
...

By Jesus Mesa
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
During the most hectic stretch of the Texas Senate campaign, a month away from Election Day, Democrat James Talarico came down with the flu and spent nearly two weeks away from public events. Republicans saw an opening in an already difficult race for the GOP.
Attorney General Ken Paxton seized on his absence, posting mock missing-person posters of his opponent and tweeting: “Talarico claims he was missing for 13 days because he had the ‘flu.’ Who actually believes that?” His campaign fueled rumors that Talarico had suffered “a full-blown mental Tala-freak-out” and was being held at a mental health facility in Ohio. They also demanded “proof of life.”
Billionaire and Tesla CEO Elon Musk, who poured at least $224 million into supporting the Republican challenger, also weighed in on his social media platform, writing on X: “The Talarico campaign is hiding something big that voters ought to know about.”
Read More on News
But Talarico's response, which several Democratic operatives praised as an example of how to handle an increasingly hostile campaign, was not to engage with the attacks. His message was simple: “You have to tell a story, be normal,” Andrew Mamo, lead strategist for Talarico's U.S. Senate campaign, said.
“When they went crazy and made up completely insane things about how he was in a mental hospital in Ohio, which he simply was not, we were just normal. We said he's sick, people get sick, he'll be back in a day or two,” Mamo told Newsweek in an interview.
The rumor fell apart within hours. The facility, the Lindner Center of Hope in Mason, Ohio, posted that Talarico “has never received treatment” there. Talarico shared the statement and added: “I’ve never even been to Ohio.” By then he was already back in public, appearing at the Austin City Limits Music Festival on October 9.
Weeks later, Talarico defeated Paxton by 12 points, delivering Democrats their first Texas Senate victory in 38 years.
Newsweek contacted Paxton’s Senate campaign via email on Monday for comment.
Related Story

How Texas Turned Against Ken Paxton: County Results Explained

...
An Early Story
The campaign had prepared for an attack like this one long before Talarico got sick. Mamo said the plan was to introduce Talarico to voters early with positive television ads, then carry the same message across Instagram, TikTok and campaign events.
“Being early and positive, because we knew the Republicans were going to come in late and negative and say, 'Actually, this guy is a crazy person,'" he said. “But when you’ve seen James talk about his faith and talk about his family and his career as a teacher, when they say he’s a crazy person, you say, 'No, he’s not. I’ve seen [him] talk. He seems pretty reasonable to me.'”
Mamo, who met Talarico in 2021, said the message had been years in the making. A former public school teacher, Talarico has long argued that the country's divide is between the powerful and everyone else, not between political parties. As a state representative, he was also a regular commentator on Fox News where he once had an exchange with then-host Pete Hegseth that later went viral.
“Great campaigns have a story to tell, and they tell them from the first day to the last day, and they set the narrative of the race,” Mamo said.
That story received an unexpected national boost in February, when Talarico's appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert became a story of its own. Colbert told his audience that CBS would not allow him to interview the Texas Senate candidate because of concerns about the federal government's equal time rule.
Colbert posted the conversation on YouTube instead. By February 18, the interview had drawn 85 million views across YouTube and social media. Talarico also raised more than $2.5 million in the 24 hours after the interview moved from CBS to YouTube, which he called the campaign's largest single-day fundraising haul.
“When you're watching something and you have the ability to scroll past it, you're actually paying attention because you're deciding to pay attention,” Mamo said, stating that the value of reaching people who actively choose to listen paid off.
“The more you can maximize free, opt-in attention, the more money you can spend elsewhere. Getting people to actually care about what you’re saying is the ultimate goal, and I think James did a really great job of that,” Mamo added.

...
Answering the Culture War
Republicans spent much of the race trying to put Talarico on the defensive over gender and faith. The line they returned to most came from 2021, when Talarico, a seminarian and aspiring Presbyterian minister, said on the Texas House floor: “God is nonbinary.”
Talarico was hardly the only target. Republicans spent an estimated $183 million on television ads focused on transgender-related attacks against Democrats in the final phase of this year’s midterm elections, according to AdImpact data.
Mamo said the campaign never dodged those fights.
“It’s not that we didn’t engage, because James has always been clear about his values, and the fact that his values haven’t changed from the day he got elected in 2018 to now,” he said. “When they attacked trans kids’ rights, James said, 'No, I will always stand up against anyone trying to bully kids.'”
The next step was to widen the conversation. Mamo described it as “almost using their attack energy against them to reroute the conversation to what people really care about.”
Many Democrats still remember the final stretch of the 2024 presidential campaign when Donald Trump and his allies leaned heavily on cultural issues to attack then-Vice President Kamala Harris. The “Kamala is for they/them. President Trump is for you” ad became one of the defining messages of that effort. Democrats were left wary of engaging in cultural fights they believed they were unlikely to win.
Mamo said Talarico's campaign took a different approach. Rather than dismissing voters' concerns about cultural issues, it acknowledged them while trying to connect those concerns to what he called “the underlying structural rot” behind their problems. That meant not telling voters that their feelings did not matter or that they were wrong to worry about their children or fairness in sports.
“It's totally fair to feel that way, but let's talk about what's really going on,” he said. “I think that turned into a powerful antidote.”
The midterms delivered a clear message. Voters cared more about the cost of living than the culture wars the GOP was relying on. That was true in Texas and across the country. About nine in 10 voters said the cost of living was a “crucial” or “major” factor in their vote for Congress, according to the AP Voter Poll, a survey of roughly 100,000 midterm voters.
About two-thirds said Trump's policies had fueled inflation. Only about one in 10 named immigration or health care as the country's top issue, while even fewer cited foreign policy or crime.

...
Running Against the Richest Man in the World
Talarico’s race became the most expensive Senate contest in American history. AdImpact found it was also the most expensive non-presidential race in U.S. history, with $573.2 million in ad spending, much of the money against him coming from Musk.
Talarico, meanwhile, built his war chest from donors. He outpaced Paxton in campaign funding, raising $155 million to Paxton’s $40 million. Through the summer, 51 percent of his total fundraising came from individuals who had contributed less than $200, while 88 percent of Paxton’s contributions came from larger donors.
Mamo said the outside money mattered less because the campaign had already defined the race.
“When you run up against the richest person in the world, you have set the tone and the conversation of the race, and you can win the big conversation, and that turns into results,” he said.
Musk and his active involvement in the race became part of Talarico’s message. Democrats won in part by hammering Musk, the tax breaks and grants his companies receive, and his relationships with elected Republicans. Slightly more than half of Texas voters said they had an unfavorable opinion of Musk, according to the AP Voter Poll of more than 5,000 voters in the state.
“No matter how much money is spent against you, people know what the race is about, because you’ve decided what the race is about. That is tremendously powerful,” he said.
He also argued that a dollar spent on an attack ad buys less than it used to. “When Republicans pay for you to watch an attack ad, that costs money,” Mamo said. “And you’re probably half paying attention to an ad because they’re making you watch it.”
Mamo said the goal was to tell “one coherent story across every platform, whether it’s Instagram or TikTok or a television ad or a speech.”
“It’s consistency, and it’s being different from everybody else and interesting,” he added.

...
Earning the Latino Vote
The campaign’s other priority was Latino voters, who had swung hard toward Republicans two years earlier. Trump captured an estimated 55 percent of the voter bloc in Texas in 2024, which set a new high-water mark for Texas Republicans.
Mamo said the campaign did not assume Trump’s immigration crackdown would bring those voters back on its own. Instead, it treated them “as the persuasion voters they are.”
“We showed up early in the primary in South Texas over and over again, trying to earn people’s votes and being very clear that we are working to earn their votes,” he said.
He recalled riding with the campaign in a parade in Brownsville during the primary, on the back of a pickup truck, while “people were going wild for James Talarico.”
Many of the Latino voters the campaign met described themselves as up for grabs. “So many Latino folks we talked to said, 'I am a free agent. I would like to see both sides tell me how they can make my life better, and then I’ll make up my mind,'” Mamo said.
The campaign spent “millions and millions of dollars of Spanish-language advertising across TV, digital, you name it,” he said. He added that Talarico’s background as a teacher and his focus on education also resonated with Latino families.
The effort paid off. The AP Voter Poll found roughly six in 10 Hispanic voters in Texas supported Talarico, compared with about three in 10 who backed Paxton.
Mamo said the result reflected a full-ticket effort that included Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa and South Texas House candidates such as Bobby Pulido. The pitch to Latino voters was direct, he said: “You might not have seen yourself as a Democrat two years ago. You might not see yourself as a Democrat today. But here is a group of people who are really sincere about trying to earn your vote and then work to make your life better. Come on board.”
A Model or a Protest Vote?
Talarico had pitched his campaign as a template long before Election Day. After his primary win in March, The New York Times reported that whether or not he became the next senator from Texas, Talarico believed his campaign could be a model for Democrats across the country as they try to find their way out of their political wilderness.
Mamo argues the result proves it. “I think Texas is on the presidential 2028 map. I think it’s a swing state,” he said. “We just proved the question of is it a swing state? Well, it just swung.”

...
Republicans see a more complicated picture. Brendan Steinhauser, a Republican strategist in Texas, said the biggest factor was the national environment and how voters saw Trump’s policies.
“The issues nationally weighed on everybody. And it dragged everybody down,” Steinhauser told Newsweek. “I think that’s the most important story from the election.”
He ranked problems with Paxton’s candidacy second, still giving Talarico credit: “Talarico did run a good campaign. He knew that he had to appeal to moderates, independents, some Republicans to try and convince them to give him a chance.”
“I think they ran a smart campaign,” Steinhauser said. “And I think they showed that the strategy [was] sound and he ended up winning big.”
National polling supports the caution. The AP Voter Poll found that while Democrats have at least a slight advantage on several major issues, including the economy and government corruption, the Democratic Party is not much more popular among U.S. voters than the Republican Party. According to the poll, just under half of voters have a "somewhat" or "strongly" favorable view of the Democratic Party, while about four in 10 view the GOP positively.
For Mamo, the lesson is about who the party nominates. “There is nothing more important than candidate quality,” he said.
Contact Newsweek editors for this story: Samantha Beech and Anthony Murray.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines