Stock image tense in-law relationship.

...

Lydia Patrick

By Lydia Patrick

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Living with your in-laws can often prove to be a testing situation, and when finances come into play, this situation can take a turn for the worse.

Racking up 7.7K upvotes, one mom took to Reddit with a post titled "AITA (Am I The A******) for outright refusing to contribute to house bills at my [MIL's] home?"

The stay-at-home mom of four said she begrudgingly moved her family into her mother-in-law's six-bedroom farmhouse to help with her bills and basic needs, upon her husband's insistence. However, the mother-in-law has seemingly repaid her daughter-in-law by telling her she should get a job to contribute more to the bills.

Read More on Life

The mother-in-law handed over the deed of the house to her son, the poster's husband, but the bills remained in her name.

AITA for outright refusing to contribute to house bills at my MILs home?
byu/Longjumping-Oil-2771 inAITAH

Household Contribution

The mom has now taken to Reddit to complain that the mother-in-law is not contributing enough to the household even as the 59-year-old has suggested her daughter-in-law return to work. While her husband is paying $2,800 a month in bills, the mother-in-law contributes $400 despite working full-time. The poster said she does not currently work full-time but makes a "decent amount of income" from "hobby work" selling customized quilts.

The poster contributes towards food alone as per her agreement with her husband who said she need not pay for any other bills since she did not want to be there.

The mom (longjumping-oil-227) posted: "My MIL (59) fell ill last year and basically begged my husband to move us (him, me and our 4 children) in to her 6 bedroom farmhouse to help her with bills and her basic needs.

"I didn't want to do this under any circumstances but my husband pushed the issue. I felt I had zero say whatsoever but I have continuously made my distaste known."

Newsweek reached out to u/longjumping-oil-227 for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.

The contributor has been a stay-at-home mom with twins, 5, a three-year-old, and an eight-month-old.

To live in the six-bedroom house the dad contributes $2,800 a month, the mom pays for groceries and the mom-in-law contributes $400, despite making $4,000 a month, according to the contributor, which she reportedly puts into her pension pot.

Stock image tense in-law relationship.

...

According to Longjumping-Oil-2771, the mom-in-law wanted her to put her children in full-time daycare so she could get a job and contribute more to her household bills.

The mother-in-law said she wanted to quit her job due to feeling too weak after her illness, the writer shared.

The Reddit user said she had refused to put her children in daycare and that she breastfeeds her toddler.

She added: "So MIL is eating for free and having 90 percent of her bills paid for by my husband. She doesn't need anything else from us.

"But last night she started screaming at my husband about how she apparently wanted us to come here so she can retire early and that the "least we could do" is pay for everything here, since she signed over the house to us and said that I needed to "get off my ass" and contribute because he shouldn't be made to pay for everything when 'I'm more than capable'."

The conflict blew up when the daughter-in-law confronted the mother-in-law.

She wrote: "I walk in and tell her she had best stop running her mouth about me when I'm not in the room to defend myself and that I am not putting my children in daycare to make her life more cushy than she already has it.

"I told her if she wants to retire than there are plenty of retirement homes OR we could move out and she can pay for 100 percent of her bills as she was before but I refuse to do anything more than I'm doing.

"My husband told me I should have stayed out of it and let him handle it but his way of handling it is by saying "I know mom, I get what you're saying" and nothing more."

The mom asked the Reddit universe if she was being the a****** for refusing to contribute to the bills and for confronting the mother-in-law."

Reddit Reacts

So far, the post has received 1.6K comments since it was posted on June 5.

NHFNCFRE whose comment received 8.2k upvotes said: "MIL is clearly out of touch if she thinks putting 3+ kids in daycare is going to somehow save money."

Puzzleheaded-Gas1710 added: "Tell her that you will put them in daycare and take over the utilities but she is responsible for daycare costs. Then price the options."

Cwoechu said: "My Nan (bless her soul) lived to 84. She lived with us for about 8 years. I love her so much.... but living with her and my grandad put a strain on all our relationships through my teen / young adult years.

"You can wave goodbye to bonding with your kids for 'family time' because they want to be there 24 / 8."

Jem10000 said: "Your mother-in-law is only 59. do you really want to spend the next 20 to 35 years living with the woman? It's definitely time to tell your husband You will need an alternate plan. Also, you did a great job defending yourself especially since your husband was not!"

Expert Advice

Alejandra Rojas, a financial professional and founder of The Money Mindset Hub told Newsweek: "There are different family dynamics at play here that get amplified when the economic factor enters the conversation.

"When a new family starts, it starts with its own set of rules and ways of living with money.

"In this case, the husband and wife have already set up rules on how to move forward when it comes to financial contribution, raising children, and their economic outlook."

Rojas advised the husband and wife to sit down and have an honest open conversation about money, raising their concerns, limits and expectations about their future, with one or two goals they would set up before the conversation was had.

She explained: "It is important that they not only think about how to get past this now but also down the line in 3, 5, and 10 years, considering perhaps the kids' education and retirement for themselves.

"From that conversation or conversations, new decisions need to be made.

"Perhaps a lot of the financial trauma assumed from interactions with the mother-in-law and the family may arise, and it is important to clear it up.

"This is a financial topic that may be better handled with an objective third party involved, such as a financial professional, so that the conversation is facilitated and a plan can be drafted."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines