Newsweek/Getty

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The boos began after 22 minutes, which is exactly when they should have. In Dallas, during England’s 4-2 World Cup win over Croatia, referee Clément Turpin stopped the match for the first of FIFA's mandatory hydration breaks, and jeers rolled round the stadium from supporters who had not crossed the Atlantic to watch soccer discover the interval. FIFA's rule is simple: three minutes midway through each half, in every match, regardless of temperature. In Dallas, it was almost farcical because the outside temperature had pushed close to 95 F but inside the air-conditioned stadium, it was about 72 F.

On the surface, the fans have a strong argument. Soccer is not supposed to keep stopping. Critics say the breaks kill the flow of the game, while others see them as a cynical way to divide matches into four advertiser-friendly quarters.

But then the soccer kept making FIFA look reasonable. England’s 4-2 win over Croatia was one of a run of high-scoring results: the Netherlands beat Sweden 5-1, Japan beat Tunisia 4-0, Spain beat Saudi Arabia 4-0, Argentina beat Austria 2-0, France beat Iraq 3-0, and Norway edged Senegal 3-2. Up to June 22, the tournament had produced 134 goals in 44 matches, a rate of just over three goals a game.

Read More on Analysis

The purists might hate it, and they might have a point about the tackiness. But there is an uncomfortable possibility: FIFA has made soccer better.

Common Knowledge

Traditionalists say soccer's charm is that it refuses to stop for you. Go for a drink, miss a goal. Check your phone, miss the calamity that explains the next 40 years of English trauma. There is also hostility to excessive advertising, though arguably that ship sailed long ago.

Panama coach Thomas Christiansen summarized that view, telling Reuters after his side's 1-0 defeat by Ghana: "It was not hot, but we have to accept that the advertisers (on) television is what's paying for all these things."

Uncommon Knowledge

The pro-break case has strengthened as the tournament has gone on. Iraq were holding Norway 0-0 when a hydration break arrived in Boston, then conceded four minutes after play resumed and eventually lost 4-1. Curaçao equalized against Germany shortly before a break, only for Germany to rediscover its rhythm and win 7-1. England's chaotic win over Croatia was interrupted twice, but still produced six goals and one of the tournament’s defining early spectacles.

A second wave of results made the pattern harder to dismiss. Lionel Messi scored twice as Argentina beat Austria 2-0, breaking Miroslav Klose’s all-time World Cup goals record and taking his career tournament total to 18. Kylian Mbappé scored twice on his 100th France appearance as France beat Iraq 3-0 after a two-hour storm delay in Philadelphia. Erling Haaland scored twice as Norway beat Senegal 3-2, giving Norway back-to-back World Cup wins for the first time.

After the first round of group matches, the tournament had produced 75 goals in 24 matches, the highest at this stage since 1958.

The fear was that expansion to 48 teams would bloat the World Cup. Instead, the early tournament has given us something weirder: lots of goals without endless walkovers. Germany’s 7-1 win over Curaçao is the obvious exception, but the same opening stretch also gave us Spain 0-0 Cape Verde, Portugal 1-1 DR Congo, Belgium 0-0 Iran, Brazil 1-1 Morocco, Uruguay 2-2 Cape Verde and Ghana 1-0 Panama.

Hydration breaks did not create all of that. They did not teach Haaland to finish, make Messi ageless or persuade defenders to panic near Mbappé. But if FIFA is trying to make the game playable at modern speed in hostile conditions, the results suggest the product may be benefiting.

The Dallas example in the England-Croatia match looks absurd. Yes, the stadium was air-conditioned. Yes, the optics were terrible. But the tournament is being staged across the United States, Mexico and Canada in summer, across multiple climates, time zones and stadium designs. FIFA's blunt rule avoids the endless argument over whether a specific match is hot enough.

That reset can change games, which is why coaches use it and fans distrust it. A pause lets a struggling team reorganize. This is not anti-soccer. Soccer has always been about teams adapting, but previously it smuggled in such tactical changes during injuries, goal celebrations and conveniently slow throw-ins.

The rest of the innovation package points in the same direction. A restart countdown is designed to reduce time-wasting. A referee bodycam gives television viewers a better sense of how fast and messy the sport is at pitch level. The upgraded offside system is designed to produce quicker decisions and clearer explanations.

That is why the Dallas boos may age badly. The fans thought they were defending soccer from FIFA, and FIFA remains FIFA: pompous, commercial, absurdly fond of solving problems it partly created. But at this World Cup, the institution everyone loves to hate may have highlighted a difficult truth: soccer can be improved with a little American thinking.

Then England drew 0-0 with Ghana. Perfect. FIFA may have made soccer better, but soccer can still surprise.

In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.

When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines