
...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Newly built homes are now cheaper than existing ones, according to the latest data, as developers navigate an oversaturated housing market where sellers far outnumber buyers.
The median sale price of a new home in June, according to the latest data made available by the Census Bureau, was $401,800, down 4.9 percent from a month earlier and 2.9 percent a year earlier. In the same month, the median sale price of an existing home was $435,300, according to data by the National Association of Realtors (NAR), up 2 percent year-over-year.
It is rare for newly built homes to cost less than older existing ones. According to real-estate analyst Nick Gerli, founder and CEO of Reventure App, this is only the sixth time in 26 years that this has occurred.
Read More on News
Gerli added that the price gap between newly built and existing homes "likely signals an inflection point in the housing market."
An Unusual Turn of Events
Newly built homes are normally more expensive than older properties where previous owners might have lived in for years. In the first quarter of the year, new homes in the U.S. cost $14,600 more than existing ones. But recently, things have switched around.
While existing home prices have now been rising year-over-year for seven straight quarters, according to data reported by the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), new home prices have been falling steadily year-over-year for even longer, eight consecutive quarters.

...
This is due to the fact that new home inventory surged over the few months, especially in areas like Florida and Texas which have experienced a construction boom in the past couple of years. Much of this supply has landed on the market at a time when buyers could not afford it due to rising housing costs, including historically high mortgage rates, and has started to pile up there.
"New home inventory has been around eight months—twice as high as existing home inventory," Lawrence Yun, NAR's chief economist, told Newsweek.
As of June, there were 511,000 new houses for sale in the country, according to the Census Bureau, up 1.2 percent from May and 8.5 percent from a year earlier.
Developers have caught up on these changes and tried to adapt to them, increasingly slashing prices and offering different types of incentives to lure in reluctant buyers.
"Some large homebuilders have cut net prices by as [much as] over 20 percent from peak, and the result is their order book is holding up well," Gerli told Newsweek. "Overall, new home sales are down only slightly compared to pre-pandemic norms, while existing sales are down by over 25 percent."
What's Behind This Price Gap?
Inventory has surged for both new homes and existing ones in recent months. And yet, their sale prices have followed very different trajectories.
For Gerli, the price gap between newly built and existing homes has a lot to do with the different attitude that developers and existing-homes sellers are showing as the market experiences a slowdown after years of overheating.
"What's happening here is that the builders are adjusting to the realities of the current housing market," Gerli wrote on X, formerly Twitter. "They've cut prices 13 percent from peak, and are giving generous mortgage rate buydowns on top of that. They're also building slightly smaller floor plans. All in an effort to deliver affordability to buyers," he added.
"Existing home sellers, on the other hand, are largely ignorant of the realities of the current market," he said. "They're not aware of the slowdown, and are still often trying to capture prices from three to four years ago when they go to sell."
This mismatch, Gerli said, is leading to "bloated existing sale prices that don't accurately reflect the current market."
Joel Berner, senior economist at Realtor.com, told Newsweek that it is "fundamentally more difficult" for existing home prices to fall "because, for the most part, existing home sellers have an inventory of one home, while builders have dozens, if not thousands, that they are looking to sell."
Prices in the resale market are "necessarily stickier, and instead of seeing sales prices fall, we just see fewer sales like we have this summer," he said. "Additionally, new home inventory is highly concentrated in the South where prices are generally lower, and the best region for home sales this year has been in the Northeast where there are far fewer new builds and prices are significantly higher," he added.
Existing homes with price tags close to their pandemic ones are largely sitting idle on the market now, as buyers know they can get better deals elsewhere. According to a recent Redfin report, inventory is near record-levels with over 1.9 million active listings and homes sold in July spent 43 days in the market before going under contract, the longest of any July since 2015.
But while this same pileup is leading to price cuts in the newly built homes market, existing home sellers are not budging. "Homeowners have experienced a cumulative 49 percent price gain since the pre-COVID period, providing financial comfort. As a result, there are very little distressed, forced sales among existing homeowners," Yun said.
There is also another reason newly built homes are cheaper than existing ones—which is that many are significantly smaller. "Builders appear to be focused on smaller-size, affordable homes rather than large luxury homes, which is another reason for the lower median sales price for newly built homes," Yun said.
According to Berner, "absent a major shift in the existing home market where prices crash and cheap listings flood the market, we do not expect builders to change course in a major way. Builders will likely continue to offer the low-priced inventory that many buyers are looking for."
What Direction Are Prices Moving?
Gerli thinks that builders are now "signaling that home prices will need to drop on a nationwide basis to bring demand back" in the existing homes market.
But it is unclear whether sellers will follow through with price discounts. Many who have noticed that the market has shifted in favor of buyers are just refusing to engage with it. According to Redfin, July saw the biggest monthly drop in active listings since 2023 as sellers delisted their properties.
"Existing home sellers are less likely to lower prices in a widespread way—assuming no major shock to the market," Berner said.
"When and if mortgage rates fall, though, their current price point could prove effective at boosting sales back to a higher level," he added. "Sellers are very reluctant to take a loss on their home, so many will stay in place as long as they can until rates fall and the market improves."
According to Yun, supply and demand will determine the direction of existing home prices.
"The oversupply of condominiums in Florida has led to condo price reductions. The inventory shortage of single-family homes in Connecticut has led to home price increase," he said. "Nationwide, the current market is balanced and therefore, there isn't strong pressure to boost or cut prices in a big way."
But Gerli does not expect newly built homes to remain cheaper than existing ones for much longer. "Maybe over the next six to 12 months this situation persists, but eventually, existing home prices should drop to meet new home prices," he said.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines