Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Getty/Courtesy of Joanna Good

Joanna Good

By Joanna Good

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


I see the reflection of his bright blue Kia in my window as I tearfully dice onions for lunch. He knocks at the door and I yell, “It’s open!”

“Hey, Mom,” he grunts as he struggles through the front door with an overflowing laundry basket. He’s never called me that before, and perhaps it was a mistake, but still I catch myself smiling as I wash and dry my hands to help him inside.

I did not raise this child. I placed him for adoption after having him as a teenager and branding myself a non-mother. Even after having my own two daughters later in life, I felt like a phony, unworthy of the title of mother, unable to be a present parent or a good role model. When my birth son came out to me as transgender as a teenager, I learned how to be a mother to him and my daughters, how to advocate for them and love them unconditionally.

Read More on My Turn

My 12-Year-Old Daughter Woke Up As Usual—That Same Day Life Changed Forever6 min read

My 12-Year-Old Daughter Woke Up As Usual—That Same Day Life Changed Forever

I Loved Tanning. 22 Years Later, I’m still Living With the Consequences9 min read

I Loved Tanning. 22 Years Later, I’m still Living With the Consequences

A Stranger Put $250 in My Kid’s Account. Twice4 min read

A Stranger Put $250 in My Kid’s Account. Twice

I became a mother one crisp Saturday night at the age of 17, while all my friends were partying in someone’s barn, drinking Schnapps for warmth. I had chosen to place my child for adoption after struggling with my mental health while living in a conservative Christian home. In the hospital, I saw the admissions clerk write “ADOPTION” at the top of my chart, and I overheard the nurses call me “birth mother” in hushed tones, treading carefully around me.

Joanna Good with Aarron as a baby. The open adoption allowed them to see each other.

...

All night my brain repeated “birth mother, not real mother” to the rhythm of the flashing red streetlight reflecting off the iced-over glass panes of the hospital window. When I first held my baby the next morning, I closed my eyes tightly and breathed in the smell of her—the blonde barely-there peach-fuzz hair freshly shampooed by a nurse, the fold on the back of her neck that still held the scent of her last home inside my body, smells that stay with me forever. I stayed that way for two hours, as nurses and family came and went, lost in my feelings of abundance, forgetting I wasn’t her mother. In my mind, I called her Sarah.

When her adoptive mother arrived (“real mother” vibrating in my head), my baby wailed loudly as I unwrapped the haphazard swaddle I’d failed at and placed her in the arms of the woman who would raise her. I had carefully picked this adoptive family—they were stable, educated and Christian. I was set in my decision to place her for adoption yet felt pained when her adoptive mother, who named her *Hanna, perfectly swaddled her and she calmed down immediately. I imagined the blanket rubbing away my scent from her neck, silently removing our bond.

Just three weeks later I stood in a courtroom and signed the papers to legally renounce motherhood (“not real mother” echoing in my head as I signed the paperwork). I had been numb since Sarah’s birth. Postpartum depression joined my regular depression in an effort to not feel, to protect me, so instead of feeling, I shifted in place, pulling at the ill-fitting khakis my mother had mended the night before, feigning indifference while trying to stop my knees from buckling.

Years passed by. I watched my little girl grow up through the letters and photographs I was granted through the open adoption, which slowed as she grew older and kept her parents busier. I started my own family at the age of 23, welcoming another little girl I was allowed to take home and love. I watched my husband cradle her against his chest, a proud father snapping and sharing photos with his family, and was reminded of the first time I did the whole birth thing, my parents snapping photos of the baby that belonged to none of us.

Again, postpartum depression ravaged my body and mind, making me question if I was ever meant to be a mother at all. I’d see my first daughter’s face in flashes while walking my colicky newborn back and forth through our tiny condo. My husband would walk in after a long day of work to both of us crying.

I don’t think he ever realized how intertwined these two babies were within my depression.

One day, my past came crashing through in the form of a letter inviting me to come visit my birth daughter Sarah in my home state just a few weeks before her 6th birthday. Her adoptive parents lived near my parents, and they had run into each other and begun a relationship, and now I was being invited in. I breathed in the promise of that invitation and accepted it immediately. As that day drew closer, I wondered if she would recognize me, and whether she might see me holding my kept child and hate me.

Good with Aarron as a child.

...

Sarah grabbed my hand and showed me she had no capacity for hate. This was the start of our annual visits. Of course, I never referred to her as Sarah. She was Hanna; she always was.

Back home, I saw a doctor and started medication, which slowly brought me around to actually experiencing motherhood. I leaned into it, suppressing my past in order to be a present parent. We lived in an affluent neighborhood, where I carefully watched and imitated the other mothers around me, like putting on a mask. With each milestone—getting my baby to sleep through the night, teaching myself how to cook for a child and husband, cuddling my daughter while sick, and then making her a big sister by having another daughter a few years later—I felt like I was earning motherhood merit badges. Only a thousand more to go until I felt like Mom.

Meanwhile, Hanna no longer lived within the confines of photos and letters. Our relationship grew through shared experiences during our visits. I was allowed to be family, through the openness of her adoptive parents, and Hanna grew up knowing I was her biological mother. But I could never assume the role of mother. In fact, she once asked if she could list me as her mother on Facebook and I said no. I had walked a careful line, collecting my motherhood badges for my own children, and trying for cool aunt status with Hanna. I always tried to respect Hanna’s adoptive parents, knowing they were doing all the hard work.

By the time Hanna was 13, we’d gotten in the habit of regularly chatting on Facebook. One day, she sent me a message that would change my entire relationship to motherhood. I was the first person she decided to come out to as transgender.

She was afraid to tell her parents and asked for my advice. I didn’t know what to say but tried to be reassuring. I told her that her parents loved her no matter what, and that she would always have me.

Good with her two daughters.

...

I had my own two daughters at home at this point, but I still struggled with wondering if I was “mother” enough. I had carried around my trauma for 13 years, tattooed it on my skin in multiples of 3s, a flower or bird or button for each child, then tried to put that body in yoga pants and take my daughters to playdates, never fitting in with the other mothers who seemed more suited to this life I was playing at.

The day of that Facebook message, I felt the mom in me grow. One day he told me his name was Aarron, before changing it on Facebook. He shared his pronouns, his worries, his hopes, his progress. I made sure he was safe and had support, staying up late, unable to sleep, thinking about his future.

I was at his beck and call, sitting at the computer all day while my daughters were at school, responding to messages, doing research and joining online groups for parents of trans children. I asked his adoptive mother if I could take him to see a gender counselor, which was hard to find in his midwestern state, during our next visit. My heart broke as I watched him suffer through the computer screen, 1,000 miles away, wanting to comfort him, wanting to mother him. I remembered the pain of being a closeted queer teenager in a conservative Christian home, feeling like I was consistently disappointing my parents, in a town where fitting in felt like life or death. I didn’t want Aaron to feel that way.

At that point, I knew what I had to do. I would be a supportive mom to Aarron no matter what—not just the cool aunt. Through his transition I learned to accept, to love beyond measure. Because of him, I was able to be the mother my daughters needed, too. I learned to see subtle changes, and advocate for them, like recognizing and calmly carrying my oldest daughter through her ADHD diagnosis. I opened up dialogues that hadn’t existed in our home until Aarron’s coming out, taking the edge off any and every difficult subject.

Aarron (right) with Good's daughters.

...

All the online research I did for Aarron in the early days, our trips to the gender counselor, our deep conversations, led me to look deeper at my own life. Helping him through his transition gave me the courage to recently come out as a lesbian at the age of 41. My family is still navigating this news, but they have been my biggest supporters, and I know I wouldn't even have gotten to this point if it weren't for Aarron.

Because of the child I placed for adoption, I've earned the title of mother, three times over. I took it back, reclaiming it from the nurses at the hospital, the legal papers, my own trauma, depression and doubts.

I earned my 1000th and final merit badge in June, when I helped Aarron move into his own apartment, just one town away from me, with the help of his adoptive dad. I’d gotten the keys before his arrival, did the walkthrough, and made sure he had food in his fridge and pantry. On moving day, we carried boxes and furniture, sorted candles and kitchenware, and enjoyed each moment.

His dad sent me a text message the next day and ended it with, “Please watch over him.”

“Always,” I said.

*Name has been changed for privacy reasons.

Joanna Good is an author living in Los Angeles with her two children. She is working on a memoir about adoption, LGBTQ+ issues, religion and motherhood.

All views expressed in this article are the author's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines