10

Loading video...

Michael Foxman

By Michael Foxman

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A person who alerts a public agency to a potentially harmful decision should be able to find out who will examine the concern and when to expect an answer. That expectation should not depend on influence, persistence, or the ability to hire a lawyer.

I believe governments should make the handling of serious complaints auditable, with assigned responsibility, response deadlines, and independent review when the process stalls.

The need to rebuild confidence is clear. The Partnership for Public Service’s 2026 report found that 27 percent of Americans trusted the federal government, compared with 33 percent the previous year. Those figures do not establish why any particular complaint goes unanswered. They do, however, show the difficult environment in which agencies must demonstrate that their decisions deserve public confidence.

Read More on Leadership Insights

An unanswered concern can leave someone facing an uncertain bill, a delayed business decision, or a dispute they cannot afford to pursue. Even when an agency has acted correctly, an unexplained response makes that harder to establish. A clear explanation gives people something they can assess and, where necessary, challenge. Silence leaves them guessing about both the decision and their remaining options.

Identifying Wider Issues and Failures

My concern is that complaint handling can be treated as a secondary administrative task when it should help identify decisions that need another look. A credible warning may reveal a problem affecting people who have never complained. If agencies examine each submission without checking for recurring issues, they may miss opportunities to correct a wider failure.

Australia’s Robodebt experience (an automated welfare debt assessment scheme) offers a concrete lesson. In March 2026, the National Anti-Corruption Commission reported that two of six individuals referred following the Royal Commission had engaged in serious corrupt conduct. It found that the other four had not.

The findings included intentionally misleading another department and intentionally misleading the Commonwealth Ombudsman during an investigation.

That distinction matters. Accountability requires evidence about particular conduct, with room for findings that do not support an allegation. Broad accusations against public servants cannot substitute for that work. The commission also said relevant process improvements had been implemented and considered them sufficient to prevent recurrence of the corrupt conduct it examined. Reform deserves recognition alongside failure.

Take Action as Soon as a Complaint Arrives

The Robodebt Royal Commission’s recommendations provide practical guidance beyond that case. They included documenting important decisions, bringing significant tribunal decisions to senior officials’ attention, and providing clear review pathways for automated decisions.

These are useful safeguards because they connect information to someone with responsibility for acting on it. Their value depends on whether that connection works in everyday administration.

A workable standard would begin when a concern arrives. The agency should record the issue, preserve relevant material, and identify an officer responsible for assessing it. The person raising it should receive a reference number, an explanation of the next step, and a realistic response date. Urgent risks should receive faster attention than routine disagreements.

There must also be a way to challenge inaction. When a deadline passes, the agency should explain the delay and provide a revised date. Serious unresolved concerns should qualify for review outside the team responsible for the original decision. Otherwise, the same office may become the sole judge of whether its own response was adequate.

Resources and fairness matter. Agencies cannot investigate every allegation at equal depth, and repeated submissions do not necessarily contain new evidence. A proportionate system should explain why a matter warrants investigation, referral, or closure. Staff should have support to make those judgments, while complainants should understand what additional information could justify reconsideration.

I would also ask oversight bodies to look beyond how many files agencies close. Anonymized reporting should show overdue cases, recurring problems, and corrective action. Closing a complaint quickly means little if the underlying error continues affecting others. Equally, a careful review should not be judged a failure simply because it takes longer.

Lawmakers should require major public agencies to publish response standards, establish independent escalation, and report whether promised corrections were completed. Agency leaders should regularly examine overdue serious complaints and assign responsibility for resolving them.

These steps would make responsiveness something the public can assess. Confidence has a better chance of growing when people can see what happened after they spoke up.

Michael Foxman is an international business adviser and CEO of RiskWise Global Capital Group, LLC, with more than 30 years of experience in strategic advisory, investment facilitation, project delivery, governance, and risk management across multiple jurisdictions. All views expressed are the author's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines