Donald Trump Connects with Teamsters

...

Alex J. Rouhandeh

By Alex J. Rouhandeh

National Political Correspondent

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Slotted to speak in Milwaukee at the Republican National Convention on Monday, surrounded by conservative governors, senators, and representatives, is someone who doesn't belong to the party.

Sean O'Brien is president of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, a group of 1.3 million freight drivers, warehouse employees, construction laborers, and other workers who since its founding in 1903 have largely been associated with the Democratic Party. Unlike most unions, which are backing President Joe Biden, the Teamsters have yet to formally endorse anyone in the White House race.

"I refuse to keep doing the same things as my predecessors did," O'Brien said in his speech. "Today, the Teamsters are here to say we are not beholden to anyone or any party."

Read More

How a Union Battle Could Decide Who Wins the U.S. Senate6 min read

How a Union Battle Could Decide Who Wins the U.S. Senate

The Union Fight for the Future of Work—and the Democratic Party18 min read

The Union Fight for the Future of Work—and the Democratic Party

Meet the Republican Millennials Warring for Trump’s Mind11 min read

Meet the Republican Millennials Warring for Trump’s Mind

O'Brien also requested a speaking slot at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago next month but his appearance at the GOP convention stands out due to a lack of precedence. It marked an inflection point in American politics as the GOP aims to transform into the party of the working class—a shift seen in the 2016 election of former President Donald Trump.

It is a shift that has the potential to cost Biden in the heavily white, working-class states of Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania that he likely needs to secure a second term. And now, following the assassination attempt on Trump, that base could further galvanize around the former president and propel him to clear front-runner status.

"Demographically, the Republicans are obviously becoming more of a working-class party, people who work in the trades, people who work in factories were maybe much more Democratic 40 years ago than they are today," Republican Senator JD Vance of Ohio, who was named Trump's vice presidential candidate on Monday, told Newsweek.

"So, it's not surprising that as the people who support Republicans are themselves members of, or at least adjacent to, organized labor that you're seeing more and more labor unions support Republicans, which I think is a virtuous cycle for our party."

Donald Trump Connects with Teamsters

...

Vance possesses deep roots in Appalachia where he overcame a challenging upbringing to attend Yale Law School, rising to prominence with the release of his 2016 bestseller Hillbilly Elegy. The Ohio Republican has sought to buck the traditional "country club Republican" moniker and joined a picket line of striking autoworkers last year.

A Gallup survey released in May found that 46 percent of Republicans considered themselves working or lower class as opposed to 35 percent of Democrats. In contrast, 62 percent of Democrats considered themselves upper-middle or middle class compared to 53 percent of Republicans.

Kara Deniz, a spokesperson for the Teamsters, told Newsweek that the union has "traditionally endorsed" a candidate after the conventions.

"Rank-and-file Teamsters will dictate any possible endorsement from our union," Deniz said in a statement. "Sean O'Brien's speech tonight is truly unprecedented since it will be the very first time a Teamsters General President has addressed the RNC.

"Our 1.3 million members work in all 50 states, represent every political background, and their message needs to be heard by as wide an audience as possible, and that includes all political candidates running for elected office."

Teamsters President Speaks at GOP Convention

...

However, despite the Teamsters openness to engaging with Republicans, most unions remain loyal to the Democratic Party.

Those include the AFL-CIO, the largest union federation as well as the Wisconsin Laborers' District Council, an affiliate of the Laborers' International Union of North America (LIUNA), which endorsed Biden.

"Under President Biden, we've seen that not only does he say the word union, but he's walked a picket line—His philosophy is growing the economy from the bottom up and the middle out," Kent Miller, president/business manager of the Wisconsin Laborers' District Council, told Newsweek. "Under President Trump, he said infrastructure was really easy to do, but we never got anything done under infrastructure—He got a trillion-dollar tax break."

Miller said the president has supported union members in both his rhetoric and actions—pointing to a Microsoft data center to be sited in Wisconsin that will require some 2,300 union workers to build. He contrasted that with Trump's ultimate failure as president to attract business from technology company Foxconn to the same area.

Newsweek contacted the Trump campaign for comment. The Biden team referred Newsweek to a statement that read: "All Donald Trump delivered workers across the country were broken promises. He is a fraud who over-promised, under-delivered, and sold America out."

The Biden administration has made much of its infrastructure push, microchip manufacturing, and green energy investment laws that it says will benefit workers. Trump meanwhile passed significant tax cuts.

Brent Buchanan, president and founder of the Republican polling firm Cygnal, believes Trump needs a more direct approach with workers.

"It's hard for a working-class person to see how a corporate tax cut benefits them," Buchanan told Newsweek. "When I look at policies like paid family leave, that I had written about, that to me makes sense and is conservative."

The argument of taking government action to strengthen the American family through paid leave departs sharply from earlier Republican views and fits better with what might have long been associated with the Democratic Party.

J.D. Vance at a union picket line

...

Yet, as the Democratic Party has focused more on issues such as climate change, social liberation, and global trade those same issues have undercut what was once the left's blue-collar base.

The shift is clearly seen in West Virginia, which from 1932 through 2000 only voted for the Republican presidential candidate three times. Over that same period, New York state voted Republican six times. Yet, after going red in 2000, the West Virginia has only grown more conservative, providing Trump his second largest margin of victory—only behind Wyoming—in 2020.

"The blue-collar, hardworking miners, manufacturers, steel workers, and factory workers, they feel like the Vietnam veterans returning home war—all of a sudden they're not good enough, clean enough, green enough, smart enough," independent Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia, a former Democrat, told Newsweek.

"I think there're a lot of hardcore, working Democrats, that I grew up with, who believe that the mentality of the national party of the Democrats have just forgotten our base, where we came from, and who we are."

The makeup of blue-collar workers has changed drastically since the Democrats dominated the group through much of the twentieth century, according to an analysis by the nonpartisan Brookings Institution.

Since the 1960s, the working class has become less unionized and less likely to work manufacturing and construction jobs. Today, many of these people work retail and service industry jobs, dreaming of starting their own business one day.

The Brookings analysis writes that this has made them more sensitive to the pro-government, pro-regulation positions associated with the Democratic Party.

Buchanan said the predominantly Hispanic Rio Grande Valley—which has grown redder in recent years—stands as an example of this. Latinos open businesses at more than twice the rate of the U.S. population as a whole, according to reporting by the Wall Street Journal.

Many Democrats say it is specifically white members of the working class who have leaned Republican in recent years rather than Hispanic and Black working-class people. But recent polling has found Trump to be less unfavorable than he was before among both those groups.

Senator Josh Hawley says that his party is undergoing significant demographic changes. The Missouri Republican told Newsweek that conservatives must now better align their policymaking with the party's base and draw lessons from the electoral defeat of conservatives in Britain he said had failed to keep promises to working people.

"Policy the last 30-40 years in this country, which is basically to say, 'hey, unless you go to college and get a four-year degree and get it in whatever, software engineering, then you're screwed, and we're all fine with that'—What a terrible policy, and that's been Republican policy too, and it's stupid," he said.

"If you think that working people are just automatically going to vote for Republicans just because the Democrats suck, you're wrong."

Update 07/15/24, 11 p.m. ET: This article was updated to include comment from O'Brien, Vance's status as Trump's choice of running mate and a statement from the Biden campaign.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines