King Charles III is due for a state visit with President Donald Trump to mark 250 years of American independence.

...

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


There’s a historical irony to King Charles III’s state visit to the U.S., marking 250 years since American independence from the British monarchy. And it’s not the obvious one.

Yes, it is amusing to see the king come to celebrate the independence of a country that broke free from its former master in such spectacular a fashion, a centuries-long humiliation that has seen the power dynamic turned completely on its head.

But there’s a more uncomfortable truth that exists outside the American imagination of British monarchs as tyrannical rulers, a vivid hallucination of Thomas Paine’s seen more recently in Lin-Manuel Miranda’s colorful interpretation of George III.

Read More on Analysis

Power, privilege, and insulation from accountability now operate in more aristocratic ways in the U.S. than in the U.K., overseen by an executive authority in the presidency that has grown more king‑like than anything exercised by the British monarch.

As President Donald Trump welcomes Charles to the former British colony, one could reasonably ask: which man is the true king here?

How the Executive Powers Diverged

Britain’s Charles III isn’t Charles I, the monarch whose reign and use of monarchical power fomented the English Civil War, which cost him his throne and his head.

A lot of history has passed since then, including the English Restoration, the Bill of Rights 1689, and numerous laws that reshaped and, crucially, constrained the monarchy over the following centuries.

The British constitution now makes the monarch the nation’s most ornate nonexecutive officer.

The Crown remains the head of state, but the Royal Family’s power to make and pass legislation rests with the elected Parliament, which is the true sovereign power in practice, led by the prime minister and their executive government.

Parliament could legally abolish the monarchy; the monarch could not legally abolish Parliament. Most royal prerogative and statutory powers are exercised on ministerial advice, with ministers accountable to Parliament.

It’s true that every Act of Parliament requires Royal Assent, but this is a constitutional formality, which hasn’t been withheld since 1708.

The U.S. Constitution, by contrast, vests executive power in the president, names him commander in chief, gives him pardon power, and requires him to “take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.”

That design always carried a monarchical anxiety at its edge; what has changed is the modern legal perimeter around the office.

In Trump v. United States, the Supreme Court held that a former president has absolute immunity for acts within his “conclusive and preclusive” constitutional authority and at least presumptive immunity for official acts.

And unlike Royal Assent, the president can, and often does, withhold their signature from bills passed up by Congress—an almost unthinkable act for a British monarch.

Charles’s authority survives by disuse; Trump’s office grows by use. Britain stripped the throne of governing power without stripping the pomp of its regal stagecraft, which retains its glistening splendor.

America stripped away the crown but kept the sovereign impulse inside an elected office.

Rise of the Ameristocracy

Then there’s the Ameristocracy.

For all the focus on British lords and ladies, and a landed elite who can trace their families back to the Norman conquest of England in 1066, there’s a deeply engrained aristocratic class in U.S. society.

All around is evidence of an entrenched and nepotistic elite held up by the vast self-sustaining infrastructure of wealth inequality, from political dynasties, to tech oligarchs, to finance masters, to Hollywood.

The same names and faces dominate, generation after generation. And data suggests it’s worse in the U.S. than the U.K.

The World Inequality Database data presented by Our World in Data show the richest 1 percent held 34.8 percent of U.S. wealth in 2024, compared with 21.3 percent in the U.K.

U.S. President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump pose with King Charles and Queen Camilla as they bid their farewells at Windsor Castle during the U.S. President's state visit, on September 18, 2025, in Windsor, England.

...

The House of Commons Library says OECD figures suggest U.K. income inequality is “slightly lower than in the United States,” even though the U.K. remains highly unequal by European standards.

The Ameristocracy is also laundered through meritocratic rituals.

A National Bureau of Economic Research paper found that children from families in the top 1 percent were more than twice as likely to attend Ivy-Plus colleges as middle-class applicants with comparable SAT or ACT scores.

The same NBER paper found that attending an Ivy-Plus college substantially increases the chance of reaching the top 1 percent of earnings, attending an elite graduate school, or working at a prestigious firm.

Britain displays hierarchy and an ancient class system that shapes public perceptions of it, not least in the U.S. But America's national mythmaking about the “American Dream” masks its own relationship with aristocracy.

'No Kings' and Impotent Republicanism

What's more, the recent “No Kings” movement against Trump’s assertive use of executive power, a crucial feature of his high-promising presidency, is revealing about the key difference with the real British monarchy.

Organizers said about 8 million people took part in March 28, 2026, "No Kings" demonstrations across roughly 3,200 events in the U.S.

The activist coalition has characterized its cause as a defense of a country that “belongs to its people, not to kings.” The slogan sounds antique, almost like it comes directly from the revolutionary period itself.

But it is aimed squarely at a 21st Century American president backed by Article II power, executive orders, emergency rhetoric, and a Supreme Court ruling that narrows the practical exposure of official presidential conduct.

The deployment of those kinglike powers, and Trump's attempts to stretch them to the very limits of the constitution, was a galvanizing moment for many Americans.

British republicanism, by comparison, remains oddly bloodless despite its own history of regicide. YouGov found in April 2026 that 64 percent of Britons wanted the U.K. to continue as a monarchy, while 24 percent preferred an elected head of state.

Overt and aggressive republicanism is almost gauche in modern Britain, because, despite real concerns about the aesthetics of royalty in an increasingly poor country, and its many undemocratic features, it has little real power.

That’s the inversion right now: American antiroyalism has a live political object with the power to act like a king of old. British republicanism mostly has a ceremonial one; an old man in a fancy hat who lives in a castle and shakes people’s hands for a living.

The Case for a King President

But it’s not authoritarian daydreaming to consider the value of a king president, despite the understandable and very American fears of the “No Kings” crowd.

Alexander Hamilton argued in Federalist No. 70 that “Energy in the Executive is a leading character in the definition of good government,” and the modern presidency remains the one national office designed to act with speed, unity, and visibility.

The Federal Register lists 225 executive orders signed by Trump in 2025 and 30 more in 2026. It’s a signal of decisive action.

After all, Americans vote for their presidents to do things, and to do them swiftly and effectively. Otherwise, why bother?

Congress can be too fragmented to govern and courts too slow to resolve emergencies before politics has moved on. For voters exhausted by legislative paralysis, robust executive power and a willingness to use it looks more like competence than tyranny.

But speed without accountability can turn republican energy into personal rule.

Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s dissent in Trump v. United States warned that “the President is now a king above the law,” which is overheated only if one assumes legal immunity and political discipline will always remain separable.

America at 250

America still has constitutional backstops: impeachment, a two-term limit, judicial review, and an amendment process requiring supermajoritarian consent.

Britain’s monarchy has endured partly because it has repeatedly yielded to constitutional reform, from the Bill of Rights in 1689 to the Parliament Acts limiting the Lords and the Succession to the Crown Act modernizing royal succession.

The real test at 250 is not whether America can denounce kings; it has always been good at that. Ask George III.

The question is whether the presidency can remain sufficiently energetic and free to govern like a benevolent king, yet bounded enough by democracy and the rule of law so it doesn't become the very thing the republic was founded to escape.


Hey gang, Carlo Versano here. I hope you enjoyed this article. As Newsweek's Director of Politics and Culture and editor of the 1600 newsletter, I'm keen to hear what you think. Now, Newsweek is offering a new service to allow you to communicate directly with me in the form of a text message chat. You can sign up and get a direct line to me, as well as the reporters who work for me. You can shape our coverage.

As a Newsweek member, we're offering this service to you for free. You can sign up below, or read more about how it works here. Let's talk!

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines