10

Loading video...

Jonathan Alpert

By Jonathan Alpert

Psychotherapist

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Nothing carries more weight in America today than victimhood. It can excuse violence, erase accountability, and even recast killers as heroes. We saw that after the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, when the accused gunman, Luigi Mangione, was portrayed and even celebrated in Luigi: The Musical, a campy production that turns an accused killer into a folk hero.

The crime itself was horrifying. The reaction was worse. Violence was not condemned; it was reframed as resistance. This did not happen in isolation. It reflects a culture where grievance, real or imagined, has become moral currency. If you can claim to be wronged, you can claim license. What once lived at the extremes has now seeped into everyday life.

Luigi Mangione attends a hearing

...

Read More on Opinion

As a psychotherapist, I see how this mindset has been fueled by a therapeutic culture gone wrong. Therapy once helped people face hard truths and build resilience. Now, it too often reinforces fragile identities and nurtures grievance. One patient admitted to shoplifting and explained it away by insisting the store "exploits workers and overcharges customers." She did not feel guilty. She felt righteous. And she is far from alone. That is not healing. It is victimhood turned into license.

This culture is not new, but it has metastasized. The civil rights movement began with grievance, but it was rooted in a noble cause: universal principles of justice and equality under the law. Today that spirit has drifted. What once was a demand for repair has become a permanent identity, a status that claims moral authority and power.

That mindset does not stay confined to the therapy office. It spills into schools, workplaces, and politics. On campuses, students insist that being challenged is the same as being harmed. In politics, leaders cast entire groups as permanent victims, stripping them of responsibility while pinning blame on others. Social media then supercharges it, rewarding outrage, amplifying victim narratives, and turning personal slights into viral causes. The louder the complaint, the bigger the audience. Responsibility rarely trends. Outrage always does.

The Mangione case shows where this logic ends. Once victimhood becomes a permanent identity, almost anything can be justified. Lawbreaking is rebranded as resistance. Violence becomes self-defense. Accountability disappears. Even murder can be recast as heroism.

The damage is profound. On the personal level, this culture breeds fragility. People grow less able to handle criticism, recover from setbacks, or navigate conflict. On the societal level, it corrodes trust and hollows out norms. Communities that once held people together now splinter as groups compete to claim the greatest victimhood. If everyone is a victim, then no one is accountable. If every harm is unforgivable, then no one can be forgiven. And perhaps worst of all, inflating every slight into oppression cheapens true injustice. Real suffering loses its moral weight.

This does not mean genuine wrongs should be dismissed. A healthy society must acknowledge real harms. But grievance cannot be the endpoint. It must move toward repair, growth, and responsibility. When it stops short, grievance becomes addictive, intoxicating, and destructive.

The way back requires a cultural reset. In therapy, it means moving beyond validation and building resilience. In education, it means exposing students to challenges instead of shielding them from it. In politics, it means leaders willing to tell hard truths rather than pandering to victimhood. And in everyday life, it means resisting the urge to nurse grievances and asking the harder question: What can I do?

The Mangione case, and the bizarre musical it inspired, should be a wake-up call. It revealed not just a single act of violence but a society increasingly willing to glorify it in the name of victimhood. That willingness to cheer harm is a warning of where this culture is taking us.

Empathy matters. But empathy without accountability turns into grievance. A society that elevates grievance above all else will not make us safer or more just. It will make us weaker, more divided, and more vulnerable to those who exploit victimhood for power.

We face a choice. Double down on grievance, where the loudest victim holds the most influence and even violence can be dressed up as virtue. Or choose resilience, where strength, accountability, and courage matter more than complaint. America's future will be defined by that choice.

Jonathan Alpert is a psychotherapist practicing in New York City and Washington, D.C. He's also the author of the forthcoming book Therapy Nation (HarperCollins, 2026). Jonathan can be followed on X.

The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines