10
Loading video...

By Alice Gibbs
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
As a federal judge extended an order blocking the Trump administration from breaking ground on a 250ft triumphal arch in the nation’s capital, one group has shared their idea for an alternative.
A temporary restraining order blocking the project was due to expire on Thursday, but U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan extended it by 14 days—keeping the administration from starting construction until at least December 3.
The idea of erecting a triumphal arch in the memorial circle between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington Cemetery has received substantial backlash from advocacy groups for Washington, D.C. and even veterans and their families.
Read More on U.S.
Analysis found that more than 75,000 graves would be overshadowed in the National Cemetery over the course of a year, while members of the Kennedy family called President Donald Trump's plans for a 250-foot arch, close to the Arlington National Cemetery, a "permanent denigration" of their relatives' grave sites.

...
Alternative To Triumphal Arch Suggested
While a legal battle over the administration’s design continues, two Harvard landscape architecture students developed alternative designs for Memorial Circle in collaboration with The Cultural Landscape Foundation (TCLF), after taking a course taught by the foundation's president, Charles Birnbaum.
Students Jeremy Dvorak and Jake Geitner subsequently worked with the foundation to develop what they describe as a “speculative counter proposal” to the administration's triumphal arch.
The two separate concepts were created during the design, both deliberately keeping the Memorial Circle relatively open and using water rather than a monumental structure.
Design 1: A Large Reflecting Pool


The first and simpler of the two designs was made up of a large circular reflecting pool in the Memorial Circle.
Using a visual axis between the Lincoln Memorial, Arlington Memorial Bridge, Memorial Avenue and Arlington National Cemetery, it would largely preserve the existing road layout and traffic circulation.
Because the intervention remains low to the ground, TCLF said it would have limited or no effect on vehicle movement and would avoid any adverse effect on nearly historic properties.
Design 2: Ceremonial Roadway


The second design provided more changes in the immediate area. Retaining the existing circular form of the Memorial Circle, the roads are reorganized around a central cobblestone axis.
That cobblestone route strengthens the physical connection from the Arlington Memorial Bridge into Memorial Avenue and toward Arlington National Cemetery, while two low, circular fountains flank the central route.
Trump previously said that the triumphal arch will be the “greatest and most beautiful triumphal arch, anywhere in the world," later adding "It’s going to be really beautiful. I think it’s going to be fantastic."
But TCLF President Birnbaum argued that the designs from the architecture students were more in tune with the public.
"Unlike the administration, we are listening to the public’s concerns—especially those of veterans and Gold Star families—and experts in the public, private and non-profit sectors who have advocated to protect one of the nation’s most solemn and symbolic cultural landscapes," Birnbaum said.
"These provocations, by design, illustrate that a solution that honors, embraces and works in collaboration with Memorial Circle’s historical and physical contexts is not only possible, but should be explored if this memorial is to truly commemorate the nation’s 250th anniversary.”
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Rebecca Flood and Emma Lee-Sang
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines