
...
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
It’s tempting for Democrats to leap to James Comey’s defense, as Chuck Schumer and Ted Lieu did, among others. But that instinct risks turning the former FBI director into a liberal folk hero and whitewashing his serious shortcomings at the agency.
Democrats should think smarter in the face of the latest provocation. Bluntly, they need to "86" Comey from their attacks on the Trump administration and let justice run its obvious course.
The Trump administration's new case against Comey begins with a beach photo, a set of seashells and an argument over slang that the Justice Department now says amounted to a threat against the president, according to the fresh indictment.
Read More on Analysis
Comey posted an Instagram image in May 2025 showing shells arranged as "86 47". The numbers carry significance: "86" is a term common in the service industry to mean "get rid of" something, or perhaps someone, and Donald Trump is the 47th president.
The former FBI director deleted the post after criticism, denying any malevolent intention and writing: "I oppose violence of any kind so I took the post down."
This is all a thin reed for a criminal case and carries the overwhelming smell of a political revenge campaign against Comey, who investigated the Trump 2016 campaign for alleged links to Russia.
But Comey carries a stink all of his own.
He Sells Seashells
The Justice Department, with a straight face, says Comey "knowingly and willfully" threatened to kill or harm Trump by posting the image.
Prosecutors say a "reasonable recipient" would read "86 47" as a serious expression of intent to harm the president, according to the indictment.
Most reasonable Americans, assuming the premise that Comey had any prior knowledge of what "86" meant, would think of democratic and legal means for getting rid of a president: the ballot box or the Constitution.
Comey’s lawyers said they "will contest these charges in the courtroom and look forward to vindicating Mr. Comey and the First Amendment."
The public evidence described so far appears thin, and the case may face serious First Amendment hurdles. It lands in a charged context after the April 25 shooting at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner, where Trump and senior officials were evacuated and a suspect was later charged with attempting to assassinate the president.”.
American courts distinguish true threats from protected, crude or ambiguous political speech, and the Supreme Court required proof of at least recklessness in true-threat cases in Counterman.
Comey will see this one through and emerge from the other side without any help from the Democrats.
And they should be wary of redeeming a man whose actions may have cost them the White House back in 2016.
Comey’s Record Starts in 2016
Yes, Comey has baggage. Plenty of it, and on both sides of the aisle. Let’s start with Hillary Clinton's emails.
The Justice Department inspector general found that Comey concealed his plan for the July 2016 Clinton email press conference from department leaders and called his conduct "extraordinary and insubordinate," according to the OIG report.
The same report said Comey's unilateral announcement was inconsistent with department policy, violated longstanding practice and "usurped the authority of the Attorney General," according to the OIG.
The inspector general also found no evidence that Comey’s October 2016 letter to Congress was driven by political preference, but concluded that he "made a serious error of judgment."
Nate Silver’s FiveThirtyEight analysis concluded that the letter was "probably enough to change the outcome of the Electoral College," while acknowledging that it was not the only reason Hillary Clinton lost.
For many Democrats, Comey is not a neutral avatar of democratic stability. He’s a reminder of how elite procedural improvisation can warp politics while calling itself principle.
Republicans Have a Real FISA Grievance
Special Counsel John Durham's probe of the origins of Crossfire Hurricane, the sprawling investigation into Russian links with the Trump campaign, gave Republicans gunning for Comey ammunition, even if it fell well short of MAGA's expectations.
Durham didn't prove a grand anti-Trump conspiracy. But official reviews found serious FBI failures in the Russia investigation Comey led.
The Justice Department inspector general concluded that Crossfire Hurricane was opened with an "authorized purpose" and "adequate factual predication," and then-FBI Director Christopher Wray accepted that finding in a public response.
But the same FBI response acknowledged that personnel failed to comply with policies, neglected appropriate diligence and fell short of the standards expected of the bureau during the 2016-2017 period, according to Wray’s letter.
The clearest evidence involves Carter Page, a former Trump campaign adviser who was surveilled under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) after applications to the secret court in 2016 and 2017.
The inspector general examined four FISA applications targeting Page and whether they complied with FBI and Justice Department rules.
The bureau later adopted more than 40 corrective steps to improve FISA accuracy and completeness, according to the FBI.
The Justice Department also reached a $1.25 million settlement with Page in 2026 over his lawsuit alleging errors and omissions in those applications, and Page was never charged with wrongdoing.
It shows that Republicans aren’t hallucinating when they say the FBI used intrusive tools against a Trump-world figure while failing to meet its own standards, and all under Comey’s watch.
That is precisely why Democrats weaken themselves when they turn Comey into an anti-Trump mascot instead of admitting that his bureau gave Republicans real evidence to distrust him. Just as Comey had done to Democrats with Clinton's emails.
Dirty Vessel
Comey's later conduct makes the symbolism even worse.
In 2019, the Justice Department inspector general found that Comey violated FBI policies and his employment agreement by giving a memo containing official FBI information to a friend with instructions to share its contents with a reporter.
The Justice Department declined prosecution after reviewing the matter.
Comey's record doesn’t validate the seashell indictment or justify revenge prosecutions. But it does make Comey a dirty vessel for a clean argument.
A president's Justice Department should not use strained criminal theories against enemies when the public evidence appears weak. But Democrats should resist canonizing every Trump target.
To the American voter able to see beyond naked partisanship, the kind of independent mind both Democrats and Republicans need to persuade to win elections, there’s a clear pattern around Comey. And it's not a good one.
Hey gang, Carlo Versano here. I hope you enjoyed this article. As Newsweek's Director of Politics and Culture and editor of the 1600 newsletter, I'm keen to hear what you think. Now, Newsweek is offering a new service to allow you to communicate directly with me in the form of a text message chat. You can sign up and get a direct line to me, as well as the reporters who work for me. You can shape our coverage.
As a Newsweek member, we're offering this service to you for free. You can sign up below, or read more about how it works here. Let's talk!
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines