A helicopter sprays a pesticide over a farmer's crop.

...

Jasmine Laws

By Jasmine Laws

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has approved a herbicide that was twice banned by two different federal courts, sparking concern from environmental and health advocacy groups.

The EPA's approvals of the herbicide dicamba in 2020 and 2024 were found unlawful by different federal courts, in part because the agency's claims that the chemical was safe to use were "irresponsible and unlawful."

The Trump administration EPA said in its February 6 announcement that it had established the "strongest protections in agency history for over-the-top (OTT) dicamba application on dicamba-tolerant cotton and soybean crops," acknowledging that "the ecological risks associated with dicamba drift and volatility are real."

Read More on News

However, groups like the Center for Food Safety have said they do not think these protections will be enough to avoid the serious harms the chemical can cause.

The EPA told Newsweek that it "fully agrees that dicamba drift and ecological risks are real, and that recognition is exactly why the agency designed the toughest set of protections ever required for over‑the‑top dicamba use."

Why It Matters

Dicamba is a herbicide, similar to the chemical 2,-4-D. It is often used on home lawns, farms, golf courses, and roadsides. However, the U.S. Department of Agriculture estimates that around 15 million acres of soybeans were damaged by dicamba drift in 2018 alone. The term drift refers to when the herbicide travels beyond the intended areas, causing widespread damage.

There have also been studies finding that exposure to dicamba may increase the risk of developing certain cancers. In a 2024 survey of pesticides' effect on cancer incidence, dicamba was "consistently at the top of the list in regions with a high added risk of colon cancer and pancreatic cancer," the study authors noted.

Given its risks, after the first Trump EPA registered dicamba for use in 2018, the approval was revoked by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in 2020, as the court ruled the approval was unlawful given the "enormous and unprecedented damage" caused by dicamba.

The EPA then reapproved the pesticide for use in 2020, and in 2024, the U.S. District Court of Arizona in Tucson overturned the move, on the basis that it violated the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act.

Regardless of these previous court rulings, the second Trump administration EPA has now brought the same pesticide back for use. Despite Trump and Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. voicing their concerns over the harm of pesticides on human health, the agency has been approving more pesticides over the past year, including five pesticides containing per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS).

A helicopter sprays a pesticide over a farmer's crop.

...

The EPA's New Approval of Dicamba

The EPA said its decision was made to support America's cotton and soybean farmers, who the agency said have been facing "critical challenges" without access to the chemical, as it helps to control resistant weeds in their growing crops.

The agency said that herbicide-resistant weeds like Palmer amaranth have become "nearly impossible to control with other available tools, threatening crop yields and farm viability."

The EPA said these weeds can grow three inches per day, destroying entire fields of crops, and that without "effective weed management during the growing season, these producers face devastating economic losses."

"This temporary approval reflects the voices of farmers who depend on this tool using informed restrictions and safety measures," the EPA said.

The agency also acknowledged the risks of the herbicide to Newsweek, but said the "scientific literature that raised potential risks, such as studies in pesticide applicators showing possible associations with certain cancers, involves decades of intensive occupational exposure to multiple pesticides, not the far lower, intermittent exposures that typical consumers or nearby residents experience."

The EPA said it still took these findings "very seriously," using them to design its protections, and that it also evaluated exposure to dicamba via drinking water and food as part of a full dietary assessment, finding "no risks of concern for infants, children, or adults."

"Because occupational studies focus on high-end, long-term applicator exposures, EPA uses them as a conservative anchor," the agency said. "If applicators can be protected with multiple layers of safeguards, then the general public, with much lower exposure, will also be protected. For typical consumers, exposure comes primarily through residues in food and potential low-level environmental contact, both of which remain well below levels of concern under the strengthened label."

In order to reduce "drift, minimize volatility, and protect ecosystems," the EPA has brought in a number of measures, including that the maximum application rate will be cut in half, reducing the amount of the chemical released into the atmosphere and environment.

The agency is also bringing in temperature-based application limits, meaning farmers will only be allowed to spray the chemical on 50 percent of their crop on a day with a forecasted temperature between 85 to 95 degrees Fahrenheit.

The EPA is also restricting who has access to use the chemical, so that applications are only made by "trained professionals who understand the risks."

There are also a number of other safety and risk mitigation measures the EPA is bringing in alongside the approval of the chemical, and the EPA emphasized that "these restrictions are not optional suggestions. They are enforceable legal requirements." Those who do not follow them may face civil fines, and even criminal prosecution, the agency said.

The Remaining Concern Around Dicamba

However, groups like the Center for Food Safety remain deeply concerned that the EPA's decision will only result in further harm to the environment and American communities.

Bill Freese, science director at Center for Food Safety said that dicamba is "extremely volatile, and often volatilizes from plant surfaces and the ground as much as four days after a spray operation, and then moves long distances to cause devastating "fencerow to fencerow" damage." He added that the EPA's restrictions "cannot do anything to stop such volatile drift."

Freese also said that these are "not the strongest protections," adding that EPA has now eliminated a rule that prohibited spraying after June 30 for soybeans in the "volatile-drift-enhancing heat of the summer."

He said that as a result, there is "no doubt that dicamba will continue to cause unprecedented drift damage miles from where it is sprayed, impacting non-dicamba-resistant soybeans as well as vegetable farms, gardens, fruit orchards, trees and wild plants that pollinators depend on for sustenance."

Beekeepers in Arkansas have seen up to a 50 percent reduction in honey production as a result of dicamba drift as well, Freese said, and he added that Missouri scientists have "documented toxic rainfall in areas of intensive dicamba use."

National Cancer Institute scientists have also found that farmers "most highly exposed to dicamba had elevated risk of liver and intrahepatic bile duct cancer compared to farmers who didn’t use it," Freese said, while Canadian scientists found that dicamba using farmers had "a higher risk of non-Hodgkin lymphoma, an immune system cancer that is also associated with glyphosate use (glyphosate and dicamba are often applied as a mixture)."

Update 2/10/26, 3:01 a.m. ET: This article has been updated with comment from the EPA and to clarify comments from Bill Freese.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines