Elon Musk shows off a shirt that says “DOGE” at the White House in Washington, DC on March 9, 2025.

...

Robert Alexander

By Robert Alexander

Senior Crime & Court Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A coalition of Democratic-led states has formally withdrawn a high-profile lawsuit challenging Elon Musk’s role in the Trump administration’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), ending one of the broadest legal efforts aimed at curbing the billionaire’s authority inside the federal government.

The case was filed in February 2025 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia and alleged that President Donald Trump unlawfully delegated expansive executive power to Musk without congressional authorization or Senate confirmation.

Newsweek contacted the DOJ for comment via email outside of normal office hours on Tuesday.

Read More on U.S.

Why It Matters

This case tests the constitutional limits of presidential power and the accountability of unelected advisers inside the federal government.

At issue was whether President Donald J. Trump could delegate sweeping authority to Elon Musk without congressional approval, and whether the creation and operation of the Department of Government Efficiency blurred the line between advising the executive branch and exercising official power.

Although the states dropped their lawsuit after DOGE was wound down, the underlying questions—how executive authority is assigned, how states are affected by federal restructuring, and whether courts can still review short-lived but consequential government initiatives—remain unresolved and continue to shape the remaining legal challenges.

Elon Musk shows off a shirt that says "DOGE" at the White House in Washington, D.C., on March 9, 2025.

...

What To Know

Legal Challenge To Musk’s Role At DOGE

The plaintiff states argued in that Musk, serving as a “special Government employee,” exercised powers reserved for constitutionally appointed officers, in violation of the Appointments Clause.

In a notice filed on December 15, the states voluntarily dismissed the action without prejudice, citing “events subsequent to its filing.”

The filing came after the court asked whether a live controversy remained, as DOGE’s formal operations had wound down and Musk had departed his government role.

The lawsuit, State of New Mexico v. Musk, was originally brought by more than a dozen states, including New Mexico, Arizona, California, Michigan and Massachusetts.

Their complaint warned that Musk had been granted “virtually unchecked authority… without proper legal authorization from Congress and without meaningful supervision of his activities.”

It further alleged that DOGE personnel accessed sensitive systems across federal agencies and directed staffing and funding decisions that affected state-administered programs.

Several declarations filed in support of the states’ request for emergency relief outlined potential impacts on education, labor, environmental protection and social services if federal funding or staffing were disrupted.

Washington State officials, for example, said federal funds made up roughly 32 percent of the state’s budget in fiscal year 2024 and warned that cancellations or freezes could have “a devastating effect” on state operations.

New Mexico officials raised similar concerns across public education, workforce programs and environmental regulation.

Despite those claims, the case saw little movement after Musk left DOGE in the spring.

Case Dismissed After Doge Winds Down

In May, a federal judge denied the Justice Department’s request to dismiss the lawsuit outright, writing that the administration appeared to endorse a “perverse reading” of constitutional checks and balances and to “sanction unlimited executive power,” according to later reporting summarized in the case record.

However, no substantive rulings followed, and the court later questioned whether the dispute had become moot.

The states ultimately chose to step back.

In a joint status report filed earlier in December, they informed the court that they had “decided to voluntarily dismiss their case” and would file the appropriate notice, which they did days later.

No public explanation accompanied the dismissal, and representatives for the New Mexico attorney general’s office did not respond to requests for comment at the time, according to contemporaneous reporting included in the record.

Related Lawsuits And Unresolved Questions

The withdrawal does not resolve all litigation related to DOGE.

Separate lawsuits brought by advocacy organizations and former federal employees remain active and continue to challenge whether Musk and DOGE staff unlawfully exercised executive authority or violated federal transparency laws.

In one consolidated case, plaintiffs argue that DOGE’s formal disbanding does not eliminate a live controversy because executive orders establishing DOGE teams across agencies remain in effect.

The Justice Department has countered that constitutional claims tied to Musk’s role are now moot, given his departure and DOGE’s dissolution. Courts have yet to issue final rulings on those remaining disputes.

For Musk, the states’ dismissal removes one of the broadest legal challenges to his government role.

For the courts, the unresolved cases may still shape how far future administrations can go in assigning significant governmental functions to outside figures without congressional approval.

What People Are Saying

Elon Musk, speaking on The Joe Rogan Experience podcast, October 2025, said: “DOGE is still happening.” [It was a remark later cited by plaintiffs to challenge the government’s claim that DOGE had ceased operating.]

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan, ruling in May 2025 when she denied the government’s initial motion to dismiss the states’ lawsuit, said the administration appeared to endorse a “perverse reading” of the Constitution’s system of checks and balances and to “sanction unlimited executive power.”

What Happens Next

The states’ lawsuit has ended without a court ruling, but the broader dispute is not over: other cases challenging Elon Musk’s role in DOGE are still pending, and judges must now decide whether those claims remain live or are moot following DOGE’s wind-down and Musk’s departure.

Without a decision on the merits, no precedent was set on how far a president can delegate authority to an unelected adviser, leaving unresolved questions about executive power, accountability, and oversight.

How courts handle the remaining lawsuits—and whether Congress steps in to clarify the use of special government employees and temporary agencies—will determine whether similar arrangements can be repeated in future administrations.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines