10
Loading video...

By Brendan Cole
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The former director of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) has questioned whether the Russian laboratory at the center of a possible plague death had modified the bacterial disease, as world leaders demand answers over the case.
Robert Redfield, who led the agency at the start of the COVID pandemic, said he was concerned at Russia’s response to the death of Darya Shipilova, 28, who worked at the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Research Institute in Siberia.
Rospotrebnadzor, Russia’s health watchdog, said that Shipilova died from "pneumonia of unknown aetiology" but unconfirmed reports she had accidentally broken a test tube containing the live bacteria that causes pneumonic plague prompted alarm.
Read More on World
Around 200 people Shipilova came into contact with have been placed under observation, according to reports, and hospitals and a maternity unit in the region have also been quarantined.

...
"The Russians have really reacted pretty aggressively," Redfield said, adding that pneumonic plague is not very infectious and that the last human-to-human transmission of the disease in the U.S. took place in 1924.
"Could it be plague that was manipulated to be more transmissible as, say, in a dual-use military bioweapons program or could it be another pathogen?" he added.
Newsweek has contacted Rospotrebnadzor for comment.
Redfield said if the lab technician had an accident, there would have been a protocol for her to go on antibiotics.
"If the plague that she was working with had been manipulated to not be sensitive to antibiotics, which some of the bio-offensive programs that the Russians have done, both with plague and anthrax, that would explain why maybe they didn’t work," he told News Nation.
The U.S., the European Union and the World Health Organization have all called on Russia for transparency over the case. President Donald Trump said he would address the issue in a conversation with Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Amos Weiskopf, editor of Plague News.com which tracks media reports of the disease, told Newsweek on Thursday that Russia’s response to the case could be over-cautious containment of a routine accident, or could be a way to quietly manage a bigger exposure than the official line admits.
Related Story

The Russia Plague Paradox Is Frightening
A multi-hospital lockdown, FSB involvement, hazmat gear and 200 contacts under observation were "out of proportion for a lab-acquired plague case," Weiskopf said.
The independent People of Baikal Telegram channel reported that those in contact with the lab worker had been taken away in ambulances escorted by members of the FSB, Russia’s main intelligence agency. Reports of FSB involvement in the response have not been confirmed but have added to claims of a cover-up by Russian authorities.
The altered antibiotic sensitivity theory means the strain may not respond to drugs normally used to treat plague, such as streptomycin, gentamicin, doxycycline and cipro, said Weiskopf.
"If true, that's the single strongest piece of evidence for anything beyond a wild-type accident, because natural Y. pestis resistant to first-line antibiotics is exceptionally rare," he said.
Kevin Esvelt, a prominent biologist, posted on X that there is no evidence so far that the pathogen that killed Shipilova would cause a pandemic but the response to her death "clearly indicates that Russia believes an epidemic is possible—and that the responsible agent is likely a pandemic weapon or otherwise embarrassing for the government."
Raj Panjabi, a former health adviser in the Biden administration, told News Now that Russia should share its information about what killed the lab worker.
The place she worked would certainly be able to do genomic sequencing to answer that question.
"We don’t yet have a sequence of whatever pathogen that she died from," Panjabi said. "That should be available within days, and that can tell us and settle whether this is a natural pathogen, a lab strain or something altered."
Russian Outlets Reject Plague Claims
Adding to the mystery of the case are conflicting accounts about how the lab worker died, with Russian telegram channels playing down reports of plague.
Local media reported that Shipilova became ill after breaking a test tube in a lab, but colleagues rejected this explanation, according to Siberia Realities, the Siberian version of U.S.-funded Radio Free Europe.
However, independent outlet the Baikal Journal, linked to the People of Baikal Telegram channel, reported that five hospitals were put under quarantine restrictions. Pro-government Telegram channels rejected the reports.
However, the outlet said that restrictions imposed on October 3 remained in place at the Irkutsk Regional Clinical Hospital and another regional clinic.
"People of Baikal noted that some pro-government media outlets, which reported on a possible plague, including restrictions in Irkutsk hospitals, later deleted their reports," it added.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Tobias Meyjes and Tony Phillips.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines