Supporters of LGBTQ+ rights hold rainbow-colored umbrellas as they demonstrate outside of the U.S. Supreme Court Building on April 22, 2025 in Washington, DC.

...

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


It landed like news of yet another skirmish in America’s long-running civil conflict over religion, sexuality, and schools.

On Monday, the Supreme Court agreed to hear a challenge from Catholic preschools in Colorado that want access to the state’s taxpayer-funded Universal Preschool Program (UPK).

They want that money without complying with Colorado’s rule that families get an "equal opportunity" to enroll, which compels them to admit those who don’t align with traditional Catholic views on homosexuality, sex, and gender.

Read More on Analysis

Same old unresolved church and state conflict. But the case is more instructive than that in the Trump era, during which the tide has shifted back toward cultural conservatism. It says something about an emerging, broader pattern.

The culture war is transmuting from the kind of free-speech conflict that tore through campuses into a fiscal one, where clashes take place over eligibility rules, grant conditions, and benefit design, rather than wokeism and library books.

Put simply, it’s all about taxpayer money—your cash—and who gets it.

What the Colorado Preschool Case Is Really About

Colorado’s UPK program grew out of a 2020 voter-approved proposition and subsequent legislation creating a mixed system of public and private providers.

Providers that want state funds must sign a nondiscrimination agreement promising eligible children an equal opportunity to enroll regardless of race, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, gender identity, income, or disability.

The Catholic plaintiffs argue that Colorado lets other providers favor low-income families or children with disabilities while excluding Catholic schools because their admissions policies require support for Catholic beliefs on sex and gender.

They see the exclusion as unconstitutional discrimination against faith-based preschools and a limit on parental choice.

But the Court did not take up a speech dispute, as it had done in previous cases on similar issues, like the infamous gay wedding cake, also, incidentally, from Colorado. It took up a case about the terms on which a state may distribute public benefits.

The questions the justices accepted ask whether Colorado’s rule is generally applicable under Employment Division v. Smith and whether Carson v. Makin changes the analysis.

The Tenth Circuit affirmed Colorado, saying the state’s nondiscrimination rule "exists in harmony with the First Amendment" and serves an "extraordinarily weighty" interest in equal access to preschool.

The ACLU of Colorado, in an amicus posture, has made the same point more bluntly: a government may condition a public benefit on a religion-neutral and generally applicable requirement.

This is the deeper significance than yet another free speech fight.

It’s a battle over who qualifies, who is excluded, and whether taxpayers must finance institutions whose participation rules would exclude many of them.

RFK's MAHA Mission

The Colorado case comes at the same time as Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. pushes a budget that cuts HHS discretionary spending to $111.1 billion while elevating Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) priorities.

At his first congressional hearing since September, Kennedy defended a proposed cut of more than 12 percent to HHS’s budget and highlighted the administration’s effort to reform dietary guidelines and crack down on "waste, fraud and abuse."

But his 2027 budget also proposes a new Administration for a Healthy America and requests $57 million for food-supply initiatives including chemical removal, PFAS work, and a shift from petroleum-based synthetic dyes to natural alternatives.

It shows that MAHA is more than some throwaway slogan. It’s a map of fiscal power over culture from an administration that intends to wield it.

Coverage of Kennedy still often centers on his long record of vaccine skepticism and the clashes it triggered at his latest hearing. But budgets reveal hard priorities more than point-scoring rhetoric on Capitol Hill.

A line item can outlast a sound bite. A reorganization can steer what agencies study, what they stop funding, and which harms they define as urgent.

Once culture politics enters a budget, it’s no longer merely expressive of desire.

It’s the machinery that decides which programs shrink, which prevention campaigns expand, and which expertise the government treats as authoritative.

The SNAPback

This is already playing out in SNAP, or food stamps, where at the start of this year five state SNAP waivers, restricting the purchase of "non-nutritious items," and affecting about 1.4 million people, came into force.

In total, so far, 22 states have now had waivers approved by USDA, most of them governed by Republicans. Different states are banning soda, soft drinks, energy drinks, candy, or broad categories of taxable junk food.

Earlier waiver requests had been denied after USDA research concluded that such restrictions would be costly and complicated to implement and might not change buying habits or reduce obesity.

Under the current administration, however, USDA and HHS encouraged governors to seek waivers, though there is no clear common definition of "non-nutritious items." Soda is the most commonly restricted item.

Researchers say the variation between states is substantial, definitions differ, and strong evaluation is still needed to know whether the restrictions improve diet quality or health outcomes.

States justified the rules with arguments about SNAP’s nutritional purpose, health-care costs, and stewardship of taxpayer dollars.

Why should those on benefits designed to improve nutrition for low-income families spend taxpayer dollars on health-destroying treats like candy and soda?

Then again, why should the state dictate an individual’s choices in how they spend the money? Aren’t poor people entitled to enjoy treats too?

This is where culture war’s moral rhetoric translated into bar codes.

The argument has moved beyond the hypothetical, from whether junk food is decadent or whether elites are patronizing the poor, and into the real world.

Now, it’s about whether a family’s grocery basket clears the register, whether a retailer’s compliance software flags the right product, and whether a welfare program is being redefined through administrative experiment rather than congressional rewrite.

Victory by Changing the Rules

This mechanism is the point. Culture wars are ultimately won at the sharp end of policy decisions, not the tongue.

Look at higher education. In January, Trump directed every federal agency to identify the civil and criminal authorities available to combat campus antisemitism, turning a moral crusade into hard administrative leverage.

By spring, a multi-agency task force had opened a review of Harvard’s federal contracts and grants.

The administration later froze $2.2 billion in grants and $60 million in contracts after Harvard rejected demands for leadership reforms, admissions changes, and restrictions on campus activism.

Cornell, by contrast, accepted a deal requiring payments and compliance commitments in exchange for restoring more than $250 million in withheld research funding.

Taken separately, each fight can sound technical or even banal. Taken together, they show an effective governing strategy that is moving from symbols to systems.

Control over public money, that’s how the culture war is waged now. And, under a Democratic administration, it may well swing back the other way.

Americans can ignore a thousand rhetorical skirmishes. They cannot ignore the moment when ideology shows up in the price of child care, the rules at the grocery checkout, or the standards that determine who gets served by the state.

Culture warriors are putting your money where their mouth is.


Hey gang, Carlo Versano here. I hope you enjoyed this article. As Newsweek's Director of Politics and Culture and editor of the 1600 newsletter, I'm keen to hear what you think. Now, Newsweek is offering a new service to allow you to communicate directly with me in the form of a text message chat. You can sign up and get a direct line to me, as well as the reporters who work for me. You can shape our coverage.

As a Newsweek member, we're offering this service to you for free. You can sign up below, or read more about how it works here. Let's talk!

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines