Rex Heuermann

...

Monica Sager

By Monica Sager

Live News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann is not all that unique – at least when it comes to being a serial killer as experts describe him as a "prototypical sexual sadist."

And the 60-year-old New York architect is being compared to the second-most prolific serial killer in America - Green River Killer.

Heuermann was first arrested in July 2023 for the deaths of four women - known as "The Gilgo Four" - whose remains were found in burlap sacks along the Ocean Parkway in New York over a decade ago. Heuermann was charged with the murders of his fifth and sixth victims, Sandra Costilla and Jessica Taylor, on Thursday.

Read More on News

"Heuermann may seem unique and interesting but there have been many before him who have written blueprints for their crimes and enacted those plans," Enzo Yaksic, who runs the Atypical Homicide Research Group, told Newsweek. "Sexual serial murderers are thankfully dwindling in number as the modern-day serial murderer is much different than their Golden Age (1970-2000) counterparts, as they are motivated by anger and use firearms to kill."

The motivation behind Heuermann's serial killing, however, seems very similar to other murderers.

"I'm wondering if and why murder became a problem-solving tool for him," Dr. Robert Schug, a forensic psychologist and criminology professor, told Newsweek. "That's generally what is happening with the repeat murderers. The homicidal behavior is solving some function in their lives."

Rex Heuermann

...

Rex Heuermann's story

Heuermann graduated from the same local high school as actor Billy Baldwin who tweeted after the news broke about his 1981 classmate's arrest, describing it as "mind-boggling."

If the new charges are true, Heuermann would have started his killing sprees at 29-years-old.

But he fit in with the profile some experts give to serial murderers: "an organized, sophisticated, white, family man who blends in and charms others," Yaksic said. He was so adept at lying and manipulating that his wife Asa Ellerup still denies her estranged husband's ability to commit such heinous acts.

Certain life events are able to potentially coincide with the serial killings as well, Schug told Newsweek.

The now-accused serial killer got his bachelor's degree from the New York Institute of Technology and went on to start his own architecture firm, RH Consultants, in 1994.

Just a few months prior, two hunters discovered 28-year-old Sandra Costilla's body in a wooded area in North Sea, Southampton, on Nov. 21, 1993.

The average for serial murderers to begin their crimes is 29, according to Yaksic. Heuermann was 30 years old when Costilla's body was found.

"This sounds like a guy who lived a life as far as we know without killing for the first three decades of his life," Schug said.

Rex Heuermann family

...

In 1996, Heuermann married Asa Ellerup and they had a daughter, Victoria, a year later. Heuermann also had a stepson, Christopher Sheridan, who is seven years older than Victoria.

This "stability" and "accountability" brought what seems to be a lull period between Heuermann's initial killing sprees.

"He had a six to seven year run with his wife as far as we know with no violence going on. That's interesting," Schug said. "Being married is generally considered a protective factor, at least when it comes to propensity for violence or maladaptive behavior."

But seven years into their marriage, Heuermann's second alleged killing occurred.

"There's psycho-social stresses, things going on in the environment that make life hard, that, could influence one's decision making or one's ability to control their emotions. Generally speaking, people that often commit acts of violence and aggression, it can often be reactive and in response to things going on around them," Schug said. "Once he gets started again, it seems like it's happening every couple of years."

Factors like a potentially rocky marriage, stress from his job or even raising his children could have led to his murderous reinstatement, Schug said.

Rex Heuermann poses for his booking photo

...

The sex worker target: 'That's very common'

The six victims Heuermann is currently charged with are all sex workers. Other cases that might be linked to Heuermann also follow a similar thread.

"That's very common," forensic psychiatrist Dr. Sanjay Adhia told Newsweek.

Adhia mentioned the similarities with Steve Wright, an English serial killer known as the Suffolk Strangler. He is currently serving life imprisonment for the murder of five women during a six-week murder spree in 2006. All of his victims were young female sex workers, just like Heuermann.

The other case Adhia compared Heuermann's to was Gary Ridgway, who is known as the Green River Killer. He was convicted of 49 murders between the early 1980s and late 1990s, making him the second-most prolific serial killer in U.S. history. Most of Ridgway's victims were sex workers and other women in vulnerable situations. Similar to Heuermann, Ridgway strangled his victims' bodies and then dumped them in forested and overgrown areas.

Green River Killer

...

New evidence revealed in court documents obtained by Newsweek shows Heuermann took notes on how to organize his plan, including supplies such as cat litter and tarps, dump site locations, recon reports and body prep.

On section of the Microsoft Word document, which was found in March, is titled "notes". The bullet points come from the book "Mind Hunter" by John Douglas, specifically the first edition published in 1996. The book profiles serial killers.

During an initial search warrant in 2023 at Heuermann's home, the task force found in his home office a book entitled "The Cases That Haunt Us," which outlines facts, evidence and victimology of several notable serial murder cases.

"There's lots of reasons why," Adhia said. "Somewhere near 20% of all serial killer victims are sex workers."

Research conducted by John Potterat, who has studied prostitution and the spread of diseases, suggests that female sex workers in the United States are 18 times more likely to be murdered than women of the same age from the general population. In the U.K., it was found that female se workers have a mortality rate 12 times higher.

"I believe the reason that sex workers are targeted is a lot of people wouldn't be alarmed if they're missing also, they're thought of as being vulnerable," Adhia said. "The police don't have infinite resources so they would not focus on if they found out a sex worker is missing. It's not going to be the top of their to do list."

And that's what happened in the cases of Heuermann's alleged victims.

The hunt for a possible serial killer started in 2010 when 11 sets of human remains were discovered along a property on Gilgo Beach in Suffolk County. Law enforcement first started searching along Ocean Parkway only after Shannan Gilbert, a 24-year-old sex worker from New Jersey, vanished in 2010.

Gilgo Beach Murders

...

Police found other remains during the search, including those that belonged to Jessica Taylor and Valerie Mack, who were also in their 20s when they had gone missing years earlier.

"They're relatively easy in terms of victimology," Schug said.

Adhia called the serial killer obsession with sex workers a "crime of opportunity." To target other people would probably take more work in planning, following and overall effort. Sex workers are often brought to more private locations.

The serial killer could also accomplish a second goal of sexual relations with these women.

In the "notes" section of the Microsoft Word document detectives found Heuermann made, there are references to book pages about "sex substitution" like penetration with an object. Douglas described it in his book as "rather horrible sexual mutilation and masturbation over (the victim's) body, but no intercourse. The penetration with the umbrella and pen were acts of sexual substitution."

The new digital evidence also revealed Heuermann had a "significant collection of violent, bondage, and torture pornography" dating back to 1994, according to court records obtained by Newsweek. The images include breast mutilation, vaginal torture, the sexualization of decapitated women and bondage. These "notably and largely coincide with how the remains" of Costilla and Taylor were discovered.

Yaksic called Heuermann a "prototypical sexual sadist." Schug said the timing of his murders can suggest there was a sexual idealization involved that was "spiraling out of control."

"I have talked to guys who have done things like this who have mentioned that they have read true crime accounts of investigative processes and learned from it," Schug said. "When you're talking about body washing wipes and foam drain cleaners and hair nets and rope and police scanners, that suggests that the person is putting some thought into this...This is very damning evidence, these lists."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines