Newsweek/Getty

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Legal analysts reacted to a report by CNN that initial survivors of a U.S. strike against an alleged drug boat did not appear to have communications devices. The report comes amid immense backlash toward the Department of Defense (DOD) and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth in the aftermath of the attack.

Why It Matters

According to CNN, the reported absence of radios or other communications devices among survivors of the U.S. drone strike on a suspected drug boat in the Caribbean is driving renewed legal and political scrutiny of the deadly missile assault.

Read More on News

Some legal analysts and lawmakers argue that the survivors' inability to call for backup undercuts a key argument that targeting them in a follow-up attack was justified as a continued threat.

The Pentagon and congressional committees are now weighing whether the mission, ordered by Hegseth and carried out on September 2, violated the laws of war or the U.S. military's own protocols for engaging noncombatants and shipwrecked adversaries.

In an email to Newsweek, U.S. Special Operations Command Colonel Allie Weiskopf said in part, "We are not commenting on what ADM Bradley [Admiral Frank “Mitch” Bradley] told lawmakers."

Legal analysts react to a CNN report that initial double-strike survivors had no radio or communications devices.

...

What To Know

In September, U.S. military forces struck a vessel in the Caribbean suspected of transporting narcotics. After the first strike disabled the boat and killed several people, two survivors were reportedly observed clinging to the wreckage. According to multiple reports, a second strike—referred to as a "double tap"—was launched, resulting in the deaths of the survivors.

Amid questions on the lawfulness of targeting people rendered defenseless by shipwreck, debate has intensified following Bradley’s report to Congress that the survivors "did not appear to have radio or other communications devices," CNN reports.

Hegseth was initially reported by The Washington Post to have allegedly ordered U.S. forces to "kill everybody" on the suspected narco-terrorist boat, but recent testimony before Congress by Bradley contradicted these claims. "The admiral confirmed that there had not been a kill them all order and that there was not an order to grant no quarter," U.S. Representative Jim Himes, a Connecticut Democrat, said following a classified briefing, outlets reported.

Former Palm Beach County State Attorney Dave Aronberg told Newsweek on Thursday night that "The decision to kill survivors of the attack who were reportedly clinging to remnants of the boat appears to be a war crime in violation of domestic and international law. The bigger question is who ordered the strike? We’ve heard conflicting reports, but I would expect the truth to come out."

However, attorney and legal analyst Jonathan Turley also told Newsweek on Friday: "No, a finishing shot on a still floating vessel is not uncommon in war."

"There is a legitimate debate over the policy of striking these boats. However, in terms of the president's inherent constitutional powers, he has the authority to strike such vessels outside of the United States. Other presidents have asserted such authority. This includes President Barack Obama, who claimed in his 'kill list' policy to have the right to kill even American citizens anywhere and at any time based on his unilateral decision that they represent an imminent threat to national security," Turley continued.

"With respect to the laws of war, if the military had the authority to sink the boat, the commander could order a finishing shot or shots to complete the mission. It has long been common in war to deliver such finishing shots even when there are survivors on board or in the area of the vessel. The commander must not re-engage for the sole purpose of killing survivors. There does not appear to have been any such order. However, through history (including the famed sinking of the Bismarck in World War II), there have been finishing shots delivered in sea engagements to destroy vessels," Turley added. "The same is true with aerial attacks. It is common for the military to deliver multiple hits on a target if it is not completely destroyed despite the presence of wounded or survivors in the area. Once again, this does not mean the decision was correct or commendable in a given circumstance, but it falls within the discretion historically afforded to military commanders in achieving mission objectives."

"In the end, the laws of war reflect the fluidity and uncertainty of military engagement. The 'fog of war' is a reality of military conflicts, even with the added technological advances that we have today." In a follow-up email to Newsweek on Friday, Turley added, "We still have not seen the full video and confirmed the timeline of orders. That will help establish if the successive strikes were plausibly tied to the mission objective of destroying the still floating vessel and stop the salvaging of the drugs. It will also help establish that the boat and the drugs were indeed stil [sic] viable targets. The latter recovery of survivors by the military would indicate that there was no 'kill them all' policy with regard to survivors."

President Donald Trump, left, speaks as Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth looks on during a Cabinet meeting in the White House on December 2 in Washington, D.C. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

...

In a statement released Thursday, House Armed Services Committee Ranking Member Democrat Adam Smith and House Intelligence Committee Ranking Member Himes said in part that Hegseth is "ultimately responsible," and that the administration of President Donald Trump has placed members of the U.S. military in difficult situations that "push the boundaries of the law."

What People Are Saying

Ryan Goodman, chaired NYU law professor, on X Thursday in part, reacting to the CNN report: "This collapses the one 'argument' Hegseth had against it being war crime."

Former U.S. Attorney Joyce Vance, on X Friday: "The arguments Trump’s DoD is making about legitimate targets could be used against members of the American military. A sobering thought."

Republican U.S. Senator Markwayne Mullin, on X Wednesday: "Barack Obama killed hundreds of innocent civilians in drone attacks. Not a word from libs on 'war crimes.' Meanwhile, over 70% of Americans support @POTUS and @SecWar blowing up narco-terrorists who’ve poisoned our friends, family members, and neighbors before they reach our shores. These drug trafficking killers murdered more Americans last year than the U.S. lost in the entire Vietnam War. They don’t give a rip about American lives. I’m all for sending these killers to the bottom of the ocean."

What Happens Next

Lawmakers have called on the DOD to release the unedited footage of the deadly September 2 attack.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines