Illinois State Police make detentions in Broadview, Ill., Oct. 11, 2025. Federal appeals court upholds block on Trump’s move to federalize Illinois National Guard amid immigration protests. (AP Photo/Adam Gray)

...

Robert Alexander

By Robert Alexander

Senior Crime & Court Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump’s administration suffered two major legal setbacks on Thursday, as separate federal courts ruled against actions involving the deployment of National Guard troops in Illinois and the withholding of anti-terrorism funding for New York City’s transit system.

Newsweek contacted The White House for comment via email outside of normal office hours on Friday.

Why It Matters

The twin rulings handed down Thursday underscore a broader reckoning over the limits of presidential authority.

Read More on U.S.

By blocking Donald Trump’s attempt to deploy National Guard troops in Illinois and reversing his administration’s cutoff of anti-terrorism funds for New York, two federal courts signaled that executive power remains subject to statutory and constitutional checks.

The decisions not only curb the White House’s discretion in matters of domestic security and federal spending but also reaffirm the judiciary’s role in maintaining the balance between federal authority and state sovereignty—an issue likely to define the next stage of Trump’s legal and political battles.

Illinois State Police make detentions in Broadview, Ill., Oct. 11, 2025. Federal appeals court upholds block on Trump’s move to federalize Illinois National Guard amid immigration protests. (AP Photo/Adam Gray)

...

What To Know

Court Blocks Trump’s Troop Deployment In Illinois

In Chicago, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit upheld a lower court order blocking the Trump administration from federalizing and deploying National Guard troops in Illinois.

The administration had argued that unrest surrounding protests against immigration enforcement justified the move under 10 U.S.C. § 12406, which allows the president to call up the Guard during a “rebellion or danger of rebellion.”

The appellate judges—Ilana Rovner, David Hamilton, and Amy St. Eve—found otherwise. “The facts do not justify the President’s actions in Illinois under § 12406,” the unsigned per curiam opinion stated, “even giving substantial deference to his assertions.”

The court concluded that the situation in Chicago did not meet the statute’s requirements and that “political opposition is not rebellion.”

Judges Reject Claims Of Unreviewable Presidential Power

The decision leaves in place an earlier temporary restraining order issued by U.S. District Judge April M. Perry.

In her ruling, Perry determined that neither of the statutory predicates for federalization had been met, finding “insufficient evidence of rebellion or danger of rebellion” and that regular federal forces were adequate to enforce the law.

The dispute arose after President Trump, in an October 4 memorandum, directed the mobilization of at least 300 Illinois National Guard members to “protect ICE, FPS, and other United States Government personnel” and property in the state.

J.B. Pritzker, Illinois governor, refused to authorize the call-up, leading the administration to federalize the Guard directly.

In its opinion, the Seventh Circuit rejected the government’s argument that such presidential decisions were beyond judicial review, distinguishing the 1827 Supreme Court precedent Martin v. Mott—which held that when Congress authorizes the president to call out the militia (under the Militia Acts of the time), the president alone decides whether the conditions for doing so exist, and courts cannot second-guess that judgment.

“Nothing in the text of § 12406 makes the President the sole judge of whether these preconditions exist,” the court wrote.

White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson defended the administration’s actions, saying in an email statement that “President Trump has exercised his lawful authority to protect federal officers and assets” and that the administration “expects to be vindicated by a higher court.”

NYPD on patrol in the New York City Subway in the borough of Queens, NY, March 19, 2025. The Trump administration’s bid to strip MTA funding and shut down New York’s congestion toll program has been stopped by a federal court ruling. (Photo by Anthony Behar/Sipa USA)(Sipa via AP Images)

...

Judge Restores $34 Million In New York Transit Security Funding

Hours later, in New York, U.S. District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan permanently blocked the administration’s decision to withhold $33.9 million in federal anti-terrorism funds from the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA).

Kaplan ruled that the cuts—justified by the administration as a response to New York’s “sanctuary city” policies—were “arbitrary, capricious, and a blatant violation of the law.”

The funds at issue were part of the federal Transit Security Grant Program, created after the September 11, 2001 attacks to strengthen security for transit systems nationwide.

By law, the money must be distributed “solely based on risk.” Kaplan noted that New York City’s subway and commuter rail systems “have been the subject of at least eight terrorist plots since September 11” and that Congress had required the Department of Homeland Security to allocate the funds accordingly.

The ruling directs the government to restore the MTA’s $33.9 million allocation for fiscal year 2025, which had been cut to zero in September.

FEMA had stated that New York was excluded from funding “because the applicant is based in a Sanctuary Jurisdiction city.”

Kaplan rejected that reasoning, finding it contrary to both statute and precedent.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James welcomed the decision in a joint statement, calling it “a victory for every New Yorker who rides our subways, buses, and commuter rails.”

While neither decision represents a final judgment on the merits, both courts emphasized limits on presidential authority in matters of domestic law enforcement and federal funding.

The Seventh Circuit’s opinion underscored that the judiciary retains a role in reviewing statutory conditions for troop deployment, while the New York decision reaffirmed congressional mandates that security grants be based on risk assessment rather than political considerations.

What People Are Saying

Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker, in an official statement October 4, 2025, opposing the federalization effort: “They will pull hardworking Americans out of their regular jobs and away from their families … For Donald Trump, this has never been about safety. This is about control.”

Governor Hochul and New York Attorney General Letitia James joint statement, October 16, 2025: “A court has once again affirmed that this administration cannot punish New York by arbitrarily wiping out critical security resources and defunding law enforcement that keeps riders safe.”

What Happens Next

Both cases are now poised for further legal and political battles.

In Illinois, the Trump administration can ask the Supreme Court to lift the appellate court’s block on deploying National Guard troops, while the underlying case continues in federal district court.

In New York, the government must restore $33.9 million in anti-terrorism funding to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority unless it wins a stay while appealing Kaplan’s injunction to the Second Circuit.

Together, the rulings set the stage for higher-court tests of presidential authority over domestic military deployments and federal funding decisions—issues that could define the legal boundaries of executive power in the months ahead.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines