
...

By Janice Johnson Dias
Sociology Professor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Fear of violence and crime have been hotbed topics on our national agenda for years, cresting and falling in perceived importance. Now, with public mass killings becoming a daily occurrence, people, specifically parents and policymakers, are again searching for solutions.
But most mass shootings aren't like what happened in Uvalde, Texas, a tragedy in which 19 young children and two adults were killed. Scientists define a mass shooting as any attack in which four or more people are hurt, which can include serial, family killings and gang activity. We are not overly concerned about serial killers, we are far more troubled by the acts of violence that target specific groups of people such as children, women and racialized minorities. Violence that occurs in public spaces like supermarkets and malls, and at schools disturb and unravel us.
Policies aimed at reducing crime sometimes ignore these concerns because lawmakers continue to focus on racialized minorities, especially Black boys and men ages 18 to 25 as the main perpetrators of crime. After all, they represent the population of individuals most likely to be incarcerated—and arrest rates remain our proxy for criminality. Data shows that in 2019 white people, who make up 76 percent of the population (including white Hispanics), accounted for 69 percent of total arrests and 58.7 percent of arrests for violent crime. Black people (13.4 percent of the population) make up 27.4 percent of the total arrests and 37.4 percent for violent crime
Read More
SCOTUS’ Conceal Carry Decision Will Endanger Black Men and Boys Most of All | Opinion4 min read

The Conversation About Guns Could Be Smarter | Opinion4 min read

Urban Voters Are Tired of Crime and Disorder. Will Progressive DAs Listen? | Opinion5 min read


...
But the perpetrators of some of the most egregious killings in the United States are not Black people; they are white men or boys. Researchers using data that included 242 cases of mass murder in the United States from January 2006 to May 2014 found that 24 percent of the perpetrators are white, and 19 percent are Asian, compared to only 9 percent of Latino and 6 percent of Black.
These data should challenge what we believe about criminality, but that is unlikely. Decades of research have cast Black people, especially men and boys as criminals and police as crime stoppers- which may explain why mayors, governors and federal executives have once again turned to the police for answers, believing law enforcement should better prevent, manage, and respond to crime.
Users of this logic have little or no understanding of the cumulative research evidence that demonstrates police are not trained, equipped or capable of stopping crime from occurring. Indeed, to summarize the past half century of social science research: police are best at addressing crime only after crimes have occurred.
Clamoring for police to be more proactive against crime is fundamentally a bad idea.
We need our police to remain reactive. Proactive policing increases the likelihood of further harm, especially to racialized populations. Proactive policing means increased police presence in Black and brown communities. We have enough knowledge to know that this does not produce positive outcomes.
Proactive policing in communities with historically poor relationships between the police and the public leads to greater confrontation, likelihood of arrest, and further strains the relationship between the police and racialized communities. Such actions can result in an intergenerational process where children learn that the police are to be feared, sometimes more than crime itself. Worse, proactive policing does not address the real problems. What we are experiencing today does not call for more policing of Black and brown folks. If policing of this kind is to occur, it needs to focus on young white boys.
But such efforts will likely yield similarly unfruitful outcomes. Because much of what we ask of police is outside their job requirements and beyond their capabilities. Police cannot stop gun manufacturers from making semi-automatic weapons. Police cannot parent the children whose families socialize their children to hate others. Police cannot pass legislation governing who is permitted to carry a weapon. Police are not equipped to deal with the mental health issues that most mass killers' experience.
If we want to limit fear and reduce crime, then we will need to address entrenched bigotries about who is a criminal. Our old lens and previous responses to crime are simply inadequate. Though we continue to look to the police for answers, we may need to look more within the institutions closer to us: families and schools. Because at the moment, our truest enemies remain our rooted biases.
Janice Johnson Dias, PhD is an Associate Professor of Sociology at John Jay College of Criminal Justice and author of Parent Like It Matters: How to Raise Joyful Change-Making Girls*.*
The views expressed in this article are the author's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines