
...

By Kate Plummer
Senior US News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
James Broadnax will soon take his last breath.
For the last 17 years, the convicted murderer has been on death row, with his execution date—scheduled for April 30—now fast approaching.
His punishment stems from a crime that took place two decades ago, when, in 2009, he was convicted of shooting and killing Matt Butler and Steve Swan during a robbery that he conducted in June 2008 with his cousin, Demarius Cummings, outside a recording studio in Garland, Texas.
Read More on News
The then 19-year-old confessed in media interviews at the time to killing the men, and a jury duly convicted him of murder. Cummings, meanwhile, was sentenced to life in prison without parole in 2011 and resides in the Coffield Unit in Tennessee Colony, Texas.
But with just under a month until Broadnax's execution, Cummings has made a startling declaration that has reshaped the narrative of the tragic events.
He said it was he, not Broadnax, who carried out the killings that secured his family member's fate.
"I was the one who shot the victims," Cummings said, according to a new written confession, seen by Newsweek.
Broadnax's attorneys are hoping this confession could be instrumental in sparing the prisoner.
A spokesperson from Broadnax's legal team said: "James’ lawyers will continue to do everything we can to stop his execution and to seek a new trial at which all of the evidence is fairly presented. At the same time, the team is preparing a clemency application to be submitted to the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles next week. We remain optimistic that the courts and Texas authorities will recognize the injustices in this case and take action to stop his execution."

...
The death penalty, legal in 27 states, has long been one of the most contentious instruments of the justice system.
In 2024, 25 death row inmates were executed, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. By November 2025, this figure increased to 47. Texas has carried out by far the most executions of all U.S. states, conducting 596 executions between 1977 and December 2025, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.
Dissenters have raised concerns about the humanity of execution methods, while proponents have said it is a crime deterrent and the ultimate consequence for the most serious of crimes.
The Confession
In his confession, Cummings said it had been his idea to rob Swan and Butler and that he had "obtained the pistol" used in the shootings.
At the time of the shooting, he had "previously committed and been convicted of other crimes" and, while both "high on PCP and marijuana," he convinced Broadnax "to take the blame for shooting the two victims."
"In fact, I was the one who shot the victims, not James," he wrote. "The fact that James received a death sentence for these crimes while I was the one who shot the victims has been weighing on my conscience, particularly as I have become more spiritual during my years in prison," he wrote.
"My hope is that James will not be executed for committing acts that he did not do."
The Appeal
Broadnax's lawyers also hope Broadnax will not be executed in light of the disclosure. In a legal filing to the Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, Broadnax's lawyers said Cumming's confession "fundamentally undermines the State's case for Mr. Broadnax's conviction and death sentence."
They added that Broadnax's confessions at the time happened when he was "drug-induced" and experiencing "psychological distress." The only DNA found on the murder weapon at the time belonged to Cummings, they added. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals told Newsweek it could not comment on pending cases.
Meanwhile, his attorneys have also filed an appeal to the Supreme Court to stay Broadnax's execution, which has attracted high-profile support. Prominent rappers Travis Scott, Killer Mike, and Young Thug, among others, have supported it.
Elsewhere, a petition calling on the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles and Texas Governor Greg Abbott to stop the execution has, at the time of writing, accrued over 10,000 signatures. Newsweek reached out to the board and Abbott's office by email to comment on this story outside of normal hours.
Eric Freedman, a professor of constitutional rights at Hofstra University in New York, told Newsweek: "What this case illustrates is that legal protections in the criminal justice system exist for a reason.
"And when they are ignored – as happens regrettably often in the death penalty system – it is hardly surprising that the system gets things wrong."
The jury that convicted Broadnax was comprised of 11 white people and one black person, something Broadnax's lawyers alleged in court filings was deliberate. Meanwhile, Broadnax's lawyers have questioned why prosecutors in the trial presented rap lyrics as evidence.
Freedman added: "In this case, the proceedings were marred by racism in the selection of the jury, by denial of Mr. Broadnax’s right to confront the evidence against him, and by the use of his rap lyrics as the basis for a death sentence.
"If the system had performed as it should, he would not now be facing the death penalty. The fact that another individual now admits he was the shooter dramatically reinforces that point."
Public Opinion
Broadly, support for the death penalty is falling in the U.S. Recent Gallup polling revealed that while a slim majority, some 52 percent, favor the penalty for people convicted of murder, this proportion has declined from 80 percent in 1994. The 52 percent support level is also the lowest support level since 1972, the pollsters found.
Death Penalty Clemency
Overturning death penalty cases in Texas is not without precedent.
In October 2025, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals (CCA) granted a stay on the execution of Robert Roberson just days before he was set to be put to death. This was the third execution date that his lawyers had been able to halt since 2016.
Roberson was convicted in 2003 of killing his 2-year-old daughter in a shaken-baby syndrome lawsuit. Roberson has always maintained his innocence and said his daughter's death was linked to complications from pneumonia.
The appeals court's decision came under Texas's 2013 "junk science" law, which allows for courts to reexamine convictions based on scientific evidence that has since been debunked.
Meanwhile, Republican Governors have recently commuted the sentences of individuals on death row. In March, Alabama Governor Kay Ivey commuted the sentence of Charles "Sonny" Burton. He was set to be executed by nitrogen gas on felony murder charges, which apply when someone is killed while a felony is being carried out, even if they did not personally commit the killing. His charge was reduced to life in prison without the possibility of parole following a campaign that Newsweek reported at the time.
Clemency powers have also been used at a federal level. Before leaving office, in December 2024, former president Joe Biden commuted the sentences of 37 death row inmates, converting their punishment to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
But "substantial obstacles" remain for Broadnax's case to be heard, Jeffrey Fagan, a professor of law with expertise in crime at Columbia Law School in New York, told Newsweek.
"Between the Texas courts and the Supreme Court’s sense of urgency to reach ‘closure’ and ‘finality,’ and the fact that the new confession has not been subjected to an adversarial process, Mr. Broadnax faces substantial obstacles to the halting of his execution. But perhaps, the specter of executing an innocent person has more salience today than in the past."
In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.
When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines

