10
Loading video...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Florida’s major property tax overhaul was approved by roughly 62 percent of voters on November 3.
But it risks making homeownership in the state even less affordable for anyone who has not already stepped onto the property ladder, experts warn.
Amendment 3 is a constitutional amendment that will take effect on January 1, 2027. It will significantly reduce property taxes for some Florida homeowners and change how local governments collect and spend property tax revenue. The state’s Republican leadership is trying to curb what they deemed to be excessive spending.
Read More on News
The measure will mark the beginning of Governor-elect Byron Donalds’ leadership. Amendment 3 will increase the homestead tax exemption for nonschool district property taxes in Florida to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, with the amount indexed to inflation starting in 2029.
During his campaign, the Brooklyn-born U.S. congressman promised "to try to find a way to give real relief to seniors and to working families, with a goal of eliminating homestead property taxes in our state."
But policy analysts and tax experts who have studied the potential impact of Amendment 3 say that the kind of property tax overhaul promised by the measure could backfire against many of these same Floridians Donalds vowed to help—especially renters and would-be buyers.

...
"Amendment 3 is a cost shift that does nothing to provide real relief to Floridians—costs will be passed onto working Floridians, whether you’re a homeowner or a renter," Sadaf Knight, CEO of Florida Policy Institute, told Newsweek.
"With local governments facing a gaping, $12-billion recurring loss in revenue, attention will turn to non-homesteads like rental units and commercial properties to raise property taxes. This means a cost shift onto renters, small businesses, and consumers," Knight added.
"Renters will pay indirectly because what will happen is that landlords will have to pay higher property taxes on their units, and what they’ll do is pass along their increase by increasing their rent," J. Edwin Benton, a professor of political science and public administration at the University of South Florida, told Newsweek.
The Price to Pay for Lower Property Tax Bills
Supporters of Amendment 3 said that the property tax cut will benefit some 92 percent of Floridians, who will be able to save thousands of dollars in property tax bills. But many in the lead-up to the vote, from local law enforcements to experts, warned that the benefits of the property tax cut may be eroded by the loss in local governments’ revenues and consequent likely reduction of public services.
"Some estimates suggest revenues will fall by almost $5 billion in 2027-2028," Abigail Hall, professor in economics at the University of Tampa, told Newsweek. "The Florida State legislature’s analytical arm estimates that, when fully implemented, local and municipal revenues will decrease by some $11.8 billion."
Shelton Weeks, a Florida Gulf Coast University professor in the Department of Economics & Finance, said: "We should expect local governments to consider all available alternatives for replacing the lost revenue. I suspect most areas will see a reduction in services combined with various revenue replacement strategies."
The loss in revenues will vary greatly across communities in Florida due to the differences in the composition of their tax bases and the proportion of residential properties with homestead exemptions, Weeks said. Rural communities with relatively lower property values will be more severely impacted than coastal communities with higher residential property values, he added.
But all Floridians will suffer the impact of local governments’ loss in revenues. The "trade-offs" for providing homestead property owners property tax relief "is that Floridians may have to pay more in other taxes and fees as well as anticipate that local services will be reduced," tax reforms often include trade-offs, and Amendment 3 is no exception," Nicole Fox, policy analyst at the Tax Foundation, told Newsweek.

...
While she believes that rental property and non-homestead property owners will "almost certainly" see their tax bills increase, it is renters and young people that Hall is most concerned about. Renters, younger residents, and prospective homeowners "receive little or no direct benefit but may face higher fees, reduced services, or increased housing costs," she said.
Hall would also not be surprised if the property tax reform shifted "the calculus for developers and local governments when it comes to choosing between developing residential versus commercial or industrial properties," she said.
Residential housing "is already costly for local governments to service," she added. "With Amendment 3—building residential is a bad economic proposition. The result? Less housing."
It was the lack of inventory, combined with a boom in demand, that brought up prices in Florida during the pandemic home-buying frenzy in the first place. Experts agree that the country needs more housing to fix the affordability crisis—not fewer.
Weeks also believes that Amendment 3 will likely cause an increase in the cost of housing in the state in the long term, "as the tax savings of households with homestead exemptions is capitalized into housing prices."
Whatever qualifying homeowners save on annual property taxes under Amendment 3 could allow them to qualify for a larger monthly mortgage payment. This extra purchasing power could immediately drive up overall home prices if buyers use their tax savings to bid more on purchases, according to experts.
There is evidence of this in previous legislation passed by other states. A 2018 study looked at the impact of property tax cuts in Virginia and found that home prices in affected areas rose by around 9.3 percent—or $18,900—after the measures were approved. Researchers concluded that, when buyers expect to save money on property taxes, they are willing to pay more upfront for a home purchase.
Florida’s Allure Takes Another Blow
When hundreds of thousands of people moved to Florida during the pandemic, the state’s relatively affordable housing market, together with its sunny weather and low-tax environment, was part of its appeal to newcomers.
But the influx of remote workers, retirees and investors from higher-cost coastal states like California and New York collided with a severe shortage of homes across Florida at the time. This sent prices soaring 51 percent between March 2020 and June 2022. By comparison, home prices at the national level rose by 41 percent during the same period.
With higher home prices and mortgage rates doubling in 2022 due to the Federal Reserve’s rate-hiking campaign, buying a home in Florida became much less affordable. Even more so when considering that other housing costs—including property taxes, home insurance premiums, and homeowner associations (HOA) fees—also saw significant increases in those years.
The state finally started adding new inventory to the market right when demand was shrinking due to worsening affordability challenges and return-to-office orders putting a damper on migration to Florida.
The number of newcomers moving to Florida fell from 183,646 in 2023 to 22,517 in 2025, according to U.S. census numbers; this was down from 310,892 people who moved to the state in 2022. Meanwhile, working-age, middle-class residents told Newsweek they were leaving the state because of how expensive owning a home in Florida has become.
"When I came to Florida in 1982, it was low-wage, low-cost. Now it is low-wage, high-cost," Howard Frank, professor of public policy and administration at Florida International University, told Newsweek.
"Families of four who aren’t knocking down close to $100,000 in earnings are in net dissaving and/or giving up retirement funding, home insurance, etc. We are 36th in earnings—even low by ‘New South’ standards," he added.
Home prices have fallen in recent months, mainly due to the increase in inventory and the decline in demand. As of last month, the median sale price of a home in the state was $383,394, below the national median price of $388,634, according to Redfin.
But it has done little to restore the allure Florida enjoyed during the pandemic. People in the state "are voting with their feet and moving to Georgia, the Carolinas, Texas, and even back to high-cost, high-tax, ‘woke’ states," according to Frank.
Donalds, as well as Democratic gubernatorial candidate David Jolly, saw the state’s affordability problem through "a cost-containment prism," Frank said. "Save people some money on property taxes, lower the insurance premiums a bit, and we will be OK. I don’t think that’s the case," he added.
"Unless and until the state’s leadership begins to ask tough questions about the economic base and commences a long-term plan to morph away from the low-wage tourist-services foundation—many residents will be, as Goethe put it, sad guests on the dark earth," the professor warns.
"The Florida Chamber of Commerce ‘gets it’ when they bemoan 20- to 29-year-old college grads moving on due to affordability. But I am not sure if they or others want to deal with the earnings gap—that sounds woke or socialist."
Benton believes that Amendment 3, coming on top of these existing challenges, will "certainly have a huge impact" on the people who may think about moving to Florida in the future.
"They may say to themselves, why would I want to retire from New Hampshire or New York or Pennsylvania to Florida when the services won’t be nearly as good as what I have here and where I live presently?" Benton said, mentioning the expected cuts in public services funding.
"We’re going to put a damper on future people, what we call Florida transplants, people who moved to Florida from elsewhere to retire or even to even for a better job."
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Ben Kelly and James Debens
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines