Trump's defense team to call New York University professor Eli Bartov, who specializes in financial accounting.
"Offering the testimony helps to build a record for purposes of appeal. It is unlikely that former President Trump will accept anything less than a complete victory in the case. As a result, an appeal is almost certain," Chaffee said.
Read More
Florida Newspaper’s Stark Warning About Ron DeSantis3 min read

Republican Senator Vows Donald Trump’s Enemies ‘Will Fear Us’3 min read

Mary Trump Issues Dire Prediction About Second Donald Trump Term4 min read

Bartov told the fraud trial on Thursday that he saw "no evidence whatsoever for any accounting fraud" and that he "absolutely" believed that New York Attorney General Letitia James' case had no merit. James' $250 million lawsuit against Trump, his two eldest sons and the Trump Organization says that the defendants inflated assets to secure better deals with banks and insurers. Trump, like his sons, has denied any wrongdoing, accusing James of being part of a political witch hunt against him.
In September, Judge Arthur Engoron ruled that Donald Trump and his sons, Donald Trump Jr. and Eric Trump, committed fraud in their property evaluations. Engoron stripped the Trump companies involved of their business licenses, ending their legal right to conduct business, and will decide financial penalties later. He is currently hearing evidence on six other accusations, including falsifying business records, insurance fraud and conspiracy claims.
Newsweek sought email comment for an attorney representing Trump, who is the front-runner for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination.

...
Chaffee said that calling someone of Bartov's stature to give evidence was a good choice.
"While Professor Bartov is certainly being paid for his testimony, he also has his reputation as a member of the faculty at an elite institution. This makes it much easier to believe that he is offering his truthful and accurate expert opinion," Chaffee said.
"Offering Professor Bartov's testimony should be viewed favorably by the court in its consideration of the remaining issues in the case", Chaffee added.
Paul Golden, a partner at New York law firm Coffey Modica, told Newsweek that the Trump team will not be able to use Bartov's evidence to overturn Engoron's summary judgment in September, because it did not form part of the evidence on which the judge made his decision.
"Hon. Engoran had not been given the opportunity to review that particular testimony, so the appellate court obviously cannot fault Hon. Engoran for making a [summary] decision without considering it," Golden said.
"Regardless, it would not be a surprise if the Trump team were to ultimately file a motion before Hon. Engoran, asking him in essence to reconsider his previous summary judgment decision, and the Trump team may try to use Professor Bartov's testimony in support of such a motion," Golden added.
Before Bartov offered his testimony, Trump's attorneys established that the professor is a seasoned expert witness, having taken the stand previously in 16 to 18 cases. They drew particular attention to Bartov's role as a prosecution witness for a case Attorney General James' office brought against Exxon Mobil, where he testified as an expert on valuation and generally accepted accounting principles.
In 2019, Bartov testified for the prosecution as part of James' lawsuit accusing Exxon Mobil of downplaying the financial risks that it faced from possible climate regulation. This made the oil company's assets appear more secure than they really were and thus misled investors. Bartov's testimony did not go particularly well, however. He repeatedly misidentified Exxon as "Enron." James ended up losing the case.
During a short break in Bartov's testimony, Trump praised his evidence, telling reporters outside the courtroom: "He reviewed fully the documents that this horrendous attorney general has put forward, and he found absolutely no fraud, accounting fraud of any kind."
However, while Bartov gave testimony that helped the defense, he also said that Trump more than doubled the value of his penthouse apartment at New York City's Trump Tower.
"The price was inflated. There is no question about it," Bartov said about the financial statements that showed the property going from $80 million to $180 million between 2001 and 2012.
Although Bartov recognized the valuation was inflated, he said it was not unusual and blamed Trump's external accounting firm for failing to catch the error.
"There is no evidence here of concealment. It's true this is an error, but it is no fraud," Bartov said.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines