Anna Rahmanan

By Anna Rahmanan

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Italy, the country where Benito Mussolini's fascist government once stripped Jews of their rights, has passed legislation combating antisemitism. It has embraced the very definition of anti-Jewish hatred that remains politically contentious in the United States, the self-proclaimed land of the free.

Lest the irony be lost, let us spell it out: a nation that once helped persecute its Jewish citizens has established a national legislative standard for confronting antisemitism, while Washington remains deadlocked over comparable legislation.

Italy's parliament approved the measure Tuesday by 147 votes to 93, with five abstentions. It adopts the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's IHRA definition, which covers hatred and discrimination against Jews, including certain attacks on Israel as a Jewish collectivity, while explicitly permitting ordinary criticism of Israeli policies.

Read More on Analysis

The legislation also establishes a national coordinator to oversee a three-year strategy involving education, monitoring antisemitic incidents, combating online hatred and protecting Jewish communities. It creates a database to track anti-Jewish incidents.

Perhaps most importantly, the law introduces no new criminal offenses: its significance lies in establishing a common standard that public institutions can use to identify antisemitism, coordinate responses and measure whether those responses work.

Related Story

A Love Letter to Thanksgiving: The One Holiday That Belongs to Everyone

A Love Letter to Thanksgiving: The One Holiday That Belongs to Everyone

Related Story

The TSA’s 25-Year Airport Security Charade

The TSA’s 25-Year Airport Security Charade

Related Story

Donald Trump’s Nuclear Dream Plays Right Into China’s Hands

Donald Trump’s Nuclear Dream Plays Right Into China’s Hands

Here's the awkwardness of it all, when it comes to America: Congress has repeatedly considered the Antisemitism Awareness Act, which would require federal education officials to consider the same IHRA definition when investigating discrimination complaints. An earlier version passed the House in 2024 but never became law. The renewed Senate proposal remains pending, despite 47 cosponsors from both parties. Italy has now officially legislated around a definition that Washington has spent years debating.

A brief history lesson makes the contrast more uncomfortable. In 1938, Mussolini's regime introduced racial laws excluding Jews from schools, professions and public life. Following Germany's occupation in 1943, Italian fascists assisted in their persecution and deportation. Approximately 8,000 Italian Jews were murdered during the Holocaust.

Nearly nine decades later, Italy's democratic institutions have legislated against the prejudice their predecessors once institutionalized.

But the European achievement should not be mistaken for national unanimity. Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's center-right coalition secured passage over objections from much of the left, which argued that the IHRA definition could constrain legitimate criticism of Israel.

The disagreement became personal Wednesday when Emanuele Fiano, a prominent Jewish figure in Italy's center-left Democratic Party, announced his departure. Fiano, whose father survived Nazi deportation, said his decision was irrevocable after his party opposed the legislation.

His resignation exposed a political fracture that extends far beyond Italy: the difficulty of separating disputes over Israel from the responsibility to protect Jewish citizens.

And the criticism hasn't been confined to Italy's borders: Amnesty International condemned the legislation, warning that it could discourage legitimate advocacy for Palestinians. Senior director Erika Guevara Rosas argued that fighting antisemitism and protecting free expression are "complementary obligations, not competing ones."

Amnesty is hardly a disinterested observer: its own Israeli branch was suspended in 2025 after disputing the parent organization's conclusions about Gaza. Apparently, even Amnesty's Israeli members were insufficiently aligned with Amnesty's position on Israel.

The same argument that has consumed Italian politics has an American microcosm in New York City. Mayor Zohran Mamdani, whose outspoken criticism of Israel has been a defining feature of his politics, made a point of distancing his administration from the IHRA definition adopted by his predecessor, Eric Adams, in 2025. Mamdani's September 2026 antisemitism strategy instead embraced a broader definition drawn from the Biden administration.

To be clear, America is hardly being asked to embrace some radical or untested definition. The IHRA standard has already been adopted by numerous American states, universities and government institutions, including Florida, Texas and New York. Washington's reluctance is all the more striking given how widely the definition has already been accepted on American soil.

Still, put the two countries side by side, and the weight of history suddenly feels, well, considerably heavier. Italy, which once used the machinery of government to identify and persecute Jews, has now committed that machinery to identifying and confronting antisemitism. America, which enshrined religious liberty in its founding principles, continues arguing over the language.

The difference may prove more symbolic than practical: Italy must still demonstrate that its law protects Jews without compromising free expression, and Washington could yet pass its own legislation.

But, for now, the country that once wrote antisemitism into its laws has found a way to write opposition to it into law. All the while, the country that made religious freedom a founding promise is still negotiating the wording.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines