Actress Anne Hathaway attends the 20th Century Fox premiere of The Devil Wears Prada at the Loews Lincoln Center Theatre on June 19, 2006 in New York City.

...

Rachael O'Connor

By Rachael O'Connor

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A man realized the major societal change when it comes to women's bodies in the spotlight when he watched a classic 2000s movie about the fashion industry.

Released in 2006, and with a sequel soon to be released, The Devil Wears Prada boasted a star-studded cast, including Meryl Streep, Stanley Tucci, and Emily Blunt. Anne Hathaway played the main character, an aspiring journalist who bags a job at a major fashion magazine, despite having no interest in fashion herself.

The movie follows Hathaway as she tries to fit in and placate her notoriously demanding boss (Streep) and showcases the cutthroat, intense reality of the fashion industry and body standards at the time, with multiple comments about Hathaway's character's weight.

Read More on Entertainment

Of course, actress Hathaway is far, far from overweight—and it is this that Threads user Justin Jordan, @freddiesroommate, commented on in a now-viral post that has reignited the debate around the fatshaming culture of the early 2000s.

In a post shared on March 24, he shared a photo of Hathaway as the character and asked: "I'm watching Devil Wears Prada for the first time and I have a genuine question. WHY WAS THIS CONSIDERED FAT?"

Jordan told Newsweek: "Watching this movie for the first time was truly a blast from the past. But the surprising part wasn't her weight being mentioned; the surprising part was the response to my post."

It had a huge reaction, with close to 10,000 views; one user wrote: "Why do you think older women are screaming about how thin all the celebrities are now? We don't want to do this…again!"

View on Threads

"Anything that wasn't 00 was fat when this movie came out," another said, recalling the likes of Jessica Simpson and Kate Winslet being mocked for their weight, and others pointing out how one decidedly not fat character in Christmas romance Love Actually was repeatedly called overweight within the film.

Others shared images from Y2K magazines calling thin female celebrities fat, recalling how anyone not stick-thin would be photographed on the beach or walking down the streets where paparazzi would zoom in on anything remotely close to a bit of weight, to be relentlessly mocked in the media.

And some women shared their own stories, posting teenage or young adulthood photos from the early 2000s and saying they were "considered chubby" or "constantly picked on for being fat," despite photos showing the opposite.

One user, who identified themselves as an elder millennial, said "there is a reason we got behind the body positivity movement later. [Because] the 90s and 00s were toxic in terms of body image. Especially in a space like fashion."

Anne Hathaway attends the premiere of "The Devil Wears Prada" at the Loews Lincoln Center Theatre, June 19, 2006, New York City.

...

Others recalled how Hathaway's character was referred to by her six (a six) at certain points throughout the movie, and how she is praised for losing weight, but one user said: "I thought the joke was that she wasn't fat. When I saw it in the theater, and Miranda called her fat, the audience burst out laughing. Because she’s NOT. It was to point out that the standards are SO ridiculous they consider thin women fat."

Jordan said some people in the responses to his post were "misremembering the film to make it seem 'nicer' than it actually was."

He added: "As a millennial myself, I grew up in a very toxic atmosphere for body positivity. But I obviously didn't get the full brunt of the toxicity like the women of my generation, and still receive today. I can't wait to see the new film and to see how the characters have changed with the times."

With the rise of weight-loss drugs such as Ozempic, and conversations reigniting over celebrities losing or gaining weight, some have wondered whether the atmosphere of the 2000s is making a return.

Health and fitness coach Becky Jones, who led a conversation on body positivity and the Y2K fat-shaming online last year, told Newsweek at the time that millennials "grew up watching the media scrutinize women's bodies relentlessly."

"Magazines would highlight 'imperfections' with red circles, films portrayed normal bodies as undesirable, and these messages were inescapable," Jones said.

Twenty-five percent of adult women report feeling "shame" around their body image, in contrast to 15 percent of men, according to a Mental Health Foundation survey. The study also found that 26 percent of women said they feel "disgusted" by their body image, compared with 12 percent of men.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines