Ivanka Trump is 'Shortsighted' in Supporting New Paid Leave Plan That Fails to Meet Family Needs, Advocates Say

ivanka, trump, paid, family, leave
White House adviser Ivanka Trump arrives at Hart Senate Office Building for a meeting with Senator Bill Cassidy (R-LA) February 13, 2019, on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C. Trump was scheduled to meet with a number of GOP senators to discuss paid family leave legislation. Paid family leave advocates said Trump's support for Cassidy's plan is "shortsighted." Alex Wong/Getty Images

This week, first daughter Ivanka Trump applauded an effort to present yet another paid family leave bill in the Senate—but several advocacy groups said the proposal fails to meet families' needs, with one leader calling Trump's support "shortsighted."

Trump, who vowed to fight for women, families and children as a senior White House adviser, commended Republican Senator Bill Cassidy, who at an AEI event on Wednesday announced he would co-sponsor a new bipartisan paid leave bill with Democratic Senator Kyrsten Sinema.

"I applaud @SenBillCassidy and @SenatorSinema for charting a bipartisan path forward on Paid Family Leave legislation." Trump tweeted. "Thank you both for your leadership. Working across the aisle we can deliver for American families! #PFL #PaidFamilyLeave"

I applaud @SenBillCassidy and @SenatorSinema for charting a bipartisan path forward on Paid Family Leave legislation.
Thank you both for your leadership. Working across the aisle we can deliver for American families! #PFL #PaidFamilyLeave https://t.co/sWDf4FKKTj

— Ivanka Trump (@IvankaTrump) April 3, 2019

Like several other bills and the paid leave proposal President Donald Trump included in his budget last month, the bill Cassidy and Sinema plan to introduce does not offer comprehensive reform. Cassidy remarked that his bill would provide leave for new parents who jointly make less than $70,000 annually.

Ivanka Trump's tweet praising Cassidy is "definitely shortsighted," Ruth Martin, vice president of the grassroots advocacy group MomsRising, told Newsweek on Wednesday.

"It's just missing the bigger piece and we need to focus on the bigger picture of the full range of families' needs," Martin said. "Parents absolutely need leave to care for the arrival of a new child but families also need to care for other family members."

Martin added that she would "really like Ivanka to talk about the full range of caregiving needs."

"I think it's an opportunity, that she could really use her pulpit," Martin said. "Certainly glad she's talking about needs that new babies have, but if we're really going to talk about what's going to help families, then we need to talk about the full range of caregiving needs."

Ellen Bravo, co-director of Family Values at Work, a network of coalitions in 27 states pushing for policies like paid family leave, said that Cassidy's proposal "badly underestimates" the financial strain on parents of new children in middle-class families and would exclude 75 percent of working people who need time off in order to care for someone else with an illness. She also expressed concern over Cassidy's remark that he was open to having cuts in Social Security and Social Security Disability Insurance to pay for the new leave.

"Let's make sure a paid leave program delivers for all of American families," Bravo told Newsweek when asked to comment on Ivanka Trump's tweet. "State coalitions have won bipartisan support for such programs, and Congress should follow their lead."

Sarah Fleisch Fink, general counsel and director of workplace policy at the National Partnership for Women & Families, said Cassidy acknowledged he understood that working people cannot afford cuts to their retirement benefits to fund paid leave, but that advocates remained concerned about a program that only provides leave for parents to bond with new children.

"I'm glad that people in both parties recognize the importance of national paid leave, including Ivanka Trump," Fink told Newsweek. "But in order for a paid family leave solution to really deliver for families, it needs to be comprehensive and affordable."

Ivanka Trump in February had a sit-down meeting with Cassidy and fellow Republican senators Marco Rubio, Joni Ernst and Mike Lee to discuss enacting paid family leave legislation.

"We are seeking to build consensus around policy that can garner enough votes to be passed into law and thank the Senators on both sides of the aisle who are working together towards that goal," the first daughter said in a statement at the time.

In March, when the president included six weeks of paid leave for new parents in his budget, MomsRising, Family Values at Work, and the National Partnership were similarly disappointed that it fell short of addressing the wider range of caregiving needs.

That day, Ivanka Trump tweeted that "adding the 1st national Paid Family Leave proposal included in any POTUS budget" demonstrated that "we continue to fulfill our pledge to American working families!"