(L-R) Judge Aileen Cannon, President Donald Trump, Former Special Counsel Jack Smith

...

Robert Alexander

By Robert Alexander

Senior Crime & Court Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A federal appeals court has ordered Judge Aileen Cannon to decide within 60 days whether to lift her injunction blocking the release of Special Counsel Jack Smith’s second report on Donald Trump’s handling of classified documents, setting up another potential clash in the long-running case.

Newsweek contacted the DOJ for comment via email outside of normal office hours on Tuesday.

Why It Matters

A federal appeals court’s order giving Cannon 60 days to decide whether to release Smith’s still-secret report on Trump’s handling of classified documents matters far beyond the case itself.

Read More on U.S.

At stake is not only public access to a key account of how Trump allegedly tried to obstruct the retrieval of government secrets from his Mar-a-Lago home, but also the broader question of how much power a single judge has to withhold information of national significance.

The ruling tests the balance between judicial discretion, transparency and accountability at a moment when Trump was poised to return to the presidency—and the report may represent the last official record of one of the most consequential investigations in modern American history.

Left, Judge Aileen Cannon, center, President Donald Trump and right, former Special Counsel Jack Smith.

...

What To Know

How The Dispute Began

The case centers on whether the public should gain access to Volume II of former Special Counsel Jack Smith’s final report, which details his investigation into Trump’s alleged obstruction and mishandling of classified documents kept at Mar-a-Lago after leaving office.

Judge Aileen Cannon of the Southern District of Florida blocked release of the report in January 2025, citing the fair-trial rights of Trump’s co-defendants, former aides Waltine Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira, whose cases were still pending at the time.

Smith delivered his two-volume final report to Attorney General Merrick Garland on January 7, 2025, after being appointed special counsel to oversee two Trump-related investigations—one into election interference and another into the retention of national-security materials at Mar-a-Lago.

Volume I, dealing with the January 6 matter, was released publicly later that month.

Volume II, covering the classified-documents case, remains sealed under Cannon’s January 21 order barring the Justice Department from releasing any portion of the report outside the agency.

Challenges From Transparency Groups

Cannon dismissed the underlying indictment in July 2024, ruling that Smith’s appointment had been unconstitutional—a decision the Eleventh Circuit never reviewed after Smith withdrew his appeal following Trump’s election victory that November.

After the dismissals, the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request for Volume II, arguing that Cannon’s injunction was the only barrier preventing disclosure.

When the Justice Department cited her order in denying the request, the Knight Institute moved in February 2025 to intervene in the criminal case and asked the court to rescind the injunction, writing that “since the Court issued its injunction, the charges against defendants have been dismissed with prejudice… [and] there is no longer any justification for the injunction.”

A separate FOIA lawsuit by American Oversight in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia likewise seeks the report’s release, asserting that it would inform the public about “one of the most significant criminal investigations in American history.”

The New York Times and reporter Charlie Savage have filed a similar case in the Southern District of New York.

Appeals Court Sets A Deadline

On October 31, 2025 (filed November 3), a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit found that Cannon had shown “undue delay” in ruling on the Knight Institute and American Oversight’s motions.

The panel—Judges Jill Pryor, Elizabeth Grant, and Nancy Abudu—said it would “hold the petitions in abeyance for a period of 60 days to allow the district court to fully resolve the motions.”

Counting forward from that date, the 60-day deadline falls on or about January 2, 2026, as January 1 is a federal holiday.

The Eleventh Circuit’s order does not dictate an outcome but adds pressure on a jurist whose handling of the Trump documents case has drawn repeated reversals by the same court.

If Cannon fails to act by the deadline, the appeals court could revive the mandamus petitions or take further steps to compel a decision or release.

The directive underscores continuing scrutiny of Cannon’s management of the case.

The panel found she “had not ruled or conducted any other further proceedings on the pending motions,” describing the situation as part of a “pattern of delay” in the classified-documents matter.

The Knight Institute argues that releasing the report now would not harm any remaining legal interests, writing that “Volume II must be released because its suppression is no longer needed to protect any governmental interest.”

The Justice Department has not publicly opposed publication but remains bound by Cannon’s order until she rules.

Should Cannon again decline to lift the injunction, the dispute is expected to return to the Eleventh Circuit, which has previously limited her authority in Trump-related filings.

For now, the clock is running: unless the district court rules by early January, the appellate judges could decide the matter themselves—potentially opening the way for the long-sealed account of how investigators say Trump sought to prevent retrieval of secret papers from Mar-a-Lago to become public sometime next year.

What People Are Saying

Alison Gill, a Trump critic and legal analyst said in a blog post Monday: “It appears that gives Cannon 60 days to rule, after which the Circuit Court might take action. I imagine she’ll deny the motion, but not until day 60 (January 2nd). I’ll be keeping an eye on this one.”

Scott Wilkens, senior counsel at the Knight First Amendment Institute said in an email to Newsweek, November 3: “We’re pleased that today’s order recognizes that there is no legitimate reason for the court’s months-long delay in ruling on our request to make the special counsel’s report public.

“This report is of singular importance to the public because it addresses allegations of grave criminal conduct by the nation’s highest-ranking official, and should be made public without further delay.”

What Happens Next

Cannon now has until early January 2026 to decide whether to lift her injunction blocking release of Smith’s second report on Trump’s handling of classified documents.

If she grants the request from transparency groups, the Justice Department could soon publish a redacted version; if she denies it or delays again, the case will almost certainly return to the Eleventh Circuit, which has previously reversed her rulings in the Trump documents matter.

Meanwhile, separate FOIA lawsuits in Washington and New York seeking the same report continue, meaning that even if Cannon acts, further appeals or redaction reviews could push any public release of the document into later next year.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines