
...

By H. Alan Scott
Senior Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Portrayals of the HIV/AIDS epidemic in film have historically been challenging, rarely representing the LGBTQ+ community authentically. In 2022, Tom Hanks told Newsweek that his Oscar-winning performance in Philadelphia about a man dying of AIDS "would require a different type of authenticity" if that film were made today. He is not wrong. At one point, it was considered that the ticket to Oscar gold for a straight actor of Hanks' stature was to play a queer person afflicted with AIDS, and it often proved to be true. One need only look to other straight male actors like Jared Leto in Dallas Buyers Club and Rami Malek in Bohemian Rhapsody, both of whom won Oscars for playing a queer character with the disease. That is bound to change with Andrew Scott's performance in Elsinore.

...
"When I was growing up and watching Philadelphia, that film had a real impact on me," Scott told Newsweek’s Parting Shot podcast. "I am grateful to Tom for everything that he said, the generosity with which he speaks, the wisdom with which he speaks and the humility with which he speaks, given what an extraordinary performance that was and how impactful it was and how useful it was for people."
Read More on Entertainment
That perspective shows an actor who has put in the work to understand the journey it has taken countless out gay actors to reach the same point in their career that Scott seems to be at. A point where one could potentially become the first openly gay actor to win an Academy Award for Best Actor.
"Any film wants a bit of a buzz about your movie, you really do," Scott said. "It is hard to talk about in some ways because I do believe in that old idiom about nobody knows anything. There is lots of speculation, but it is almost like an industry now. Speculation about those things is a sort of fun game for people and I get why. But at the moment, what we are trying to do is just get the film out and to hopefully get Ian's name in the public's imagination, which I think would be such an amazing thing."

...
The “Ian” Scott speaks of is Ian Charleson, the late actor of Chariots of Fire fame. Elsinore follows the true story of Charleson as he battled AIDS while performing the part he waited a lifetime to play, Hamlet, months before he would die from complications of the disease. Directed by Simon Stone and written by Stephen Beresford, the film co-stars Olivia Colman and Billie Piper.
"There does seem to be a lot of people talking about the unsung heroes," Piper said regarding the women who supported gay men during the epidemic, a point of which Elsinore does so well. "They were there in every sense. Lots of young people do not know a great deal about the AIDS crisis at all, let alone the people involved, the people supporting the communities, the neglect of the government and the appalling media coverage. It is just a really good reminder that this is something we need to continue to talk about."
Unlike other films depicting the AIDS experience, it was important to Stone and Beresford to find the balance between turning Charleson into a hero and just showing the man as he was.
"It was really important to me that he was complex and flawed," Beresford said. "One of the things that really appealed to me as a story was that he is publicly a closeted gay man. Traditionally, the redemptive arc of that character is a coming-out scene to his parents at Christmas, ideally, and that is not what the story does. I felt that that was more real and closer to a more complex history which I think we deserve."

...
"He has a lot of self-doubt as a character, which I think is what is charming about it," Stone added. "It is not by virtue of him having superhuman abilities that he pulls it off. He is a human who is frail emotionally and physically who, despite that frailty, does something unthinkably brilliant. I find that more inspiring for an average audience than watching someone who is a hero be a hero."
And it is in the attempt to show the real Charleson that Scott's performance truly shines. Watching Scott transform emotionally is an example of an actor in top form. It is in the subtle small things he does, from the way he notices a doctor obsessively washing his hands to the anxiety of waiting for an inevitable fate, that audiences recognize an actor doing something that happens only rarely on screen: a true metamorphosis. Scott's performance is reminiscent of Charlize Theron in Monster or Jamie Foxx in Ray. After a while, viewers cease to see Andrew Scott and suddenly Ian Charleson is alive again.
"You see this miraculous moment happen, which is that an actor breaks through every layer of artifice to something so honest and raw," Stone said of the performance. "That made me aware that I had to protect what Andrew was doing and what Andrew was doing was once in a lifetime."
Scott is keenly aware of what this performance means to the queer community, and in many ways it is the wisdom he spoke of when reflecting on Hanks' Oscar win that Scott is also adopting.

...
"To be in this moment now, and to have the opportunity to play this part that Ian and his counterparts would not have enjoyed, it feels like an embarrassment of riches," Scott said. "To be able to work with people that I love and to be able to make a piece of work [Scott also produced Elsinore] that is very important but also that is very surprising for people."
Elsinore is not just another awards film to see this year. It is a film to see to be remembered, because Charleson is an example of so many actors who were taken away too soon by AIDS. It is also because Scott delivers a performance that will stay with audiences for years to come. In fact, something Hanks told Newsweek speaks to the power of a film like Elsinore.
"If it could have empowered anybody, including audiences, to say like, when I can I will be myself and I will be proud of myself and I will be able to walk like everybody else and talk and gather and love who I want to love," Hanks said referring to Philadelphia. "Well, isn't that a little bit of the power of the cinema at its absolute best, but only at its absolute best?"
The same could be said for Elsinore.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines