10
Loading video...

By Sam Stevenson
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Democrats won control of the Senate in November’s midterms, but the victory has sparked an internal fight over whether Chuck Schumer should lead the new majority or step aside for Chris Van Hollen.
The result will determine who controls the agenda of the incoming Democratic majority as the party faces pressure to lower living costs, confront President Donald Trump and convert its midterm gains into legislation.
Assuming every caucus member participates and a simple majority is required, a candidate would need 28 votes in a 55-member caucus or 29 in a 56-member caucus.
Read More on Politics
Newsweek’s count is based on public statements, official announcements and reports attributing a position to the senator or the senator’s office.
Because the leadership election will be conducted by secret ballot, public endorsements may not reflect the final vote.
Newsweek emailed the offices of Schumer and Van Hollen for further comment on Tuesday morning.

...
Why It Matters
The leadership fight presents Democrats with a choice between continuity and a different political direction.
Schumer points to a party that secured at least 55 Senate seats under his leadership.
Van Hollen argues that voters demanded a broader break from the status quo, including a more aggressive approach to economic policy, campaign spending and the exercise of congressional power.
Key Points
- Van Hollen formally entered the race on November 12.
- Four caucus members have publicly backed his candidacy, bringing the total to five when including Van Hollen himself.
- Sixteen have declared support for Schumer, including Schumer himself.
- Six others have ruled out Schumer or called for new leadership without endorsing his challenger.
- Nineteen have discussed the contest without publicly choosing either candidate.
- Nine members of a 55-seat caucus are not classified because no public position has been located.
Full List Of Senators Backing Chris Van Hollen
Other than Van Hollen himself, four other members of the incoming Democratic caucus have publicly backed his leadership bid. They are:
- Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan said he was the first candidate in the country to back Van Hollen in a public November 12 statement: “Van Hollen offers both the courage to go toe-to-toe with the Trump administration to deliver for working people and the experience to maneuver the Senate caucus.”
- Bernie Sanders of Vermont said on X that the American people “want a Democratic Party that will stand up to powerful special interests, take on the billionaire class and fight for working families. That is why I am supporting Senator Chris Van Hollen to lead Senate Democrats.”
- Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota endorsed him in a November 13 X post, calling him the “leader and fighter” needed to deliver change.
- Jeff Merkley of Oregon: endorsed Van Hollen for Senate majority leader in a November 13 X post, offering his “full support” and saying the party needed leadership focused on “the people, not the privileged and powerful.”
Full List Of Senators Backing Chuck Schumer
Other than Schumer, 15 other members of the incoming Democratic caucus have publicly backed his bid to remain leader:
- Angela Alsobrooks of Maryland: cited by Politico as backing Schumer.
- Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island: previously reported as saying, “Schumer delivering a Democratic Senate certainly justifies another term as leader.”
- Sherrod Brown of Ohio: reported by Punchbowl News as backing Schumer on November 9.
- Kirsten Gillibrand of New York: reported by Roll Call as backing Schumer.
- John Fetterman of Pennsylvania: reported as backing Schumer by WHTM Harrisburg.
- Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut: told reporters last week on November 9 that he planned to support Schumer, clarifying earlier remarks in which he called for “new energy and ideas” within the Democratic caucus.
- Brian Schatz of Hawaii: publicly voiced his support on November 9, Punchbowl News reported.
- Angus King of Maine: public statement endorsed Schumer on the day Van Hollen announced his challenge.
- Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada: Reaffirmed support for Schumer in a November 13 X post.
- Jacky Rosen of Nevada: confirmed her backing in a November 13 social media post, saying: “He did the work to deliver what will soon be a 56-seat Senate majority against all odds.”
- Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin: announced support in an official public statement dated November 12.
- Jack Reed of Rhode Island: announced support in an official public statement also dated November 12.
- Mark Kelly of Arizona: told Politico that he backs Schumer - but said Democrats need a new way forward.
- Mazie Hirono of Hawaii: confirmed support last Monday, telling The Washington Sun: “I have a long history with Chuck.”
- Ruben Gallego of Arizona: confirmed support on Wednesday last week, saying: “When the manager takes you to the World Series, you give him another contract. And this has been a really good election cycle for us,” KJZZ Phoenix reported.
Senators Who Will Not Back Schumer
These six members have ruled out supporting Schumer or called for new leadership without endorsing Van Hollen:
- Juliana Stratton of Illinois: has repeatedly said she will not support Schumer. After winning the Illinois Democratic primary in March, she said her position “hasn’t changed,” and she reaffirmed that pledge following her Senate victory.
- Adam Hamilton of Kansas: “I mean no disrespect for Chuck Schumer, but we need new leadership,” he told CNN in September and has since reiterated that his position has not changed.
- Troy Jackson of Maine: “I’ve told Senator Schumer I’m going to support somebody else,” he told reporters, Newsweek previously reported.
- Elissa Slotkin of Michigan: has ruled out supporting Schumer for majority leader and welcomed a contested election, telling reporters last week that she was “glad to see there’s more people getting in the race.” Although she has described having good conversations with Van Hollen, she has not publicly endorsed him.
- Annie Andrews of South Carolina: called for generational change in a November 6 Fox News interview, but is not listed as having endorsed a particular contender.
- Chris Pappas of New Hampshire: Declined to back Schumer when asked on November 12, saying he would first see who entered the contest. The Hill later reported that he had called for new leadership without endorsing Van Hollen.
Publicly Uncommitted Senators
The following members have discussed the leadership contest publicly but have not said whether they will support Schumer or Van Hollen:
- Tim Kaine of Virginia: he is weighing three factors: Schumer’s role in delivering what he called “an amazing win,” the New York senator’s experience dealing with Trump, and voters’ demand for change, according to Punchbowl News.
- Jon Ossoff of Georgia: he has not committed to either candidate and said he would hear from everyone running, according to Punchbowl News.
- Chris Murphy of Connecticut: declined to say whether Schumer should be replaced when questioned on Meet the Press, instead stressing that Senate Democrats were united as a caucus.
- Josh Turek of Iowa: avoided committing to Schumer when asked by MS NOW, saying he was “not trying to measure the drapes yet.”
- Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts: said before the midterms that “we’ll know a lot more” after the election but has not publicly endorsed either contender.
- Maria Cantwell of Washington: said she would listen to the leadership debate while giving Schumer credit for Democrats’ election victory.
- Patty Murray of Washington: said Democrats would discuss the leadership choice as a caucus and that she would not “litigate” the decision in the press.
- James Talarico of Texas: has not committed to a candidate and said he wanted to hear Schumer’s vision before deciding.
- Ed Markey of Massachusetts: declined to endorse Schumer after the election, saying his immediate priority was discussing a progressive agenda with colleagues, according to The Boston Globe.
- Michael Bennet of Colorado: would not say whether he would support Schumer, telling reporters that the caucus needed time to discuss and debate the choice.
- Raphael Warnock of Georgia: said he would hear the case of any caucus member who believed that person should lead, while separately noting that voters wanted change, per CNN.
- Martin Heinrich of New Mexico: said he would not commit to Schumer or Van Hollen, telling Punchbowl News that he planned to hear from both candidates and the incoming freshman class.
- Mark Warner of Virginia: declined to commit to Schumer during a November 10 press call, saying he wanted to see how the contest unfolded in the coming days, according to Virginia Scope.
- Peter Welch of Vermont: said Democrats were committed to change “whether it’s Schumer or not” and would wait to see who entered the race
- Chris Coons of Delaware: did not endorse either candidate in a November 13 X post, describing the contest as a debate over the right combination of experience, ability and vision.
- Andy Kim of New Jersey: declined to choose a side when questioned by MS NOW, saying the caucus’s priorities mattered more than allowing one person to determine its direction
- Cory Booker of New Jersey: called the leadership contests a “family conversation” and welcomed a genuine discussion within the caucus, according to AP.
- Scott Colom of Mississippi: suggested that regional representation will influence his decision. Speaking to MS NOW on November 6, the Mississippi senator-elect said “too many of our leaders are from the same areas of the country,” pointing to the Brooklyn backgrounds of Schumer and House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries.
- John Hickenlooper of Colorado declined to name a preferred candidate, telling Punchbowl News that examining how the caucus could improve was healthy. He also noted the tension created by challenging Schumer after Democrats flipped nine Senate seats.
Newsweek had not located a public position from the remaining nine members of the 55-member incoming caucus as of Tuesday afternoon. This list will be updated as more make their positions known.
What Happens Next
Senate Democrats are expected to hold the leadership election in early December.
Before then, both candidates must persuade members that they can unite a caucus spanning democratic socialists, institutional liberals, centrists and lawmakers elected from competitive states.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Robinson, Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines