
...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Home prices are plummeting in a Florida city some called "ground zero" for the subprime mortgage crisis of 2008. According to housing experts, Cape Coral now has one of the worst housing markets in the entire country—and the situation is likely to continue precipitating in the coming months.
What Is Happening in Cape Coral?
Cape Coral's housing market exploded during the pandemic, when thousands of out-of-state newcomers flocked to the relatively affordable Florida town, snatching up for-sale homes and driving up prices. Between May 2020 and May 2022, the median sale price of a home in the city rose from $239,020 to $436,475, according to Redfin.
Read More on News

...
But since 2023, when the nationwide market experienced a brief price correction, Cape Coral's housing market has been on a downturn. In May 2023, the median sale price of a home had plunged by 5.3 percent from a year earlier to $413,245; in May 2024, it was down to $391,200, down by another 5.3 percent year-over-year. And in May 2025, the median sale price of a home in Cape Coral was down to $361,250, 7.7 percent less than a year earlier.
According to a recent analysis for the Wall Street Journal conducted by the site Homes.com, home prices in the Cape Coral metropolitan statistical area fell by 11 percent in the two years through May—the most of any metro area in the country in that same period.
Why Is the City Experiencing a Downturn?
Similar to the rest of the Sunshine State, there is currently an imbalance between buyers and sellers in Cape Coral. According to Parcl Labs, the city market currently shows a record 10,049-unit surplus—for a 525 percent growth since 2022—and absorption rate at 0.268—lower than the U.S. average of 0.423.
The company reported that Cape Coral has also reached "unprecedented levels" of price reduction activity, with 55.35 percent of listings cutting prices—much more than the 34 percent U.S. average.
The number of homes for sale is on the rise all across the country, as homeowners who were locked into their properties by lower monthly payments have stopped waiting for mortgage rates to come down. At the country level, the number of homes for sale was up by 16.2 percent year-over-year in May, for a total of 2,098,681.
In the Sunshine State, an explosion of new developments triggered by the pandemic boom has also contributed to significantly increasing the available stock of for-sale homes. In May, the state had 234,288 homes for sale, up 14.2 percent from a year-earlier, including 45,771 newly listed homes.
But listings—at both national and state level—are also up because fewer buyers are showing up for the inventory on the market due to long-standing affordability issues, including historically high mortgage rates and rising costs. Slower domestic migration to the state, which is partially linked to return-to-office orders across the country, has also contributed to cool down demand across Florida.
Cape Coral is facing all the same challenges the state is battling with, plus some of its own. The city was badly hit by Hurricane Ian in September 2022, and its recovery has been strained by the other storms and flooding which followed that deadly event.
The growing frequency and severity of natural disasters on the Southwest Florida coast has brought up the cost of home insurance, while some carriers have cut coverage in the most at-risk areas of the state. According to MoneyGeek, home insurance in the city costs an average of $640 per month, or $7,679 per year.
The city's condo market has also been particularly hit by the regulation passed in the aftermath of the deadly Surfside collapse of June 2021. The law, which requires condo associations to conduct regular building inspections and reserve the necessary funds for repair and maintenance, triggered a surge in condo listings from owners trying to avoid paying higher fees.
Much of this inventory is now sitting idle on the market, as buyers steer away from a likely risky investment.
Will the City Face a New Burst?
Cape Coral was at the center of the 2008 bursting of the U.S. housing market's bubble, with a speculative mania taking over the city in the years leading to the crisis, and is still Florida's foreclosure capital. The city has nearly 11,000 homes in foreclosures, about one in every 31 households.
But according to Marco Santarelli of Norada Real Estate Investment, while "the ghosts of 2008" may be stirring in Cape Coral, the situation in the city is quite different now than it was nearly 20 years ago.
While the 2008 crisis was driven by subprime mortgages, speculative buying and a general lack of oversight on the mortgage market, the current downturn in the Cape Coral housing market has been driven by high mortgage rates, rising inventory and growing economic uncertainty at the national level. Some of these factors are likely to endure in the coming months, with mortgage rates expected to remain between 6 percent and 7 percent through 2025 and 2026.
Prices might continue falling in Cape Coral in the coming months, but a majority of experts think that the city remains attractive thanks to its natural qualities—a beautiful, young city which remains more affordable than many of its neighbors—and the market will offer good opportunities for both buyers and savvy investors.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines