Gen X Are Most Worried About Retirement

...

Aliss Higham

By Aliss Higham

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Confidence about meeting retirement goals varies widely across generations, with Generation X standing out as the least optimistic, according to new research.

PNC Bank's third annual Financial Wellness in the Workplace Report found that Gen Z is the most confident about their post-working years, with 56 percent saying they are "somewhat" or "very confident" they will reach their retirement goals. Millennials and Baby Boomers reported equal confidence at 50 percent. But only 43 percent of Gen Xers expressed confidence—the lowest among all age groups.

America's retirement landscape has shifted dramatically in recent years, leaving many struggling to save enough for later life. A 2023 Pew Research Center report showed that about one in five Americans aged 65 and older were still working—nearly double the share from 35 years ago. Rising living costs, inflation eroding purchasing power, and longer life spans have all made stepping away from the workforce more difficult than ever.

Read More on News

Experts say this lack of confidence reflects both structural and personal financial challenges. Karla Dennis, finance expert and CEO of tax planning firm KDA, Inc., described Gen X as being under extraordinary pressure.

"I believe so few Gen Xers feel confident about retirement because they are carrying the heaviest load right now. They're paying mortgages, putting kids through college, and in many cases helping aging parents," Dennis told Newsweek.

"On top of that, many of them never fully recovered from the 2008 crash, so their retirement savings fell behind. With pensions disappearing and Social Security looking shaky, it makes sense that they're worried."

Gen X Are Most Worried About Retirement

...

Why Aren't Gen X Confident About Retirement?

Dennis pointed to what she calls the "double-duty generation," caught between caring for children and parents, all the while facing high housing costs and lingering student debt.

"It's not that they don't want to save; it's that they're stretched so thin that confidence about the future naturally takes a hit," she said.

This generational squeeze is supported by recent findings from the Allianz Center for the Future of Retirement. Its study shows that three in four members of the so-called "sandwich generation"—defined as adults with at least one child under 18 and a living parent—said it was difficult to balance their retirement and financial goals while caring for both sides of the family.

Erica Sandberg, consumer finance expert at CardRates.com, said Gen Xers are at a point in life where optimism meets financial reality.

"People who are between the ages of 45 and 60 years old are being bitten by reality, especially those on the higher end of the age spectrum. They are just about to reach that milestone of being able to draw Social Security—at age 62 [in the U.S.]—but are also faced with the hard numbers in their retirement accounts," Sandberg told Newsweek. "Rising inflation will cut into fixed incomes. That's a legitimate concern."

She noted that many in Gen X are still dealing with student loans or supporting college-age children.

"If their parents do not have the means to support themselves, but their health is declining, their adult children may come to the rescue and fill in some financial gaps. That can be an enormous economic burden, particularly when they're still helping their own kids to launch," Sandberg said.

Gen Z Feeling Better

But younger generations appear more self-assured on the matter, with their confidence stemming from having time on their side and growing up with unprecedented access to financial tools and advice.

"Gen Z has the benefit of time and tech on their side, which is a huge advantage. They've grown up with free financial advice from apps like TikTok, and they have access to more information than any other generation," Dennis said. "That gives them confidence."

Sandberg agreed that the benefit of youth is time, providing more room for saving. "Gen Zers are full of youthful confidence—and they should be! They can do anything. Because they're between the ages of 13 and 28, youth is on their side and can afford to take risks," she said.

"However, confidence without action can be dangerous," Dennis said, adding that "saving and investing early" should still be a priority for those who will retire long in the future.

Read Newsweek's full interview with Karla Dennis and Erica Sandberg below

Q: Why do you think only 43 percent of Gen Xers feel confident about retirement—lower than every other generation?

Dennis: "I believe so few Gen Xers feel confident about retirement because they are carrying the heaviest load right now. They're paying mortgages, putting kids through college, and in many cases helping aging parents.

"On top of that, many of them never fully recovered from the 2008 crash, so their retirement savings fell behind. With pensions disappearing and Social Security looking shaky, it makes sense that they're worried."

Sandberg: "People who are between the ages of 45 and 60 years old are being bitten by reality, especially those on the higher end of the age spectrum. They are just about to reach that milestone of being able to draw Social Security—at age 62 [in the U.S.]—but are also faced with the hard numbers in their retirement accounts.

"They can start to take distributions from their 401(k) plans and IRAs without early penalties at age 59.5, but will their savings be enough to sustain them? Rising inflation will cut into fixed incomes. That's a legitimate concern.

Q: Are there structural or economic factors unique to Gen X that might explain their lower confidence? Do caregiving responsibilities play a role?

Dennis: "Yes, there are structural or economic factors unique to Gen X that might explain their lower confidence. Gen X is what I call the double-duty generation. They've got kids on one side and parents on the other, both in need of financial support.

"Then, you add in remaining student loan debt, higher housing costs, and no pension safety net, and retirement starts to feel like the last thing on an ever-growing list. It's not that they don't want to save; it's that they're stretched so thin that confidence about the future naturally takes a hit."

Sandberg: "Unfortunately, many Gen Xers aren't in a secure financial position. Not only do a fair number have their own student loans that are still lingering in the background, many are also supporting their college age children. And if they had kids later in life or from second marriages, the costs of raising them are still a factor.

"It all impacts the amount of money they have for essential expenses as well as fun. More, if they didn't purchase their own home and build equity, some are facing an increasingly unaffordable rental market."

Q: What does Gen Z's relatively high confidence suggest—are they being realistic, or overly optimistic given their age?

Dennis: "Gen Z has the benefit of time and tech on their side, which is a huge advantage. They've grown up with free financial advice from apps like TikTok, and they have access to more information than any other generation. That gives them confidence.

"However, confidence without action can be dangerous. If they're not consistently saving and investing early, that optimism could turn into the same reality check Gen X is facing today."

Sandberg: "Gen Zers are full of youthful confidence—and they should be! They can do anything. Because they're between the ages of 13 and 28, youth is on their side and can afford to take risks.

"Those who are over the age of 18 can explore different jobs and career opportunities, live on a super tight budget. This is a time to try things out, make mistakes, learn and gain financial strength."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines