
...

By Jordan King
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Several media outlets have been slammed for describing the Hamas Chief Ismail Haniyeh as "moderate" in their reporting on his assassination.
Haniyeh, Hamas' Political Bureau Chief, was killed after attending the swearing-in ceremony of newly elected Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian, in Tehran, on Tuesday.
Reuters described him as "tough-talking" but "the more moderate face of Hamas," while Sky News called him "the pragmatic face of Hamas."
Read More on News
Indeed, when Sky News broke the story on TV, Special Correspondent Alex Crawford said: "He was also considered a very moderate leader for Hamas."
Haniyeh was a political leader of Hamas at the time of the militant group's October 7 attack on Israel, in which 1,200 people were killed and some 250 people, including women and children, were taken hostage.
Former Israeli Government Spokesman & International Media Advisor to the President of Israel, Eylon Levy, was one of several to criticize these descriptions.
Sharing a clip of Sky News' coverage on X, he wrote: "What is a 'very moderate leader' of an Islamist jihadist death cult that perpetrated the deadliest terror attack since 9/11 on October 7? Alex Crawford, what on earth are you talking about?"
Israeli journalist Daniel Rubenstein wrote: "Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh was a moderate because he gave Israel the option of peacefully dissolving itself, opening its borders to millions of hostile immigrants, changing its name to Palestine, incorporating Hamas's military into the state's army, and accepting Islamic law."
Dave Rich, an author who writes books about antisemitism, said: "If Ismail Haniyeh was 'moderate and pragmatic' as every media outlet claims, that means his open Jew-hate and repeated calls for the violent destruction of Israel are a 'moderate and pragmatic' position to hold. And what does that tell us about the status of Jews today."
Newsweek spoke to the Middle East Institute's Vice President for International Engagement, Paul Salem, to find out why some consider Haniyeh moderate.
He said: "It certainly and completely depends on the perceptions of who you talk to. Obviously, the Israelis and the U.S. consider all of Hamas, including its leadership as extremist, they consider the organization a terrorist organization. And many of them are not willing to enter into a conversation about 'is this person more moderate than the other?'"
But Salem, who is based in Beirut, went on to describe Haniyeh as a politician. "He's a hard-liner, no doubt, but he's a politician so he's a good negotiator and he's more pragmatic," Salem said.
Haniyeh, 62, first joined Hamas during the group's formation as a splinter of the Muslim Brotherhood in the 1980s, amid Israel's decades-long occupation of Gaza. He participated in the First Intifada uprising, was arrested by Israeli authorities and later released in 1992, after which he began to rise the ranks.
His position was bolstered during the Second Intifada of the early 2000s and he went on to briefly serve as prime minister of the Palestinian National Authority under still-serving President Mahmoud Abbas in 2006. Hamas' success in Palestinian legislative elections that year, however, led to a violent rift between Hamas and Abbas' left-wing Fatah party and Hamas ultimately seized control of Gaza the following year.
Haniyeh was promoted as the Hamas' leader in Gaza in 2014 and in 2017 was named head of the Hamas Political Bureau, becoming the most visible face of the group and regularly engaging in international diplomacy before and during the ongoing war in Gaza.
Dr. Nimrod Goren is the founder of The Israeli Institute for Regional Foreign Policies. He told Newsweek: "Anyone who is part of an organization that is viewed by governments all over the world as a terrorist organization—there is a limit of how moderate you can expect them to be.
"But, within the scope of Hamas, it is true that the views that Haniyeh had were more on the political side of things."
Goren added: "Within Hamas Haniyeh had a certain position, but within this organization which is not a moderate one."
Haniyeh had also been a negotiator for Hamas in ceasefire talks with Israel.
Salem said**:** "Haniyeh has also been the person that has been, among others, involved in the negotiation, based in Qatar.
"Qatar is a U.S. partner and a U.S. ally. The U.S. wanted Qatar to host Hamas, and effectively Ismail Haniyeh, in Qatar, so that indicates a certain American position or openness or tolerance toward him. So yeah, you'd have to say that, compared to [Yahya] Sinwar, certainly, he is much more political, much more moderate in that sense."

...
Salem was referring to Yahya Ibrahim Hassan Sinwar here, the leader of Hamas' military wing and seemingly the one "calling the shots" in general, according to all the Middle East experts Newsweek has spoken to.
He is the main figure that Israel holds responsible for October 7, with Defense Forces (IDF) spokesman Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari saying at the time: "Yahya Sinwar is the commander... and he is a dead man."
Khaled Elgindy, who directs the Middle East Institute's Program on Palestine and Israeli-Palestinian Affairs, told Newsweek he believes Haniyeh had a "moderating influence" on Sinwar.
For example, Elgindy suspects Haniyeh had a large role to play in Hamas dropping its demand for a deal with Israel to include the guarantee of a permanent ceasefire at the beginning of this month.
Salem went on to call Haniyeh's killing a "major escalation" that he believes "stops the negotiations to end the war—at least indefinitely."
He said this was exacerbated by Israel killing senior Hezbollah commander Fuad Shukr, just 24 hours before, in the Lebanese capital of Beirut in response to a deadly attack on an Israel-occupied town in the Golan Heights, where 12 children were killed at a soccer field, that was blamed on the Lebanese movement.
Salem said: "I think the major fallout is going to be military insecurity—that Israel, in the span of a few hours, killed a high-level Hezbollah commander, and did it in the capital of Lebanon and killed a foreign guest of the Iranians' joint inauguration of their presidency in the capital of Iran, Tehran.
"And I think that puts both Iran and Hezbollah in a position where, in order to respond—which they will insist on doing 'in kind', not more and not less as it were,—that would mean that they would respond probably picking a target in Tel Aviv, and trying to hit something there. Which then means, likely, that Israel would then respond to that and we might be headed for major uncontrolled escalation here. That's the fear and that's the real risk."
Iranian officials have already vowed to exact revenge against Israel, with Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei saying Israel had "prepared a harsh punishment for itself" over its alleged role in the killing.
On Wednesday morning, the Israeli Defense Forces said there is "no change" in the country's defensive guidelines.
IDF spokesperson Daniel Hagari said in a post on X, formerly Twitter: "There are no changes in the home defense policy. At this time, the IDF is conducting a situation assessment.
"If any changes are decided, we will update the public immediately on the platforms of the IDF and the Home Front Command. You must stay informed and act according to the instructions of the Home Front Command."
While no group immediately claimed responsibility for Haniyeh's killing, Israeli officials have repeatedly vowed to target Haniyeh and other Hamas leaders following the group's October 7 attack.
The Palestinian Health Ministry in Hamas-led Gaza has estimated that more than 39,400 people have been killed in the ensuing war.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines