
...

By Maya Mehrara
News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump's proposal to "clean out" Gaza has sparked a backlash from the Arab nations he would need to help implement it.
Egypt and Jordan have spoken out against Trump's plan to resettle Palestinians in their countries, stating that it would not achieve peace sought by many in the region, according to their foreign ministries. Trump's idea has provoked widespread opposition from people not directly affected, and an ally of his has also branded the plan not "overly practical."
Newsweek reached out to the White House for comment via email outside of business hours.
Read More on World
Newsweek also reached out to Egypt and Jordan's Ministries for Foreign Affairs for comment via email.

...
Why It Matters
Trump has repeatedly called for an end to the Gaza war and promised to facilitate a ceasefire during his 2024 election run, drawing support from both pro-Israel and pro-Palestinian voters. But his proposal to 'clean out' Gaza has faced a fierce backlash, with some opponents labeling it "ethnic cleansing." Trump said such a population movement could be either temporary or long-term.
The decades-old conflict in the Middle East has been one of the most intractable in the world. Numerous attempts to end it, including proposals for a two-state solution with a Palestinian state alongside Israel, have so far proved unachievable.
Some 1.9 million Palestinians have been displaced since the war in Gaza began, following Hamas' attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, according to Amnesty International.
Since the start of the conflict, more than 40,000 Palestinians have been killed, according to Hamas health authorities. Israel denies targeting civilians in its attacks.
What To Know
Trump introduced his plan to "clean out" Gaza in a 20-minute interview with reporters aboard Air Force One, saying that the region is a "demolition site right now." Trump said he would "rather get involved with some of the Arab nations, and build housing in a different location, where they can maybe live in peace for a change."
The president proposed resettling Palestinian refugees in Egypt and Jordan and said, "You're talking about probably a million and a half people, and we just clean out that whole thing and say, 'You know, it's over.'"
Egypt's Ministry of Foreign Affairs responded to Trump's proposal and said that they "affirm Egypt's adherence to the constraints and determinants of the political settlement of the Palestinian issue, stressing that it remains the central issue in the Middle East, and that the delay in settling it, ending the occupation, and usurping the rights of the Palestinian people, is the basis of the instability in the region."
Cairo has rejected "any infringement on these inalienable rights, whether through [Israeli] settlement expansion, land annexation, or the removal of Palestinians from their land through resettlement, encouragement of transfer, or uprooting, whether temporary or long-term."
Egypt added that it views such actions as a threat to "stability, a warning of an expanded regional conflict, and a barrier to opportunities for peace and coexistence among the region's peoples."
Egypt ruled Gaza until the 1967 Middle East War, in which it was captured by Israel along with the then Jordanian-run West Bank and east Jerusalem.
Jordan also opposed Trump's idea, and Foreign Minister Ayman Safadi spoke out about it in a joint press conference with Sigrid Kaag, the U.N. Senior Humanitarian and Reconstruction Coordinator for Gaza in Amman on January 26.
Safadi said that "the stability of the Palestinians on their land is a Jordanian constant that has not changed and will not change." He added that Jordan's "position that the two-state solution is the way to achieve peace is firm and unchangeable. Our rejection of displacement is firm and unchangeable. This is not only a firm and steadfast position from which the Kingdom cannot deviate, but it is also a necessity in order to achieve the security, stability and peace that we all want." He also noted that Amman looks forward to working with the Trump administration.
Trump ally Senator Lindsay Graham has said the idea of Palestinians moving out of the Gaza Strip to live elsewhere is impractical.
Jordan is currently home to more than 2.39 million registered Palestine refugees, according to the UN.
What People Are Saying
The Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, the leader of the leader of the Religious Zionism party, said in a statement published by the Times of Israel: "After 76 years during which the majority of Gaza's population has been forcibly kept in harsh conditions to preserve the aspiration of destroying the State of Israel, the idea of helping them find other places to start new, better lives is an excellent idea."
"For years, politicians have proposed impractical solutions like dividing the land and establishing a Palestinian state, which endangered the existence and security of the world's only Jewish state, leading only to bloodshed and suffering for many. Only out-of-the-box thinking and new solutions will bring about peace and security. With God's help, I will work with the prime minister and the cabinet to develop an operational plan to implement this as soon as possible."
Assal Rad, Middle East historian and foreign policy analyst, posted on X, formerly Twitter: "Does no one in the media know what it's called when you 'clean out' an ethnic group and expel them from their land? 'Trump Calls For Ethnic Cleansing of Palestinians From Gaza,' that is your headline."
In a post on X, Julie Roginsky, a former Fox News and CNBC contributor, wrote: "Egypt and Jordan want to take Palestinian refugees even less than Trump wants to take it Guatemalan refugees. If Trump understood anything about the history of the Egyptian ruling clique v Muslim Brotherhood or the Jordanian Hashemite rulers v Palestinians, he would know this."
When asked on CNN's State of the Union about Trump's Gaza "clean out" remark, Sen. Lindsay Graham, a Trump ally, said: "The idea that all the Palestinians are going to leave and go somewhere else, I don't see that to be overly practical."
What Happens Next
The Trump administration is yet to respond to the statements issued by Egypt and Jordan. Amid a tenuous but uninterrupted Gaza ceasefire, international efforts continue to address the severe humanitarian crisis in the region.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines