10
Loading video...

By Megan Cartwright
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A legal dispute has erupted between Warner Bros. and Fox News Media over promotional material for The Vow, with Warner Bros. alleging the teaser borrows protected elements associated with The Bachelor.
Entertainment attorney Madison Karsenty told Newsweek that Warner Bros. may face an uphill battle if it is trying to claim ownership of common dating-show imagery such as roses, tuxedos and mansion backdrops, though she said the studio could have a stronger case if specific promotional content was copied.
The disagreement affects the launch of Fox Nation's The Vow and could influence how competing reality shows market themselves in the future.
Read More on Entertainment
It also comes as Chris Harrison, long synonymous with The Bachelor, returns to the dating-show genre as host of The Vow, adding another layer to the trademark debate.
Newsweek contacted Fox Nation and Warner Bros. via email for comment on Wednesday.

...
What To Know
Warner Bros., owner of The Bachelor franchise, sent a cease-and-desist letter to Fox News Media alleging that promotional material for The Vow improperly uses elements associated with its long-running dating series.
According to the letter, per Variety, the teaser includes falling red rose petals, references to The Bachelor, a tuxedo-clad man holding a rose and a mansion backdrop that Warner Bros. argues evokes the show's iconic setting. The company said the trailer appears designed to capitalize on the goodwill built by The Bachelor over more than two decades.
The Vow is a dating competition series that follows single men and women exploring whether shared values and long-term commitment can lead to lasting love. It is scheduled to premiere in November and is hosted by Harrison, who fronted The Bachelor from 2002 until 2021.
Fox has rejected the accusations, arguing that Warner Bros. does not own exclusive rights to common romantic imagery or to the use of the phrase "the bachelor" in its ordinary meaning.
Can Roses and Romantic Imagery Be Protected?
Karsenty, a partner at Donaldson Callif Perez LLP, told Newsweek that Warner Bros. faces challenges if it attempts to claim ownership over broad dating-show conventions.
"Fox has a strong argument that red roses, falling rose petals, tuxedos and mansion imagery are not protectable on their own," Karsenty said.
She noted that courts generally exclude stock genre elements and standard conventions when evaluating copyright claims. In her view, Warner Bros.' strongest argument is not ownership of roses or romance-themed visuals, but whether Fox copied the specific creative execution of Bachelor promotional materials.

...
"If the teaser closely tracks the lighting, pacing, shot sequence, graphics, music, layout and overall execution of identifiable Bachelor promo assets, Warner Bros. has a more plausible copyright theory," she said.
Karsenty added that, based on publicly reported facts, the copyright claim appears vulnerable unless Warner Bros. can identify similarities involving specific protected expression rather than familiar dating show motifs.
Why Chris Harrison Could Be Important
While Harrison's involvement does not create a copyright issue, Karsenty said it could strengthen Warner Bros.' trademark arguments.
Warner Bros. has acknowledged that it does not object to Harrison hosting another dating show. Instead, the dispute focuses on how he is presented alongside imagery that audiences may associate with The Bachelor.
Related Story

Who Was Jennifer Eckhart? Ex-Fox Producer and Podcast Host Found Dead
Karsenty said the combination of rose-related visuals, references to The Bachelor and Harrison's appearance could provide Warner Bros. with a stronger argument that consumers might perceive a connection between the two programs.
"The issue is whether the teaser uses Harrison together with Bachelor-specific cues in a way that suggests affiliation, sponsorship or approval by The Bachelor franchise," she said.
At the same time, she said Fox has several potential defenses. One is that the teaser uses references to The Bachelor in an expressive or parodic way rather than as branding. Karsenty noted that lines such as "Expecting someone else?" and "Roses fade..." may support that interpretation.
Similar Cases Have Struggled In Court
Karsenty pointed to the 2012 legal fight between Big Brother and ABC's The Glass House as a useful comparison.
In that dispute, CBS argued that The Glass House copied key aspects of Big Brother's reality-show format. A court declined to block the competing series, reasoning that reality television formats often rely on broad concepts rather than highly specific, protectable creative expression.
Related Story

How ‘Scrubs’ Became TV’s Funniest Answer to Shows Like ‘The Pitt’
According to Karsenty, that ruling could help Fox if Warner Bros. is attempting to claim ownership over common dating-show features or genre conventions.
However, she said the comparison is not exact because Warner Bros.' claims focus primarily on marketing materials rather than the underlying concept of a reality dating competition.
What Happens Next
Fox has maintained that references in the teaser are protected speech and that imagery such as falling roses has long been used across film and television.
Warner Bros. has not publicly expanded on its allegations beyond the cease-and-desist letter.
If the dispute continues, the central question may be whether viewers would reasonably believe The Vow is connected to or endorsed by The Bachelor, or whether the teaser merely references a well-known television franchise while promoting a separate show.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Megyn Cartwright and Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines