10

Loading video...

Hollie Silverman

By Hollie Silverman

News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A judge has denied a motion by attorneys for Karmelo Anthony, the Texas teenager convicted of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during a high school track meet confrontation, seeking a new trial.

In an order signed Saturday, Judge B. Michael Chitty, said the motion was denied after review of records, briefs, arguments and evidence in the case.

Chitty was assigned to the case after Judge John Roach, who presided over Anthony's murder trial, was removed from handling the appeal proceedings Wednesday after a visiting judge granted a defense motion for recusal, according to Dallas news station WFAA.

Read More on U.S.

Anthony was convicted of murder in June and sentenced to 35 years in prison for the fatal stabbing of Metcalf during a dispute at a Frisco track meet in April 2025.

Newsweek reached out to Roach, Anthony's new defense attorney, and the Metcalf family via email for comment.

“We respect, and expected, the court’s decision denying the motion for a new trial," Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis told CBS News Texas on Saturday. "The jury’s guilty verdict stands, and we remain confident in the process. Every defendant has the right to appeal, and our thoughts and prayers remain with the Metcalf family in the painful wake of last week’s hearing.”

Karmelo Anthony's booking photo.

...

The appeal marked the first major challenge to one of Texas' most closely watched criminal convictions in recent years.

Anthony's attorneys argued that Roach should not continue overseeing post-trial proceedings, citing comments they say he made about the case after the verdict. They also raised concerns about evidentiary rulings and jury instructions presented during the trial.

Visiting Judge Sid Harle said he believed Roach could be fair but noted that was not the legal standard under consideration, WFAA reported. Harle subsequently granted the motion to recuse Roach from any further matters involving the Anthony case, meaning that another judge will now be appointed to hear arguments on Anthony's request for a new trial.

Austin Metcalf

...

What Prosecutors Said During the Trial

During closing arguments in June, prosecutors argued that Anthony's actions did not qualify as self-defense and instead amounted to murder. First Assistant District Attorney Bill Wirskye told jurors that deadly force must be "immediately necessary" under Texas law and contended that standard was not met in the confrontation that led to Metcalf's death.

"This is not self-defense, folks. It's murder," Wirskye told the jury, arguing that Anthony escalated the altercation after being asked to leave a tent belonging to another school's team.

He also maintained that a physical shove did not justify the use of deadly force, telling jurors, "You do not get to meet a shove with a stab, especially if you provoke the shove."

Prosecutors repeatedly described the stabbing as a "sneak attack" and argued that testimony from numerous student witnesses showed Anthony was the aggressor.

After the conviction, Wirskye publicly defended the outcome, saying the jury heard extensive evidence and delivered a unanimous verdict.

Following sentencing, Wirskye said the facts of the case were straightforward and maintained that the trial "was never about race" and "really never about self-defense." He said the prosecution believed justice had been served by the jury's verdict and the 35-year sentence.

Related Story

Karmelo Anthony Update as Judge Releases Trial Evidence Photos

Karmelo Anthony Update as Judge Releases Trial Evidence Photos

What Happens Next in the Case

Despite the denial of the motion, Anthony can still challenge his conviction through the Texas appellate system.

Legal experts have noted that new trials are granted infrequently, making the upcoming proceedings significant for both the defense and prosecution.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Sam Wilson.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines