10

Loading video...

Dan Gooding

By Dan Gooding

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said the Supreme Court's decision Monday to revive key parts of President Donald Trump's election executive order covering mail-in ballots could undermine confidence in the electoral process, warning that the ruling risks "jeopardizing" the public's interest in a "fair and orderly election cycle."

In a sharply worded dissent issued Monday, Jackson accused the court's conservative majority of allowing the Trump administration to move forward with election-related initiatives while sidestepping fundamental questions about whether the president has the legal authority to impose them.

She argued the decision could inject uncertainty into the months leading up to the 2026 midterm elections and force states to grapple with potential changes to voting procedures while the underlying legal battle remains unresolved.

Read More on Politics

The White House described the ruling, which lifted a lower court bar on the executive order, as a "major win" for election security.

“These are commonsense measures that protect the security of mail-in ballots and ensure only Americans are electing American leaders," spokeswoman Lauren Bis told Newsweek in a statement. "This Administration will continue to lawfully enact the agenda President Trump was elected on – which includes the safety and security of our elections.”

A coalition of 23 Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia brought the lawsuit, including California, New York, Illinois, Pennsylvania and Michigan.

New York Attorney General Letitia James responded to the ruling on X, writing that it was a "painful setback."

"The right to vote is sacred, and no administration should be able to put that right in jeopardy," James said. "We're exploring our legal options."

Election workers sort ballots at Contra Costa County's election operations facility on May 27, 2026, in Martinez, California.

...

Santiago Mayer, Executive Director at Voters of Tomorrow, said in a statement shared with Newsweek that the number of young people now eligible to vote was a driving concern for the president.

"Since the 2024 election, millions of young people have turned 18 and are now eligible to vote. That is a terrifying reality for Donald Trump, and why he’s doing everything he can to silence the will of voters," Mayer said. "Today’s Supreme Court ruling is horrifying, undemocratic, and a stark reminder of what’s at stake in this moment. If we allow this authoritarian regime to continue unchecked, more of our rights will be stripped away. Democracy is fragile."

Related Story

Why Trump’s Mail-In Ballot Win Is Likely Too Little, Too Late

Why Trump’s Mail-In Ballot Win Is Likely Too Little, Too Late

What Did the Supreme Court Decide?

The Supreme Court granted the administration's request to temporarily lift a lower-court injunction that had blocked portions of Trump's March executive order on election integrity.

The order directs federal agencies to pursue a series of initiatives, including creating state citizenship lists, prioritizing investigations into ineligible voters, and issuing Postal Service rulemaking related to mail ballots. The justices did not rule on whether those measures are constitutional or lawful, concluding instead that the states challenging the order likely lacked standing because they had not yet suffered a sufficiently concrete injury.

Writing for the court, the majority said the challenged provisions are largely internal directives to executive branch agencies and do not presently require states to take any action.

The justices emphasized that future implementation efforts may still face legal challenges and stressed that Monday's order "does not mean that any measure taken by the Government to implement the Order will necessarily be lawful."

Jackson disagreed. She argued that election officials in the plaintiff states are already facing real-world consequences from the executive order because they must plan ahead for potential changes to election administration. The justice also warned that delaying judicial review could create confusion during an active election cycle, writing that the court was contributing to "pre-election chaos instead of quashing it."

She further contended that the ruling risks significant harm to states, election officials and voters by leaving major unanswered questions hanging over the administration's efforts to reshape election procedures.

"Granting this stay," Jackson wrote, "risks significant harm," including consequences that risk "jeopardizing the public's interest in a fair and orderly election cycle."

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by Justice Elena Kagan, also dissented. Sotomayor argued that the states face a sufficiently concrete and imminent threat from the executive order to challenge it now, rather than waiting for further federal action.

President Donald Trump speaks during an event in the Rose Garden of the White House on August 24, 2026.

...

Trump's Election Rules Order: What To Know

At the heart of the case is a broader fight over who controls federal election rules: the states that traditionally administer elections, or a Trump administration seeking a greater federal role in policing citizenship verification and mail voting.

The order, issued in March, directed the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to compile "State Citizenship Lists" identifying voting-age U.S. citizens and provide those records to states. It also instructed the Justice Department to prioritize investigations involving ballots issued to allegedly ineligible voters and ordered the U.S. Postal Service to pursue new rules for mail voting.

The mail-ballot provisions quickly became the most controversial part of the order.

Under the proposed framework, states that wanted to use USPS for absentee and mail voting would send voter information to the Postal Service, which would maintain participation lists linked to mail-ballot distribution. The proposal also contemplated new ballot-envelope requirements, including unique barcodes and additional tracking measures.

Related Story

How US Voting Looks Under Trump’s Finalized Election Plans

How US Voting Looks Under Trump’s Finalized Election Plans

Critics argued the changes amounted to a federal takeover of election administration, a role traditionally handled by states. Supporters said the measures were intended to prevent fraud and ensure ballots were issued only to eligible voters.

Opponents also warned that implementing new mail-ballot procedures months before a national election could create logistical problems for election officials already preparing for November voting.

Court filings cited concerns about redesigning ballot materials, updating voter guidance, retraining election workers and integrating new federal requirements into systems that vary widely from state to state. Those concerns featured prominently in Jackson's dissent, where she argued that election officials were already being forced to devote resources to preparing for potential changes while litigation remained unresolved.

The Trump administration has maintained that the order is designed to strengthen confidence in election results by verifying citizenship and securing mail voting. The White House has argued that barcode tracking, citizenship verification and closer coordination between federal agencies and election officials would help ensure that only eligible voters receive ballots and participate in federal elections.

The legal fight has largely turned on a separate question: whether states can challenge those plans before they are fully implemented.

What Happens Next

Monday's Supreme Court order did not decide whether the executive order is constitutional. Instead, the court concluded that the states likely sued too early because many of the alleged harms depended on future actions that federal agencies might or might not take.

“Today, the U.S. Supreme Court opened the door for the Trump Administration to try to make it harder for Americans to vote. But today’s decision was not a ruling on the merits, and this fight is far from over,” California Attorney General Rob Bonta said in a press release. “As I have said from the beginning, the U.S. Constitution gives the President no authority over how states administer their elections. We will continue to use every legal tool at our disposal to fight back against unlawful federal overreach whenever it occurs.”

The case now returns to the lower courts, where judges will continue considering the administration's appeal. While the Supreme Court's ruling is a significant procedural victory for Trump, the legality of the executive order itself remains unresolved.

Update 8/24/26, 11:15 p.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from Lauren Bis and Rob Bonta.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Gabe Whisnant and Sam Wilson.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines