10
Loading video...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Florida Governor-elect Byron Donalds will inherit a more stable home insurance market in January than his predecessor, Republican Ron DeSantis, faced in recent years, but stubbornly high costs remain a major challenge.
Rising premiums are an issue that worries Floridians even more than higher property tax bills, according to a survey conducted by the Public Opinion Research Lab at the University of North Florida in July. A majority of 63 percent of respondents said insurance was their biggest concern, while 36 percent said they were more worried about property taxes. Only 1 percent said they did not know which of the two issues they were most concerned about.
While Floridians are set to receive some relief on the property tax front, their concerns about insurance costs remain largely unaddressed. Property taxes are set for a major overhaul after 62 percent of voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, expanding the homestead exemption and reducing non-school property taxes for most homeowners in the state. Florida’s home insurance crisis, however, remains unresolved.
Read More on News
Finding a solution will now fall to Donalds, a Republican U.S. Representative who has pledged to build on DeSantis' legacy and the tort reform passed under his leadership.

...
“Most Republicans have said it’s OK, we’ve already passed some legislation to reform the insurance market and now we just have to give it a chance to work. That's kind of been what they’ve said for the last two or three years, and what Donalds have said, too,” Aubrey Jewett, a professor of political science at the University of Central Florida, told Newsweek.
But not everyone is convinced that preserving the current approach will be enough. Birny Birnbaum, director of the nonprofit Center for Economic Justice, believes Donalds is too willing to rely on the reforms implemented under DeSantis while overlooking what he sees as a major source of excessive costs: the financial arrangements between insurers and their affiliated companies.
“Donalds’ approach is to maintain the status quo and continue to rely on the mistaken belief that ‘tort reform’ has solved Florida’s insurance problems,” Birnbaum told Newsweek. “He says nothing about the monstrous profits of Florida insurers encouraged by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation’s hands-off approach to affiliated business arrangements of reciprocal exchanges.”
Related Story

Roofs Collapse, Airports Submerged as El Niño-Fueled Floods Slam Florida
Birnbaum pointed to a state-commissioned analysis of payments between Florida property insurers and affiliated businesses from 2017 through 2019. Excluding several outliers, the analysis found that insurers reported approximately $432 million in aggregate losses while their affiliates recorded roughly $1.3 billion in net income.
The report flagged payments by 20 insurers as exceeding its benchmark for what was fair and reasonable. Regulators and insurers have disputed the analysis, which did not conclude that the transactions were unlawful or establish that they caused higher premiums.
In response to the findings, which dominated the debate around insurance ahead of Election Day, Jolly called for tougher restrictions on affiliate payments; Donalds campaigned on preserving recent insurance reforms while proposing the creation of a public scorecard showing prices, claim denials and payment speed.
Florida’s Insurance Market: From Crisis to (Slow) Recovery
Florida’s home insurance market has spent years battling financial instability, insurer withdrawals and rapidly rising premiums.
Between 2021 and 2025, Florida homeowners’ insurance premiums rose 75 percent, nearly double the national average, according to a report from national nonprofit group the Coalition for an Insurable Future.
The increases have been attributed to a combination of excessive litigation and widespread fraud, rising reinsurance and rebuilding costs, and Florida’s exposure to costly natural disasters, although experts disagree over the relative importance of those factors. Carriers were facing higher costs and passing them on to policyholders. When they could not do so, they were going bust, cutting coverage or withdrawing from the most vulnerable areas of the state.
With the private market struggling, the state’s insurer of last resort, Citizens, ballooned in size, growing its total policy count to a high of 1.4 million in 2023 and causing concerns among lawmakers about its capacity to cover claims in case of a major storm hitting the state.
Since then, several things have gotten better. In 2022 and 2023, the state launched sweeping tort reforms that experts said has helped partially stabilize the market and draw back some private insurers. A “depopulation” effort took off in late 2023 and 2024 to shrink Citizens’ policy count, with the goal of returning it to a healthy, sustainable level. As of October 31, Citizens reported 216,447 policies in force.
And more than 20 new property insurers have entered the market since 2023, according to data from the Insurance Information Institute.
Yet for homeowners, the recovery has not necessarily translated into affordable coverage. Florida remains the most expensive state in the country for home insurance, with the average annual premium reaching $8,471 for a policy providing $300,000 in dwelling coverage, according to Insurance.com.
The premiums in Nebraska, the second-most expensive state in the nation for home insurance on average, were substantially lower at $5,513.

...
What Donalds Proposed to Fix the Insurance Affordability Crisis
The cost of home insurance emerged as a major battleground in the Florida gubernatorial campaign, with Donalds and Democrat David Jolly sharply divided over how to address it.
Jolly proposed converting Florida’s state catastrophe mechanism into a fund that would directly assume hurricane and wind risk, ultimately replacing the current Cat Fund and Citizens structure. He proposed financing it through taxes on insurers that his campaign said were currently avoided, while also identifying real-estate transaction fees and existing tourist taxes as possible sources. His plan left the final funding structure to the state Legislature.
Donalds criticized the proposal, saying it would have shifted hurricane risk onto the state and ultimately left Floridians paying the bill.
“His insurance plan is socialism. It’s basically removing the private sector unilaterally and putting government in control,” he said. “We already know that when you put government into control, it always fails the people....We’re going to keep Governor DeSantis’ tort reforms in place.”
In September, Donalds announced his “Bring Down the Bill” plan to cut insurance costs for Floridians.
“We will protect successful reforms, lower reinsurance and rebuilding costs, make mitigation grants deliver real premium savings, and hold insurers accountable,” Donalds wrote on X.

...
In his plan, Donalds pledged:
- to cut insurance premiums by 20 percent, though it did not specify the timeline for this goal;
- to protect existing litigation reforms, which experts said have helped stabilize the market;
- to reform the Florida Catastrophe Fund and reinsurance structure;
- to restructure My Safe Florida Home grants and other grant programs to fund real, storm-hardening upgrades that lower annual premiums the most;
- to create a public insurer scorecard that would allow homeowners to compare insurance companies on price, how fast they pay claims, and how often they deny coverage;
- to target construction and rebuilding costs by cutting red tape and restrictions that make rebuilding a home expensive and drive up insurance premiums;
- to keep the state’s insurer of last resort Citizens’ policy count low and avoid all Floridians being hit with a “hurricane tax” after a big storm.
Newsweek contacted Donalds’ transition team for comment by email on Wednesday.
Has Florida’s Tort Reform Worked?
Where Jolly proposed a much larger government intervention in the insurance market, Donalds has focused on preserving the private insurance system while trying to reduce the costs insurers face and improve accountability.
Florida’s share of nationwide homeowners-insurance lawsuits fell from about 79 percent in 2020 to 41 percent in 2025, according to OIR. The regulator also reported that lawsuit filings fell 23 percent in 2024, 25 percent in 2025 and another 25 percent during the first five months of 2026 compared with the same period a year earlier.
But considering premiums are still the highest in the nation, more solutions are needed to fix the state’s affordability issues.
Can Reinsurance Reforms Bring Premiums Down?
Donalds said he wants to reduce policyholder surcharges when the Catastrophe Fund has strong reserves and allow insurers to pool certain reinsurance purchases in an effort to obtain lower prices. Reinsurance is insurance for insurance companies.
According to Birnbaum, the Florida public reinsurance system is responsible for saving policyholders significant money on premiums “because the public reinsurance is much less costly than private reinsurance,” he said.
“Because Florida is dominated by single-state or regional insurers who have little ability to geographically diversify risk, the demand for reinsurance is great,” Birnbaum said. “Reinsurers, consequently, call the shots and have been able to extract massive profits for the past five years—profits far exceeding their cost of capital.”

...
What Does Reducing Citizens Actually Achieve?
Citizens was set up by the Florida Legislature in August 2002 to offer property insurance coverage to all Florida homeowners who cannot find it in the private market.
While the company is funded by policyholder premiums, Florida law requires Citizens to levy assessment on most homeowners in the state should it experience a deficit in the wake of a particularly damaging storm or other type of natural disaster. That puts the state in a very vulnerable position if Citizens’ exposure grows beyond what it can actually cover.
So far, efforts to depopulate the insurer of last resort have worked to push the risk further away from Floridians. Under Florida law, Citizens’ policyholders must switch to a private insurer if offered a policy with a premium no more than 20 percent higher than their Citizens rate.
Birnbaum is wary of the insurer shedding further policies, saying there is “no trick” to do so, you can only “force Citizens policyholders to buy [flood] insurance not required from the private market and you force Citizens policyholders to accept takeouts from weakly-capitalized reciprocal exchanges at 20 to 40 percent more than Citizens premiums and you hollow out the coverage by forcing policyholders into arbitration when there is a claim dispute.”
Homeowners end up relying on Citizens because the private market doesn’t want to provide coverage, Birnbaum said, “so state policy is to punish consumers who have been abandoned by the private market.”
What Happens Next
For Donalds, the challenge will be turning signs of market stabilization into meaningful savings for homeowners. Florida has attracted new insurers, reduced its reliance on Citizens and seen litigation decline, but those improvements have yet to make coverage affordable for many residents.
Whether preserving DeSantis’ reforms and making incremental changes to the insurance system will be enough is an open question. With premiums still the highest in the country, Donalds will ultimately be judged not just on the health of Florida's insurance market but on how much homeowners are actually paying.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Robinson and Dave Siminoff.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines