
...
By Martha McHardy
US News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Plans to install a $7,000 bronze "MAGA" plaque at a California library have sparked anger.
The plaque, which is meant to commemorate the Huntington Beach Central Library's 50th anniversary, features the slogan Magical, Alluring, Galvanizing, Adventurous. However, some residents see the plaque as a not-so-subtle allusion to President Donald Trump's "Make America Great Again" slogan—and they're not happy.
Newsweek has contacted the Huntington Beach Central Library for comment via email.
Read More on Politics
Why It Matters
The battle over the plaque is the latest flashpoint in a broader culture war as Trump campaign slogans and agendas continue to generate sharp divides well beyond Washington and into communities. Huntington Beach City Council has found itself in the midst of those debates, having advanced an agenda aligned with Trump's Republican Party politics and the MAGA movement.

...
What To Know
A conservative majority assumed control of the Huntington Beach City Council over a year ago. In January, Huntington Beach Mayor Pat Burns designated the city a "non-sanctuary" jurisdiction, aligning with Trump's mass deportation policies.
A year earlier, in 2023, the City Council voted to remove books deemed as having sexual content from the teen section of the library. The council also restricted who could give the opening prayer before council meetings and stripped the three liberals on the council of assignments on boards and commissions.
"Most of California has become liberal. Why can't we have an area for ourselves?" City Council member Gracey Van Der Mark told Reuters. "I'm just fighting for the residents that want a place that represents their values."
In the latest dispute, a commission voted unanimously to install the "Magical, Alluring, Galvanizing, Adventurous" plaque at the library on Wednesday despite hundreds of people protesting the move.
"More than 300 emails were against this [plaque]," Matt Szabo, a reporter for the Daily Pilot, which is published under the umbrella of the Los Angeles Times, wrote on Bluesky. He added that "most of overflow crowd" at Tuesday's meeting of the Huntington Beach Community and Library Services Commission were also against the plaque being installed.
Some 40 people spoke out against the plaque at the meeting, while six spoke in favor of it.
Former council member Natalie Moser was among those opposing the plan, calling the commemorative plaque "political propaganda disguised as a celebration."
"Libraries are spaces for knowledge, community and inclusion, they are not tools for political messaging yet this plaque inserts division, exclusion and control into a space meant to foster learning and unity," Moser said. "The use of a 'MAGA' acrostic injects partisan ideology into a public institution that belongs to everyone, not just a political movement."
Chris Kluwe, a resident of the city, said: "If you go forward with this plaque, you are putting MAGA front and center [in] our city. It is really important that you understand that MAGA as an ideology is destroying our country, OK? MAGA is the idea that trans people shouldn't exist. MAGA is the idea that you can let a billionaire come in and run our government and take our Social Security numbers to do who knows what, because there is no oversight," the Los Angeles Times reported.
Another resident, Barbara Richardson, added: "From far away, it looks like the plaque is celebrating 50 years of MAGA, as the word is dead center in the middle of the plaque. This is where one's eye is drawn, to a political slogan. Are political slogans even allowed to be installed on city buildings? Why shouldn't the city be neutral?"
After public comment, the board approved the plaque by a 6-0 vote. It is set to be installed outside the library, according to a staff report. Community and Library Services Committee Chairman Austin Edsell reportedly said at the meeting that the plaque would be paid for through private donations.
"It's a great library," Edsell said, according to the Los Angeles Times. "Honoring it and celebrating it in this way, I think it's very fitting for us."
Jeanne Paris, a member of the Community and Library Services Commission, added: "Make America great is not a racist comment."
The overflow crowd of opponents booed that sentiment, KTLA reported.
Huntington Beach Deputy City Manager Jennifer Carey said that City Council member Gracey Van Der Mark proposed the idea of the plaque.
"The plaque's design was a collaborative effort, incorporating input from various City Council members and the community," Carey said in an email Wednesday, according to the Los Angeles Times.
According to KTLA, the Magical, Alluring, Galvanizing, Adventurous slogan appears to be a new slogan created specifically for the plaque, with no ties to the official verbiage or brand identity of Huntington Beach or its public library system.
What Happens Next
The plaque design is expected to go to the City Council for final approval next week.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines