10
Loading video...

By Howard Steele
Professor of Psychology at The New School for Social Research
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
There has been much criticism of Elon Musk's suggestion in early 2025, in conversation with Joe Rogan, that empathy is a weakness of Western civilization. In fact, as believing Christians, Jews, or Muslims know, the founders and leaders of these major world religions advocate understanding of others, empathy for their suffering, and the pursuit of peaceable relations with all. Yet, even as believers or non-believers know, we often fall short of our ideals. And the best way to deal with this sense of shortcoming is to redouble our efforts and try anew to empathize with others, and act with a moral sensibility for the betterment of ourselves, others, and the world we live in.
A popular psychological theory that assumes, counter to the idea of "original sin," that we are born essentially good is attachment theory, the product of the British psychiatrist and psychoanalyst John Bowlby.

...
Read More on Opinion
According to attachment theory, we are born into the world biologically primed to expect sensitive/responsive care, from a wiser, stronger, and kinder person (typically a mother or father), to help us manage our distress. And once calmed down, from thousands of such interactions with a caregiver who successfully addresses our confusion, fear or distress, we arrive by 1 year of age with confidence in ourselves as loved and have the makings of an emerging person who can be loving and empathic toward others.
This has been robustly demonstrated across linguistic and cultural groups. So too has the opposite been shown. That is, if a child is not well-loved, or does not routinely experience others empathizing with his or her distress, then that child will learn to fear and suspect others and will be lacking empathic skills.
New, more favorable and balanced relationships, following disappointing ones, can help to rewrite a person's expectations, beliefs, and behaviors, just as adverse relationships following good enough beginnings can disrupt and change one's belief and behaviors. As environmental influences tend to be stable over time, how we begin is how we are likely to continue.
All of this suggests that investment in early childhood education, and rewarding economic support for teachers, ought to be a high priority of city, state, and federal governments. This is vital given persisting economic disparities in the U.S. and other developed Western democracies, evident year after year. That is, the growing gap between the rich and the poor—a core feature of the polarization of American society.
To better understand how young children think and feel about wealth and poverty, I am conducting a research study on 5-8-year-olds' understanding of wealth, poverty, and redistributive justice. We call it our Robin Hood project, developed with support from the Provost's Office at The New School.
We have a set of illustrations of two worlds, one where there is plenty of food and toys and a functional house (the world of more), and another that has insufficient food and not enough toys (the world of less). We ask children to talk about who lives where, and why? We also indicate that someone takes from the world of more and gives to the world of less, and children are asked if they approve of this action.
Our working idea is that if children who have been loved well enough at home (they have the benefit of a secure attachment), and believe in their intrinsic worth, will show more empathy for others living with less resources than they have. To facilitate this research, we have embedded in the Robin Hood task a set of bunny family drawings that depict moral, attachment, and domestic dilemmas where we tell the beginning of a story and ask the child to tell the end of the story. Children's story completions convey a sense of what their family life is like at home, and this provides us with a measure of the extent to which the child is likely to have a secure attachment.
We are also measuring a range of other possible influences, including the number of siblings, economic status of the child's family, religious commitments of the family, and whether there are any family discussions of wealth/poverty at home, or at school. All the data is being collected online over 30-45 minutes and we seek parents with children aged 5-8 to please contact us should they wish to participate in the research or learn more about it.
Among our goals is to develop a set of good practice guidelines for conversations parents and teachers might have concerning income disparity, so that the future our children inherit may be one where there is less poverty and more empathy for those who are marginalized and disadvantaged. Surely in the wealthiest county in the history of the world, there should be no children living in poverty with few opportunities to effectively pursue the American Dream. According to World Bank calculations, 3.5 million Americans lived in extreme poverty earning no more than $3 per day in 2022. And 37 million Americans lived below the poverty line ($27 per day) in that same year. These numbers of impoverished Americans, including many millions of children, consistently put the U.S. at the top of reported poverty rates in the industrialized world.
This Robin Hood study has received seed money support for the development of the task from the Provost's Office, The New School.
Write to the following email if you are interested in the research described above: RobinHoodstudy@newschool.edu.
Howard Steele is a professor of psychology at The New School for Social Research.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines