...
By Jenni Fink
Senior Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Former Real Housewives of New York cast member Leah McSweeney's lawsuit against Bravo and executive producer Andy Cohen will proceed in a public courtroom after a judge shot down a request to move it to private arbitration.
Reality television producers on several shows have been accused of prioritizing the audience over talent on shows, leading to defamation claims and lawsuits over sexual assault and unsafe work environments. McSweeney, who spoke about her sobriety on the show, has accused producers of the show of preying on her alcohol addiction and trying to get her to drink to make for better ratings on the show.
In an Instagram story, McSweeney said the lawsuit is "emotionally and mentally draining," which is why she doesn't talk about it a lot on social media. But, she decided to post about it to acknowledge the "huge ruling" she just received in court. McSweeney acknowledged that many people said the claims wouldn't hold up in court and that it had been a long two years since she filed the lawsuit.
Read More on News
"Reality TV might look like entertainment, but behind the drama, there can be harmful misconduct that should never be normalized," McSweeney said.
In a ruling on Monday, Judge Lewis Liman criticized Bravo and Cohen for not raising arbitration during the hearings on motions to dismiss the case and for raising it only after trying to get the case dismissed. The judge speculated that arbitration was because of the "daunting specter of civil discovery" that would be made public in federal court. Since they tried to get the case dismissed through litigation, Liman said they waived their right to arbitration.
"Defendants are trying to have their cake and eat it too," Liman wrote.
Newsweek reached out to lawyers for Cohen, Bravo and McSweeney via email for comment.
Leah McSweeney's Lawsuit Explained
In February 2024, the former Real Housewives of New York City cast member filed a federal lawsuit in the Southern District of New York against Cohen, several producers, and corporate entities, including Bravo Media LLC, NBCUniversal Media, LLC, Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc., and Shed Media US Inc. The complaint alleges years of disability discrimination, retaliation, sexual harassment, and the creation of a hostile work environment tied to McSweeney’s alcohol use disorder and mental health conditions.
McSweeney claims that despite disclosing her history of sobriety and relapse before joining RHONY, producers repeatedly pressured her to drink alcohol on camera, discouraged her from remaining sober, and weaponized her relapse into a central storyline for ratings. The lawsuit alleges that when McSweeney attempted to maintain sobriety, she was mocked, labeled “boring,” threatened with lost pay, and ultimately sidelined from future Bravo projects.
...
The complaint details incidents during RHONY Seasons 12 and 13 and Real Housewives Ultimate Girls Trip in which McSweeney says she was denied reasonable accommodations, prevented from attending Alcoholics Anonymous meetings, and pressured to continue filming during panic attacks and family emergencies. She alleges that these actions contributed to severe emotional distress, suicidal ideation, and psychiatric hospitalization.
Beyond individual allegations, McSweeney frames her lawsuit as an indictment of a broader Bravo production culture that allegedly incentivizes excessive drinking, emotional distress, and public humiliation as entertainment. The complaint asserts more than 30 causes of action under federal, New York State, and New York City law, as well as a civil RICO claim alleging a coordinated enterprise designed to violate employment protections for profit.
Andy Cohen, Bravo's Response to Lawsuit
The defendants have forcefully denied McSweeney’s claims. In a letter sent to McSweeney that was obtained by People, Cohen called the lawsuit a “shakedown,” categorically denying allegations that he encouraged substance abuse or engaged in drug use with cast members. His legal team has argued that many of McSweeney’s claims are constitutionally barred, asserting that Bravo’s programming decisions are protected by the First Amendment as creative expression.
In court filings, Bravo, Cohen, and the production companies have argued that McSweeney was an independent contractor, not an employee, and therefore not entitled to many of the workplace protections she invokes. They have also emphasized that McSweeney voluntarily signed contracts acknowledging the nature of reality television production, including the presence of alcohol, emotional conflict, and editorial discretion in how footage is used.
A talent agreement reviewed by Newsweek states that the activities associated with the series may include "the consumption of alcohol by Artist and others" and asks the person signing it to assume the risks related to those activities. It also warns people that they may be exposed to "serious and extreme physical, emotional and mental stress and injury."
In May 2024, the defendants moved to dismiss the complaint in its entirety, arguing that reality television depicting alcohol consumption is central to the Real Housewives format and therefore shielded from regulation. A federal judge later dismissed several claims but allowed key disability‑based allegations to proceed, finding that alcoholism can qualify as a protected disability under federal and state law.
Why Is Caroline Manzo Suing Bravo?
McSweeney’s lawsuit is not the only one that Bravo's facing. Former Real Housewives of New Jersey star Caroline Manzo filed her own lawsuit against Bravo and related entities in New York State Court in early 2024, alleging that producers failed to protect her from sexual assault during filming of Real Housewives Ultimate Girls Trip in Morocco. Manzo claims that producers knew of prior misconduct by another cast member, yet continued filming and failed to intervene.
Manzo later amended her complaint, expanding allegations of negligence, retaliation, and unsafe working conditions. Her case parallels McSweeney’s, particularly regarding claims that Bravo prioritizes dramatic content over cast safety and discourages meaningful internal accountability.
Bravo has denied Manzo’s allegations and moved to dismiss her lawsuit, arguing that production responded appropriately and that some claims fall outside New York’s jurisdiction. Bravo hasn't aired the season of Real Housewives Ultimate Girls Trip that Manzo was on.
Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Defamation Lawsuit
Bravo isn't alone in facing scrutiny for allegedly prioritizing story lines over cast members. Last year, Marciano Brunette, a cast member from Vanderpump Villa, filed a defamation lawsuit against The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star Demi Engemann and the show’s producers. Brunette alleges that Engemann falsely accused him of sexual assault during filming, claims that he says were aired and amplified for dramatic effect, despite contradictory evidence.
Brunette told Newsweek in an exclusive interview at the time that production had reviewed footage from Vanderpump Villa, where the assault allegedly occurred, and cleared him of any wrongdoing. However, they still aired the storyline months later during season 3 of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.
Brunette’s lawsuit argues that producers prioritized a sensational storyline over factual accuracy, causing significant reputational and professional harm. Engemann has denied defaming Brunette and has moved to dismiss the case, with her attorneys arguing that her statements reflect her lived experience and are protected speech.
As these cases move forward, they are being closely watched by networks, talent, and labor advocates alike for what they may signal about the future of reality TV—and the legal limits of manufacturing drama for entertainment.
In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.
When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines