
...

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A brand image tarnished, a customer base alienated and boycotts taking their toll on the car maker's bottom line can be listed among Tesla's current woes, but it isn't the first company to navigate such a situation.
Swapping low-calorie beer for electric vehicles, and "woke" social media promotions with a CEO's full-throated endorsement of a Republican president, the stories of Tesla and Bud Light-owner Anheuser-Busch read largely the same.
Bud Light's troubles began in April 2023, sparked by the company collaborating with transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney in a series of social media campaigns. While intended to address a decline in sales and foster a more inclusive brand image, the resulting boycott – which rode a wider wave of conservative backlash against companies "going woke"—saw sales drop as much as 20 percent within a few months, according to estimates at the time.
Read More on U.S.
"Bud Light alienated its core market of older conservatives when it courted a younger segment with transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney in 2023," said Hugh Wilson, a professor of marketing at Warwick Business School. "You can often play to different segments with different messages in different media. But not, it seems, on culture-war issues in the increasingly polarized U.S."

...
The catalyst for Tesla, meanwhile, has been Musk's numerous forays into the world of politics, pumping nearly $300 million into Republican election campaigns in 2024, becoming the figurehead of the Trump administration's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), while also lending rhetorical support to far-right parties across Europe.
The effects of this have been at least as pronounced as the backlash to Bud Light. Tesla's stock has plunged since the inauguration (currently down over 40 percent) and its global sales are sluggish at best.
According to analysis from CreditSights shared with Newsweek, Tesla posted a 39 percent annualized decline in registrations across Europe in February. Volumes tumbled over 76 percent in Germany—where Musk has propped up the Alternative for Germany party in the recent elections—which analysts said was "largely driven by a consumer backlash due to Elon Musk's association with the Trump administration."
"What we are witnessing is extraordinary," media and marketing expert Omar Oakes said. "Business professors will do case studies for years on X and Tesla and how to destroy brand equity so needlessly."

...
The cases differ in a number of ways, however, the most obvious being the ideologies of those lashing out at the companies and those lamenting the consequences.
"Bud Light. Disney. Target. Go WOKE. Go BROKE," the X account for the Republican House Judiciary Committee posted in May of 2023.
The very same account, in response to Minnesota Governor Tim Walz saying that Tesla's declining stock price gave him a daily "boost," wrote: "Democrats are CHEERING for American companies to fail. Disgusting behavior."
"Money does talk—Anheuser-Busch now understands that," Donald Trump posted to Truth Social during the height of the Bud Light boycott.
This draws a sharp comparison with Trump's attempt to rejuvenate Tesla's image—likely owing to the CEO's political proximity to the president. Last week, Trump hosted an impromptu showroom on the White House lawn, purchased a Tesla for staffers to drive, and declared the boycotts and protests "illegal."

...
As some conservatives have recently pointed out, the Bud Light boycotts also never descended into violence and vandalism, though country singer and MAGA icon Kid Rock did post a video of himself shooting cases of the drink with a submachine gun.
Beyond the general aversion some prospective car buyers may have toward Musk's politics, Tesla's troubles also stem from the increased competition the company faces in the EV space it once dominated, as well as the failure to revamp its product offerings.
"In a world where consumer demand for electric vehicles is strong and growing, Tesla should be consolidating its enormous success over the last decade by innovating its product lineup and investing in strong brand marketing as rivals catch up," Oakes said. "Instead, there has been no innovation for a decade."
"Refreshing the Model Y and launching a niche Cybertruck product doesn't move the dial," he added.
However, the cases are similar in that both companies angered what was considered to be their core customer base—Bud Light alienating the straight and conservative, while Musk's actions have likely pushed away more Democrat-aligned drivers, who a 2023 Gallup poll found are much more likely to opt for an electric vehicle than their Republican counterparts.
"Both cases demonstrate, in very different ways, the perils of managing brands in these polarized times," Patrick Barwise, a management and marketing professor at London Business School, told Newsweek.

...
Bud Light was able to somewhat weather the boycotts, though it never reclaimed the top spot in the U.S. beer market and continues to battle slow sales. Much of the ground it has lost, however, is to Michelob Ultra, another Anheuser product.
As for Tesla, it remains to be seen how the company will rebound.
According to Garrett Nelson, vice president of equity research firm CFRA, Tesla's declining share price matches a pattern of highs and lows that have defined the stock over the past few years.
"The stock is currently experiencing its eighth peak-to-trough decline of 40 percent or more since the end of 2018," Nelson told Newsweek. "Each time has proven to be a rewarding buying opportunity for investors."
He added that several upcoming developments could inject life into the stock, including the development of autopilot features, and the release of Optimus, the humanoid robot that Tesla plans to make commercially available in 2026.
However, others believe the only way for Tesla to mount a major recovery is to part ways with its CEO.
"Tesla's only option now is to remove Musk as CEO," Oakes said. "They no longer have a free run at the EV market and it's time to put a grown-up in charge."
Newsweek has reached out to Tesla via email for comment.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines