10

Loading video...

Billie Schwab Dunn

By Billie Schwab Dunn

Pop Culture and Entertainment Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Landman viewers have noticed similarities between the new show from Taylor Sheridan and his hit, Yellowstone, with some saying the writing is "lazy."

Set in West Texas, Paramount+ describes Landman as: "An upstairs/downstairs story of roughnecks and wildcat billionaires that are fueling an [oil] boom so big it's reshaping our climate, our economy and our geopolitics."

Billy Bob Thornton has been praised for his role as Tommy Norris, an oil crisis executive who tries to take his company to the top during an oil boom. He stars alongside Demi Moore, Ali Larter, Jon Hamm and Michelle Randolph. So far reviews of the show have been mixed from critics and everyday viewers—and now people online are pointing out similarities between the oil industry drama and the neo-Western.

Read More on Entertainment

Newsweek emailed a spokesperson for Sheridan for comment on Monday outside of normal business hours.

Billy Bob Thornton, Cole Hauser, Kelly Reilly

...

After the fourth episode aired, one person posted a thread to Reddit with the headline: "Reusing lines from Yellowstone in landman." They wrote: "When the Lawyer says 'I'll hang your f****** law degrees above my toilet' it's almost word for word what Beth said to Willa in Season 3 'I'll hang your diploma above my f****** toilet'.. Damn i like this show but that was lazy af [sic]."

People took to the comments to discuss the topic, with some people agreeing.

"I caught this too and was going to post something about it but you hit the nail on the head," one person commented.

"Agreed. It's just another Beth from Yellowstone rant, but with this chick. These scenes are getting old from Sheridan," said another.

A third person added: "I caught that too. Kinda off putting. Like you were so proud of that line in Yellowstone that you just HAD to use it again. I don't mind that Sheridan has multiple shows running at the same time, but if it's just recycled writing...kinda lame..."

However, others disagreed, with one person writing: "It's a line used by lawyers well before the shows."

"How exactly is that lazy writing? Do you think that this is the first time a line was used in two different shows?" someone else asked.

"I just took at [sic] as more of an easter egg than lazy writing. Future scripts will tell me more," a different Reddit user commented.

This isn't the only similarity between the two shows that viewers have noticed, as one person pointed out the fact that rattlesnakes have appeared in both programs, writing: "Don't forget the rattlesnakes. Taylor really wants you to know they have rattlesnakes in Texas."

Lots of Rattlesnakes

This refers to the fact that during Episode 3 of Landman, Tommy killed a rattlesnake that lawyer Rebecca (played by Kayla Wallace) was too spooked to run away from. And in Season 5, Episode 10 of Yellowstone, Rip (Cole Hauser) discovers a rattlesnake in Teeter's (Jennifer Landon) tent. After removing the viper, Rip and the other campers realized that they had pitched their tents on top of a snake nest.

This similarity was also noticed on a different Reddit thread that was started after Episode 3 of Landman aired, titled: "Landman | S1 E03 | Episode Discussion."

"Did Taylor Sheridan seriously just reuse the rattle snake scene from Yellowstone earlier this month?" one person questioned.

"Was that the same rattlesnake from S5 of Yellowstone?" another queried.

The show gets its inspiration from the 11-part documentary podcast Boomtown, from Imperative Entertainment and Texas Monthly, which told the story of the Texan oil industry. Boomtown host Christian Wallace worked as a co-creator with Sheridan on Landman.

Four episodes have aired so far, with reviews being mixed. On Rotten Tomatoes, the program had an average Tomatometer score of 76% at the time of writing, which is based on the collective opinions of film and television critics. A movie or show is considered "Fresh" if at least 60% of critic reviews are positive, and "Rotten" if less than 60% are positive. The Popcornmeter rating, which captures audience sentiment, is 67%.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines