Getty Images. Newsweek/Illustration

Newsweek Contributors

By Newsweek Contributors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


On Saturday, a Border Patrol agent fatally shot ICU nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. The killing came only weeks after an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent shot Renée Good in the same city.

As protests over ICE tactics continue in Minneapolis and across the United States, does the agency need to be reformed, or abolished altogether? Newsweek contributors Nina Turner and Mark Davis debate:

Nina Turner:

Read More on Opinion

On New Year’s Eve in Los Angeles, Keith Porter was killed by an off-duty ICE agent. Then Renée Good, then Alex Pretti. Any federal agency that can murder civilians and have the administration lie about the events must be abolished and dismantled. It cannot exist. We can have a humane immigration system that secures our borders without people being snatched up off the streets—or murdered. If elected officials cannot figure out how to do that without ICE, they should resign and find a new job.

Mark Davis:

First to the matter of language. There have been no "murders," nor will there be charges to that effect. The questions of proper or improper ICE behavior in these shootings deserve thorough investigation. Meanwhile, the administration would do well to rediscover an emphasis on pursuing “the worst of the worst," a concept Trump won on. Deportations of violent criminals remain widely popular. For their part, Democratic leaders may issue whatever sharp criticism they like, but recklessly labeling their opponents Nazis and dictators inflames rather than resolves the problem.

Getty Images. Newsweek/Illustration

Turner:

Ask the families of American citizens Porter, Goode, and Pretti if their loved ones simply died or were murdered. I agree that there should be a full investigation conducted by local, state and federal officials, but the feds are unwilling to cooperate. The imagery of Nazis is indeed reckless, considering the tactics deployed by ICE are not foreign—they are all too American.

Davis:

Family members don’t determine legal definitions; our judicial system does. We should all favor a thorough investigation, but there is great irony in calling for local police establishment to suddenly be welcomed into the investigative process when the city and state have so brazenly refused to cooperate with the administration in its mission to enforce immigration laws in the first place.

Turner:

American citizens are being gunned down in the streets at the hands of ICE agents and, without proof, being labeled domestic terrorists by the Trump administration. Was that part of its mission? Trampling over the Constitutional rights of American citizens is a helluva way to "enforce" immigration laws. ICE has lost all credibility. It did not exist prior to 2003; we can live without this rogue agency. It must be dismantled.

Davis:

Putting Tom Homan in charge in Minneapolis is in part an admission that the administration's messaging had not been good. So we won’t be hearing any more about "domestic terrorists"—unless more are found amid the protesters. And meanwhile, the focus should return to finding and deporting dangerous illegal immigrants. When that happens, the public image of ICE will be restored, and stunts like shutting down the government over DHS funding will backfire.

Turner:

The people of Minneapolis are in charge, not an appointed federal official. The issue isn’t messaging—it’s that two people are now dead in that city. As of Saturday, ICE was responsible for 66 percent of the homicides in Minneapolis in 2026. If we are talking about dangerous people, it’s the ICE agents. Facts don’t care about feelings.

Davis:

The people are indeed in charge—the people of the United States elected Donald Trump to address our rampant illegal immigration problem. Policy adjustments are under way. The dangerous atmosphere stemmed from sanctuary policies that saw dangerous offenders free on the streets, and protesters who were far from peaceful.

Turner:

When a government agency repeatedly violates people’s First, Fourth and now Second Amendment rights, it is our duty as Americans to stand up to it and provide oversight. Since the government is not equipped to effectively oversee this agency, that agency must cease to exist. We all have a responsibility to demand that ICE is abolished.

Davis:

As this Minneapolis crisis hopefully subsides, there are lessons to be learned all around. If Minnesota Governor Tim Walz and Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey are now in a more cooperative mood, President Trump can direct ICE to refocus on the most dangerous names deserving of attention. One can hope that any protests will be peaceful, avoiding the agitation and rioting which have needlessly endangered communities. The administration and its critics would then do well to avoid heated rhetoric and wait for results of investigations into the shootings, which we all hope will now stop.

Nina Turner is a former Ohio state senator, a senior fellow at the Institute on Race, Power and Political Economy at the New School, and the founder of We Are Somebody.

Mark Davis is a syndicated talk show host for the Salem Media Group on 660AM The Answer in Dallas-Ft. Worth, and a columnist for the Dallas Morning News and Townhall.

The views expressed in this article are the writers' own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines