Hungary's Lack of Transparency Hurting Pandemic Recovery, Media and Health Officials Say

Hungarian journalists and health workers are calling for clearer COVID-19 statistics from the government, which they claim has been withholding regional information as infections continue to climb.

While the government's website lists the number of new infections, hospitalizations, ventilator uses and deaths, it does not break down the numbers by region. It also doesn't provide any visual tools such as graphs and maps, leaving many Hungarian journalists to try to create their own.

Illes Szurovecz, who works for Hungarian news site, told the Associated Press that if he and fellow journalists were not recording trends, "it would be virtually impossible to look back in Hungary today and see how the pandemic has gone."

When the government refused to release more detailed data, journalists began entering COVID-19 wards in hospitals to get their own, until the government banned it.

In addition to regional statistics, experts have requested data on how many hospitalized COVID-19 patients have been vaccinated.

Andras Falus, immunologist and professor emeritus at Semmelweis University in Budapest, told AP that a lot of Hungarians no longer pay attention to the data they are given because it has been so "inconsistent and unreliable" in the past.

"If there had been more data...the responses would have been much more effective," Falus said. "We could have known which cities and which counties had particularly virulent infections."

Budapest, Hungary, crowd
As coronavirus infections and deaths soar in Hungary, the country's journalists and public health professionals are demanding more detailed data on the outbreak from the government, with some experts saying that greater transparency might boost lagging vaccination rates. Above, people sit on the outside terrace of a bar in Budapest, Hungary, on April 24, 2021. Laszlo Balogh, File/AP Photo

Information is often hard to find in the country of over 9 million people, where infection rates have broken records and daily deaths per capita are among the highest in the world.

Although Hungary has secured vaccine doses from China and Russia in addition to those provided by the European Union, nearly a third of its adults still have not received a single shot. That hesitancy is something Falus said can be partly attributed to official communications about the pandemic released by the conservative government of Prime Minister Viktor Orban being "extremely poor, inconsistent and totally incapable of maintaining trust."

On Friday, the government's official coronavirus website reported 166 daily deaths, 6,884 new infections and 6,939 virus patients being treated in hospitals, 573 of whom were on ventilators.

Hungary's government defended its data practices, saying in an email that it was "setting an example by communicating on a daily basis epidemiological data."

"This is one of the reasons behind the cooperation of the population, successful disease control and the fact that we are the first in the EU in terms of booster vaccination," a government spokesperson wrote, adding that criticisms of its pandemic response were "politically motivated."

Yet last month, Hungary's National Authority for Data Protection and Freedom of Information asked the government to release infection data at the municipal level to mayors, writing that both local leaders and the public "need to know the figures in order to make informed decisions about how to protect themselves against the pandemic."

Similar problems were reported earlier in the pandemic in the Czech Republic, where mayors said they lacked details about the numbers of infected people in their communities that harmed mitigation efforts like distributing personal protective equipment.

Those issues were ultimately remedied late last year.

Trust of official statistics also has been a problem in Russia, where some experts have criticized official data on COVID-19 infections and deaths provided by the state coronavirus task force, arguing the reported numbers were likely an undercount.

Data analysts have pointed to inconsistencies in Russia's virus statistics that they say suggest manipulation. While the task force reported over 9.9 million confirmed COVID-19 cases and 287,180 deaths as of Friday—the highest death toll in Europe so far—a report released last week by the state statistics agency Rosstat put the overall number of virus-linked deaths between April 2020 and October 2021 to over 537,000—almost twice the official toll.

In Hungary, journalists and experts have often taken matters into their own hands in an effort to procure more detailed information, despite efforts by the government to withhold data.

After the government denied a freedom of information request earlier this year, news site filed a lawsuit to get detailed figures on daily hospitalizations, deaths and the number of those treated in hospital ICUs during previous surges.

A court in November ruled that the data had been unlawfully withheld, ordering its release.

Scott Griffen, deputy director of the Austria-based International Press Institute, said that his group "continues to condemn the Hungarian government's efforts to block media access to information on the pandemic."

Withholding such data was "fully in line with Orban's policy of controlling the message, restricting public debate, and hindering the ability of independent media to do their job," Griffen said.

Hungary's government has argued that virus testing is an ineffective means of controlling the pandemic, and that only mass vaccination can save lives. It also contends that the country's high official death rate is the result of broader criteria for attributing deaths to COVID-19.

During comments in Hungary's parliament this week, an opposition lawmaker asked Orban why the COVID-19 death rate in Hungary was so much higher than some of its neighbors.

"Anyone who says that more people die in Hungary than elsewhere is also saying that our doctors are doing a worse job," Orban said, "and I will defend them against your accusations."

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

COVID-19, Sputnik V, Budapest, Hungary
Although Hungary has secured COVID-19 vaccine doses from China and Russia in addition to those provided by the European Union, nearly a third of its adults still have not received a single shot. Above, a box of the Russian vaccine Sputnik V is prepared in Saint Margit Hospital in Budapest, Hungary, on April 14, 2021. Zoltan Balogh/MTI via AP, File