10
Loading video...

By Jenni Fink
Senior Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
After a brief encounter on the playground the other week, I’m pretty confident in my decision not to gentle parent.
With parents more stressed out and busier than ever, I can see the value in consciously taking a step back and allowing your child to figure things out on their own. In some ways, I think gentle parenting encourages parents to slow down and be in the moment instead of constantly rushing your child through life because we're all too busy to waste precious seconds while they try to do something we could easily do ourselves.
But when did we decide kids shouldn’t want to make their parents proud? Or that we should tell people they’re parenting wrong while they’re just trying to enjoy the playground with their toddler?
Read More on Life
Before we get to the story, here’s a quick welcome to Diary of a Work-In-Progress Mom, a weekly check-in on how life is going as a new mom who wasn't sure she wanted to be a mom until she was told she couldn't get pregnant. If you’re not already following me on TikTok, Instagram, or Facebook, here’s a brief introduction.
I’m a 34-year-old woman living in New York City with a 16-month-old, and I am really making my own rules for being a mom because I know nothing. As in, I never even held a baby before having a baby of my own (I know, I think my parenting scares my mom sometimes).
Living in New York City, my toddler and I spend most of our day outside the house, so we’re regulars at the playground. I rarely get into in-depth conversations with other parents because I’m chasing a feral toddler around, but we’ll exchange a few words here or there, bonding over the shared chaos that is parenthood, and usually everyone’s perfectly pleasant. Which is why, when I was scolded for being a bad mom, I was left completely stunned.

...
My son climbed up the stairs on his own, so I clapped and told him, “Good job, buddy!” Listen, was it the most impressive thing I’ve ever seen? Of course not. But he held onto the railing and figured out how to hoist his chunky thighs up a step that’s half the size of him, and for a little kid, that’s an accomplishment.
Suddenly, I heard a woman’s voice next to me, “You shouldn’t do that.”
I assumed she meant don’t let him climb the stairs on his own because it’s dangerous, so I told her that it was fine because I was right there nearly touching his back so he wouldn’t fall.
“No, you shouldn’t say, ‘Good job,'" she said.
Right about now you’re probably either agreeing with this woman or you’re thinking about all the things you would have told her, most of which aren’t appropriate for me to repeat here.
All I could muster up was, “Oh.”
I know, I know, I should have stood up for myself. But I was stunned. When I left the house that morning, the last thing I thought was going to happen was that I'd be mom-shamed for telling my son “good job.” Mom-shamed for a bunch of other things I do that seem insane in today's world? Sure. But not for telling my son, "good job."
“When you say, ‘good job,’ it makes kids want your approval instead of self-motivating,” she informed me.
Of course, I've since come up with tons of things to say to her. Perfect responses that would have defended my position and made her see the errors of her ways. But, in the moment, I just stared. Until I noticed my toddler about to dive bomb off the playground, so I swiftly left the conversation to save my child’s life. Plus, I didn’t want to hear her thoughts when I told him, “Bad job.”
Objectively, it’s not great to be a person who needs constant approval from others. You should be proud of your accomplishments regardless of how anyone else reacts. But I like that I grew up wanting to make my parents proud.
My town was filled with overachievers and parents who needed everyone to know how accomplished their kids were. Mine were different. They expected us to do well in school, keep our moral compass trained on north, and generally be good people. My mom always supported us and my dad is mine and my sisters' biggest fan. If I told him I was running for president tomorrow, he’d come up with a list of people I should connect with and tell me I’m exactly what this country needs in the current political climate. In his mind, there's nothing we can't achieve.
But my parents never competed with other parents for whose kids were more impressive. As my mom said at a luncheon one time, “My kids are there to make your kids look better.”
Maybe that’s why I enjoyed impressing them, because their love and pride were given freely instead of used as a carrot on a stick to get us to perform so they would look better. If I grew up with parents that made me feel like nothing I did was good enough, maybe I’d feel different.
I hope my son grows up feeling fulfilled by his own accomplishments, but also wanting to make me and his father proud. Without that, my ability to guide him and keep him on the straight and narrow may disappear.
Years after I graduated from high school and became an adult paying my own bills, my mom told me she worried I'd wake up one day and realize my parents had no real power over me. Sure, they could ground me and take away my cell phone, laptop and car. But they couldn’t chain me to my bed and trap me in the house. They couldn’t force me to study or come home at a reasonable hour on the weekends.
Their power was in me and my sisters wanting to make them proud and not disappoint them. If we didn’t care what my parents thought, we wouldn’t have had really any reason to follow rules we didn’t agree with.
I love that my parents are proud of me because I know it’s made their lives better. In a small way, it feels like I’ve given a little back to them for the wonderful life they’ve given me. And if they never told me they were proud of me, how would I ever know?
If you want to read more from Jenni Fink, subscribe to The Good Life newsletter here.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines