10
Loading video...

By Deanne Criswell
Former Administrator, FEMA
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
I've been an emergency manager for nearly three decades, and one thing has never changed: All disasters begin and end at the local level. Whether I was leading emergency operations in a small town or in the nation's largest city, this fundamental truth remained the same—local responders are the first line of defense. But they can't do it alone.
Emergency management has long followed this principle: local execution, state management, federal support. Local firefighters, EMS, police, and emergency managers are always the first on scene. When local capacity is overwhelmed, they reach out to the state. When the state needs more, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) steps in. FEMA doesn't supplant local responders; it supports them. This system can take days to escalate—or mere hours when disaster strikes fast, like it did in Western North Carolina last year or Kerr County, Texas, this past week.
Let's be clear: FEMA does not take over response operations. It supports them. And in a disaster, time is our most precious resource.
Read More
Donald Trump, Deep State Swamp Monster | Opinion4 min read

Federal Workers Took an Oath. Now We’re Taking a Stand Against ICE | Opinion5 min read

How To Ruin a Country’s Image, Economy, and Global Standing in Six Easy Steps | Opinion7 min read

FEMA exists to support states and communities when they need help the most. But the system only works when it's allowed to work. In recent months, we've seen challenges that could limit FEMA's ability to lead: reduced grant funding, constrained hiring authorities, and administrative delays that slow or sideline responses. These moves don't just weaken FEMA—they weaken the entire emergency management system.
One of the most powerful tools we have to save lives is early warning. Sirens, wireless alerts, NOAA weather radios—these systems work. But they require trust and investment. Communities must have the training and system access they need to issue warnings. FEMA's grant and technical assistance programs make this possible, especially for smaller jurisdictions. Yet already, one major grant program has been eliminated, stripping communities of their chance to install or maintain life-saving systems.
FEMA's grants fund nearly half the emergency management workforce in many communities. These dollars support planning, training, staffing, and early warning systems—tools that are essential in the face of increasing threats, such as hurricanes, wildfires, floods, and even cyberattacks. Without this federal support, we're asking local governments to meet 21st-century risks with 20th-century tools.
We've been here before.
Nearly 20 years ago, Hurricane Katrina exposed critical failures in our disaster response system. FEMA was unprepared, under-resourced, and poorly integrated with other agencies. Still settling into the newly created Department of Homeland Security, the agency suffered from dysfunctional coordination and confusion about who was in charge. Some in top leadership had no emergency management experience. Political affiliations, not qualifications, shaped appointments. Bureaucracy slowed life-saving action. People died.

...
In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, FEMA was restructured and strengthened through the Post-Katrina Emergency Management Reform Act, which clarified the agency's authorities and restored some of its autonomy within DHS. The law mandated two key reforms: First, the FEMA administrator must have real, on-the-ground emergency management experience. Second, FEMA was elevated to a presidentially appointed, Senate-confirmed position with direct access to the president during disasters, cutting through red tape to speed up response. It also introduced the concept of response doctrine through the National Response Framework, based on five key principles: engaged partnership, tiered response, scalable/flexible/adaptable operations, unity of effort through unified command, and readiness to act. These reforms weren't partisan—they were about saving lives.
Emergency management standards are born from tragedy. But the farther we get from Katrina, the more those hard-won lessons seem forgotten. In the case of this week's floods in Texas, FEMA was ready to respond—but was delayed by administrative hurdles and approval processes that took 72 hours to resolve. That's time we can never get back. And in emergencies, delayed help can cost lives.
Imagine a major hurricane bearing down on Florida while wildfires rage in California and floods surge across the Midwest. That's not a hypothetical—it's our new normal. And we're talking about dismantling the very system designed to protect us from it.
So now what?
I've spent my career responding to crises. I've seen how quickly lives can change, and how deeply preparedness matters. The choices we make now will shape how this nation weathers the storms ahead—literally and figuratively. If we continue down the path of dismantling FEMA, we're not just inviting disaster. We're guaranteeing it.
Helping people before, during, and after disaster is not just FEMA's job—it's America's promise to everyone who calls this great nation home. Every level of government has a role to play. Of course the system can improve. But reforms must be thoughtful, informed by experience, and shaped in partnership with the state, tribal, territorial, and local emergency managers who rely on FEMA's support.
Now is not the time to weaken FEMA. Instead, we must strengthen it with the essential tools, resources, and leadership to confront future challenges head-on. Emergency managers across the country are working tirelessly, and they don't need theatrics. What they need is genuine partnership and unwavering support. It's time to come together and ensure all emergency managers, including FEMA, have everything they need to protect and serve our communities effectively.
Today, we mourn the lives lost in Kerrville, Texas. But tomorrow, it could be any community—your community or mine. The threats we face are increasing, not diminishing. We can't afford to strip away the resources or experience needed to respond.
We must remember the lessons of our past—so we don't repeat them in our future.
Deanne Criswell was the 12th FEMA Administrator and confirmed unanimously by the U.S. Senate. Previously, she served as lead emergency manager for New York City and Aurora, Colorado. She also was a fire firefighter and a member of the Colorado Air National Guard.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines