...
By Aayu Sharma
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When James Gunn came out with "Superman" last year, everyone felt that the DC Universe had finally found the right direction. The movie went on to become a hit at the box office and received positive reviews from critics, giving fans hope that DC has finally cracked the code. However, the early critical reception of "Supergirl" and the conversation surrounding the film have been noticeably different.
As critics began sharing their official reactions to the film, its score on the review site Rotten Tomatoes quickly became a hot topic of discussion across social media. Everyone hoped for the film to achieve a high score on the aforementioned platform. Sadly, the outcome fell short of those expectations, raising fresh questions about the DCU's momentum after "Superman." As of writing this piece, the Milly Alcock-starrer has garnered a rating of 58%, based on more than 136 critic reviews, making it one of the most polarizing entries in the newly launched DC Universe.
...
Read More on Movies
The rating also establishes that "Supergirl" is now the lowest-rated project in the DC Universe, and is a long way behind the other titles, such as "Creature Commandos" (95%), "Peacemaker" Season 2 (94%), and "Superman" (83%). Meanwhile, when we compare the film's rating with other DC projects, the situation doesn't look particularly encouraging. While the number may go up, "Supergirl" has already been positioned among the weaker-reviewed DC films, such as "Wonder Woman 84" (57%), "The Flash" (63%), and "Aquaman" (66%).
The reviews have been mixed, and critics seemed to like some aspects of the film, while expressing concerns about its overall execution. Moreover, the negative reactions become noteworthy because "Supergirl" is not just another comic book movie. It is the second major film in the universe led by Gunn, and everyone wanted to see if the franchise would be able to carry forward the momentum generated by "Superman," which is widely considered to be a promising start to the DC Universe.
But not every response has been negative about the film. Critics have praised Alcock's performance and noted how she manages to bring a new layer of charisma and depth to the iconic character. On the other hand, there has been a lot of praise for introducing a character like Lobo (played by Jason Momoa), which has reportedly added an extra layer of excitement to the film.
The critical reception might tell one story, but the film is yet to be seen by audiences, and "Supergirl" might very well become one of those titles where audience reactions differ significantly from professional reviews. The film may not be the unanimous hit everyone expected, but its long-term impact will largely depend on audience response and box office performance. It would be interesting to see how the audience reacts to the film and if the RT score will hamper its success.
"Supergirl" is scheduled to hit theaters on June 26, 2026.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines