Experts Debate Florida Immigration Bill

...

Carine Harb

By Carine Harb

Associate Editor, My Turn

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Florida's TRUMP Act, a controversial immigration bill, has passed through the state legislature, but remains stalled as Governor Ron DeSantis has pledged to veto it.

The bill aimed to strengthen immigration enforcement in Florida as part of President Donald Trump's broader crackdown on illegal immigration. It proposed allocating $500 million to improve coordination between state, local, and federal authorities and sought to increase criminal penalties for undocumented immigrants convicted of crimes, including potentially implementing the death penalty in certain cases.

Speaking at a roundtable event in Palm Beach County on January 30, 2025, DeSantis harshly criticized the legislation, calling it a "very grotesque" and "weak" for not going far enough in tackling illegal immigration.

Read More on News

One of his biggest concerns was a provision that would have shifted immigration enforcement powers to Florida's Agriculture Commissioner, Wilton Simpson, rather than keeping them under his administration's control. DeSantis' opposition to this bill has heightened tensions with Republican lawmakers, who pushed the legislation as a key measure to align Florida's policies with Trump's national immigration agenda.

Newsweek has reached out to experts for their analysis on the potential implications of the bill if it were to become law, as well as their perspectives on DeSantis' stance and its broader impact.

Experts Debate Florida Immigration Bill

...

From Professor Michael A. Leeds: Florida Immigration Bill Makes No Economic Sense

Apart from the inhumanity of this legislation and Governor Desantis' response, such laws will inevitably impose significant hardships on the people it is supposed to protect.

For the sake of argument, let's assume that the laws succeed in driving all undocumented aliens from Florida. This will significantly reduce the supply of workers to the "3-D" occupations, jobs that are Dirty, Dangerous, and Demeaning. At best, this will significantly increase the cost of providing these services—at worst, they will go unperformed.

Home construction and repair, hospital stays, and agricultural produce will all become significantly more expensive. Florida's state budget will also come under pressure, as undocumented aliens tend to pay more into the system in taxes than they take out in benefits.

In sum, the legislation makes no economic sense. Governor DeSantis' response can be discounted as mere political grandstanding. It is all a sad commentary on the state of public policy in America.

Michael A. Leeds, Professor of Economics, Temple University, Philadelphia.

From Dr. Aubrey Jewett: Florida's Immigration Bill is Not Weak, But May Hurt The Economy

Objectively, the legislature's bill is not "weak" on illegal immigration. It creates a bunch of new policies to crack down on illegal immigration in Florida making life much harder for people living here without documentation and much easier for them to be removed by the federal government with much more assistance from the state.

It is different than the governor's bill in several major ways, including putting oversight and enforcement of the new law under the Commissioner of Agriculture instead of the Governor. It requires law enforcement to use their best efforts to cooperate with federal immigration authorities but does not threaten law enforcement with job loss or financial penalties, and it would not track and/or make it unlawful for undocumented people to wire money to family back in their home country.

Politically, this is bringing Florida back to what we have normally seen—and what is found in most states over time—the legislature is a coequal branch of government with the executive branch.

But we don't know for sure what will happen yet and DeSantis could yet impose his will on the legislature. The big unknown currently is Donald Trump. If he takes a side the fight will likely end pretty quickly, and if he sides with the governor, the legislature will almost certainly back down. If he backs the legislature than DeSantis' political reputation will take a big hit. If Trump stays out of the fight, then it might be a long battle, but DeSantis will clearly be politically weaker than he has been and his political prospects for the future somewhat dimmer.

If there is a big crackdown on illegal immigration in Florida across the board then it will hurt the state's economy. There are an estimated 800,000 to a million undocumented or illegal immigrants in Florida and most of them are working in agriculture, construction, and the service industry like hotels and restaurants.

Aubrey Jewett, PhD, Associate Professor and Associate Director, School of Politics, Security, and International Affairs (SPSIA), University of Central Florida (UCF), Treasurer, Florida Political Science Association (FPSA).

From Jessica M. Vaughan: Florida's Immigration Bill Fails to Deter Illegal Migration or Employment

The bill proposed by the legislature offers modest improvements to the way local law enforcement agencies can interact with federal immigration authorities, but refrains from measures that would work more directly to address human trafficking, cartel and gang activity, and human smuggling.

Moreover, it does not offer measures that would deter illegal migration or illegal employment, such as tackling the problem of remittances and their connection to money laundering and other transnational crime networks.

These problems are so big in Florida now that the federal government badly needs the help of state authorities, and cannot do it alone. As long as Florida tolerates illegal immigration and the criminal infrastructure that supports it, this problem will continue to be a drag on state taxpayers. Voters spoke very clearly in November that they want to see more action on illegal immigration, and this bill is going to disappoint them.

This bill is not only weak, it seems like an attempt to undermine the progress that Gov. DeSantis has made in combating illegal immigration in Florida. Not only does it avoid enacting the important reforms that were crafted based on years of investigation by state agencies and a statewide grand jury, it would give control of state enforcement actions to the state Agricultural agency.

The Agriculture commissioner is not a law enforcement officer, and typically represents special interests that benefit from illegal immigration, so it's hard to imagine how this person could be effective in leading anti-illegal immigration efforts in the state.

Jessica M. Vaughan, Director of Policy Studies, Center for Immigration Studies, Washington, D.C.

From Dr. Hector H. Sandoval: Florida Labor Shortage May Raise Wages and Costs

A reduction in undocumented workers would shrink Florida's labor supply, particularly in industries reliant on immigrant labor, such as hospitality, agriculture, and construction. The implementation of the bill could further constrain workforce availability in these sectors, making it harder for businesses to fill positions. As a result, firms may need to raise wages, which could drive up business costs and potentially lead to higher consumer prices. However, the overall impact will depend on how effectively the bill is enforced.

Hector H. Sandoval, Director of the Economic Analysis Program at the UF's Bureau of Economic and Business Research (BEBR), University of Florida.

From Professor Ingrid V. Eagly: TRUMP Legislation Would be a Significant Drain on State Economy

Governor DeSantis has called the legislation "weak," but what he really seems to object to is the Commissioner of Agriculture serving in the role of chief immigration enforcer rather than the Governor.

If enacted, the law would be a significant drain on the state economy, as it commits more than $500 million in state tax dollars to engage in immigration enforcement, an obligation of the federal government. Additional state tax dollars would be spent defending legal challenges that will be brought against the enforcement of the law.

Ingrid V. Eagly, Professor of Law, UCLA School of Law, Los Angeles, California.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines